Critical Thinking in the Aftermath of 9/11 Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

Critical Thinking for Homeland Security

The capacity of a government to protect its citizens pivots on the ability of its leaders and high-placed specialists to think critically. Few times in history point so clearly to this principle than the 9/11 disaster. In 1941, the same year that the attack on Pearl Harbor occurred, Edward M. Glaser published a book titled, An Experiment in the Development of Critical Thinking. Glaser's practice of psychiatry was remarkable in that he dispensed with the Freudian deep dive into past events, pushing his patients to deal with problem solving in the present -- a critical thinking practice he called reality therapy. Many of Glaser's tenets were adopted by other disciplines because of their universal utility and association with positive results. Glaser defined critical thinking as, "A persistent effort to examine any belief or supposed form of knowledge in the light of the evidence that supports or refutes it and the further conclusions to which it tends." The gem in this quotation is: "the further conclusions to which it tends." This is the nexus at which facts, intuition, and imagination meet -- and sometimes collide.

A Failure of Imagination

In the final report of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, the commission asserted that the 9/11 attacks occurred because the measures taken by the U.S. government in the period from 1998 to 2001 "were failures of imagination, policy, capabilities, and management" ("National Commission," 2004, p. 9). Of these, imagination was the key variable that prevented the U.S. government agencies and the military from perceiving that the threat posed by al Qaeda in 2001 was not cut from the same cloth as the usual terrorist threat that had plagued the United States for literally decades. Given the information available to the government and the military at the time of the 9/11 attacks, it is fair to say that it would not even have been a stretch of the imagination, if you will, to perceive the extent to which al Qaeda radicalism had progressed. Prevailing thought at the time was insufficient to imagine "the new brand of terrorism[as] posing a threat beyond anything yet experienced" ("National Commission," 2004, p. 9).

The Critical Thinking Frame Juxtaposed

The Paul-Elder model of critical thinking model applies universal intellectual standards to the elements of thought. These intellectual standards are as follows: Clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, significance, breadth, depth, logic, and fairness (Paul & Elder, 1995, 2001). Through the application of the intellectual standards to the elements of thought, a person develops a habit of mind. In the briefest form, the elements of thought are: Purpose, question, information, assumption, interpretation, concepts, implications, point-of-view. The fundamental purpose in establishing a habit of mind that utilizes these frameworks is to improve thinking and improve the ability to think about thinking, or practice metacognition (Eichorn, 2012).

The relevance of critical thinking to matters of the government and the military are commonly noted. Indeed, Eichorn, (2012) suggested that the emergence of critical thinking as a metacognitive framework, circa 1941, was not coincidental and may well have may have been associated with the "chaos that was unleashed by aggressive, totalitarian governments. In his article introducing the changed curriculum at the Army Management Staff College, Eichorn underscored how much the old paradigm from the "fearsome stability" of the former Soviet Union had changed. Indeed, Eichorn argued that the Army now requires critical thinkers and stipulated that, according to the April 1997 draft of FM22-100, Army Leadership, critical reasoning is "one of the key conceptual skills leaders must possess starting at the junior leader level" (Eichorn, 2012). Presumably some time in the late 1990s[footnoteRef:1] Eichorn wrote: [1: The exact date that Eichorn wrote the curriculum introduction is unavailable, although the webpage information shows the last modification occurring on January 4, 2012. ]

"[T]he Army has an immediate and widespread need for people who can examine assumptions, work through problems and evaluate different courses of actions, consider the implications of situations, and look to not only first order consequences of actions, but second and third order consequences as well. In other words, the Army needs people who can think critically."

Clearly the U.S. Army recognized the need for critical thinking among its members and was actively working to embed critical reasoning skills in its quotidian practice. The 9/11 Commission unequivocally stated that, "At no point before 9/11 was the Department of Defense fully engaged in the…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Critical Thinking In The Aftermath Of 9 11" (2014, October 19) Retrieved October 25, 2016, from

"Critical Thinking In The Aftermath Of 9 11" 19 October 2014. Web.25 October. 2016. <>

"Critical Thinking In The Aftermath Of 9 11", 19 October 2014, Accessed.25 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Strategic Management of the U S Airline Industry After 9 11 2001

    POST-9/11 Management OF U.S. AIRLINE INDUSTRY Strategic Management of the United States Airline Industry after the 9/11/2001 Terrorist Attacks Strategic Management of the United States Airline Industry after the 9/11/2001 Terrorist Attacks Airlines in the United States have a long, complicated history in terms of management strategy that includes alterations due to technological advances, bankruptcies, economic downturns, deregulation and even presidential intervention, but none of these forces had the power to both destroy and restructure

  • Tourism After September 11

    Terrorist Attacks on New York City Consumer Behavior and Risk Terrorism and Consumerism in the Melting Pot How has September 11 Impacted Americans Economic Impact of terrorism Outlook for the New York Economy Examination of the Effects on Business Regaining Consumer Confidence Sampling Procedures Survey Construction Survey results Recommendations for Further Studies Survey of Consumer Patterns After The September 11 attacks on the World Trade Towers Survey Results presented Graphically Store Owner Interviews The Impact of the Terrorist Attacks on New York City: One

  • External Analysis of Southwest Airlines External Analysis

    External Analysis of Southwest Airlines External Analysis Southwest Airlines Will Southwest Airline's strategic plan continue to bring success in the new airline industry landscape? This paper sought to answer this question by examining the external increasingly consolidated environment in which Southwest competes. The review was conducted through application of Porter's Five Forces, a PEAT analysis, and a SWOT analysis. The report concludes that Southwest has gained ground and maintained stability, changing only as

  • Weapons of Mass Destruction

    WMD Annotated Annotated Webography: Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD) With the attacks on September 11th, 2001, the United States came face-to-face with the reality that our security strategy is far from impenetrable. To the contrary, the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, and more recently, the Boston Marathon bombing, proved that we are quite vulnerable to mass casualty events. Perhaps most worrisome is the concern that such an

  • Supply Chain Management Hypothesis Defined Concepts of

    Supply Chain Management Hypothesis defined Concepts of SCM and the evolution to its present day form Critical factors that affect SCM Trust Information sharing and Knowledge management Culture and Belief -- impact on SCM Global environment and Supply Chain management "Social" and "soft" parameter required for SCM Uncertainties This chapter aims to give an outline and scope of the study that will be undertaken in this work. The study lays out the issues faced by manufacturing organizations when it comes

  • Mexico and Convergence Between Terrorism International Terrorist...

    Mexico: Terrorism and Organized Crime The convergence in numerous means of organized criminal activities that include terrorism and drug trafficking is a developing concern in the United States and the entire world. Some professionals in this filed imply that the increasing number of cases of terrorism and organized crime groups are jointly coordinated and the trend is increasingly developing into a worldwide phenomenon (Rollins 2). These occurrences pose a great and

  • Perceptions of Terrorism and 911

    It's impossible to believe that a few furtive little characters armed with box cutters ho had no idea how to fly… could have maneuvered the planes like this (Sehmer). Still, when surveying media and scholarly materials about 9/11, the subject of religious fervor continues to come to the forefront. A contrasting, but negative impact of religion on society is the radical Islamic sects Al-Qaeda's plot and subsequent terrorist action against

Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved