Delta Is a Legacy Carrier essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

For example, Delta cannot readily expand to Canada by any means because of regulatory limits on foreign carriers.

Competition is a key driver of change in the industry as well. Firms behave in a manner similar to oligopolies, responding to each other's moves. This forces firms to be creative with respect to how they attract and retain customers. An innovation like loyalty programs is easily replicated by all competitors in the industry, as is characteristic of monopolistic competition. Innovation, therefore, only leads to short-term gains, and firms within the industry need to constantly innovate and improve in order to win steady profits.

The Competitors

There are three main classes of competitors for Delta. The first consists of the other legacy carriers -- United, U.S. Airways, American Airlines among them. These carriers typically have similar cost structures to Delta and similar business models. Each operates a hub or hubs around the country and utilized the hub-and-spoke distribution model. The firms in the industry have the same customer base and therefore find it challenging to truly differentiate.

The second group of competitors consists of differentiated players. Discounters like Southwest and JetBlue are in this category as are regional players like Alaskan Airlines. The third group of competitors for Delta are international carriers. Many international carriers have landing rights at major U.S. airports and compete with U.S. carriers on international routes.

Delta, after its merger with Northwest, now has the largest market share of any U.S. carrier, with 17.1%. The market is heavily diffused, with American holding 14.3% share, Southwest a 13.1% share, United an 11% share, U.S. Airways an 8.3% share, Continental a 7.6% share. Delta is the only major airline with a hub in Atlanta, the other hub there being AirTran. Delta therefore has a competitive advantage in moving people around the Southeast, where it has a very high concentration of flights feeding into Hartsfield-Jackson Airport. Of the main competitors, all but Southwest are legacy carriers and at this point Southwest is old enough to be in that category as well, albeit not as obviously as some of the others.

Financial Performance

Delta is increasing its revenues steadily, but its profits have been erratic. In the two recent years with massive losses (FY08 and FY06) the company has had significant write-downs that caused the losses. Only in FY2008, with high fuel prices and a recession, did the company have negative cash flow from operations. Investing activities and writedowns have proven the most harmful to cash flow and profit. In recent years, the company's cost of goods sold has increased significantly, from 38% in FY06 to a peak of 86% in FY08. This illustrates the role that fuel prices play in Delta's financial performance -- years with high fuel prices have very low operating margins. The company retired over $2.5 billion in debt in FY10, something that has helped to improve the balance sheet. Long-term debt stands at 30.52% of assets, down from a peak of 35.77%. Shareholders equity, unfortunately is a paltry 2% of the capital structure. This tells the story of a firm with financial difficult, given that equity was 31% of the capital structure in FY07. The company also has relatively poor liquidity, given a current ratio of 0.64.

All told, Delta's financial performance is mediocre. The company earned a profit last year on improved earnings, but overall remains without much financial strength. Equity is low, liquidity is low, and the company has experienced only limited profitability in the past five years, with only one year over $1 billion in profit in that span.

SWOT and Value Chain

Delta's strengths lie in the size of its route network, its international partnerships, its brand equity and its loyalty program. Ultimately, its competitors share these strengths. The company is weak financially, has high costs, and has not demonstrated any innovative management in recent years. Worse, there are few opportunities for Delta. If future consolidation is allowed by the Department of Justice, then this remains a possibility for Delta. However, the company is limited with respect to international growth and is probably saturated in the domestic market as well. The threats, however, are numerous, in the form of the economy, regulators and competitors in particular.

The value chain at Delta emphasizes the marketing and service elements, as well as inbound logistics. The latter is critical because of the importance of fuel hedging to the bottom line. The former are critical for enhancing capacity utilization. In particular, the Delta brand is a source of strength and if the company can build a stronger brand than its competitors, it is reasonable that it can win market share. Only marketing and service can build a brand superior to those of competitors.

Recommendations

Delta is in a difficult position. There are few opportunities in the environment that the company can take advantage of. There are also few options for sustainable competitive advantage -- Delta has this in Atlanta but that is only valuable to the extent that Atlanta is a superior hub to those of competing airlines. There are two recommendations, therefore, for Delta. The first is that the company should pursue consolidation domestically. The industry has a low level of concentration, so it is reasonable that Delta acquiring another airline would survive regulatory challenge. By building out scale and scope, a larger Delta would have a competitive advantage over its rivals until they too consolidated. Ultimately, Delta may need to work on ensuring that any acquisitions would be met with regulatory approval, and then pursue a smaller airline in order to build market share.

The second recommendation is to lower the fixed cost structure of the airline. The challenges that the company faces during times of suppressed demand illustrate that Delta does not have enough flexibility built into its operations. As a result, it should lower its fixed costs in order to improve its razor-thin margins. With little pricing power over most key inputs, Delta needs to ensure that its organization is highly-efficient, and that the result is better margins in the long run and the ability to adapt more rapidly to changes in market conditions.

The third recommendation for Delta is that it should reduce underperforming routes. These add to fixed costs, but are often unprofitable. This might mean surrendering competition in some markets. However, with few serious strategic options available to the firm, Delta must rationalize its operations even as it seeks a merger partner in order to keep its costs down and try to drive profits.

A fourth recommendation is that Delta focuses more on lucrative overseas routes. The company still mainly connects with Europe and some major centers in Asia. A South American presence is entirely reasonable that the company only flies to Johannesburg in the entire African continent. Overseas routes have lower competition levels and are therefore more profitable. Delta should build out this aspect of its business as much as possible.

Works Cited:

Cobbs, R. & Wolf, A. (2004). Jet fuel hedging strategies: Options available for airlines and a survey of industry practices. Kellogg School Of Management. Retrieved November 28, 2011 from http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=delta%20fuel%20hedging&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CDEQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.kellogg.northwestern.edu%2Fresearch%2Ffimrc%2Fpapers%2Fjet_fuel.pdf&ei=dWLUTsvAA8Li0QHkqcWeAg&usg=AFQjCNEQoiP1mQjuEnxlHegT2nwtQ9opQg&cad=rja

Jacobs, K. (2011). Delta says union rejection upheld. Reuters. Retrieved November 28, 2011 from http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/11/28/us-delta-idUSTRE7AR2EJ20111128

Meyer, G. (2011). Delta Airlines shifts fuel hedges out of U.S. benchmark. Financial Times. Retrieved November 28, 2011 from http://www.ft.com/international/cms/s/0/22323616-596f-11e0-bc39-00144feab49a.html#axzz1f4Bw4chJ

MSN Moneycentral. (2011). Delta Airlines. Retrieved November 28, 2011 from http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/invsub/results/statemnt.aspx?symbol=DAL

QuickMBA. (2010). Porter's generic strategies. QuickMBA.com Retrieved November 28, 2011 from http://www.quickmba.com/strategy/generic.shtml

QuickMBA. (2010). Porter's five forces. QuickMBA.com. Retrieved November 28, 2011 from www.quickmba.com/strategy/porter.shtml[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Delta Is A Legacy Carrier " (2011, November 29) Retrieved December 10, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/delta-is-a-legacy-carrier-47994

"Delta Is A Legacy Carrier " 29 November 2011. Web.10 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/delta-is-a-legacy-carrier-47994>

"Delta Is A Legacy Carrier ", 29 November 2011, Accessed.10 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/delta-is-a-legacy-carrier-47994

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Commercial Air Carrier America Airlines

    " (1999) Reported as being potential dimensions for disaggregation are those of "market, season, month, week, section of week, segment, and itinerary." (McGill and Ryzin, 1999) American Airlines experienced dramatic growth when other airlines were going bankrupt through increasing its capacity. American Airlines is reported as a prime example of an airline that grew successfully during the years that TWA and other failed. United Airlines held a strong financial position as

  • Protection Afforded to a U S

    Sometime the debtor is able to successfully reduce its liability and returns to profitability but quite often it returns to seek the court's protection again and sometime the end result is liquidation. Under Chapter 11 protections, the debtor gets an automatic protection from all creditors. The unsecured creditors cannot lay a claim on assets and secured creditors are also prevented from foreclosing on their collateral. A Chapter-11 company also gets

  • Qantas Virgin Blue Overview and Contents

    The steep reduction in revenue at Virgin Blue resulted in a reduction in their efficiency ratios. Given that the company continued to expand in size with only a minor expansion in revenue, their efficiency suffered. There is evidence of overcapacity, an issue that they have addressed in the interim with service cuts (Associated Press, 2009). Financial Stability -- Short-Term Both companies are liquid at present. Qantas, however, has seen the more

  • Post War Italy a Time of

    From the end of the War to the early 1950s, the Bank of Italy was credited for attracting and managing international aid, which helped bring the country out of a steep state of emergency and on the path of reconstruction. International aid came from Interim Aid, the Marshall Plan and the World Bank (Einaudi). Italy's Technical Redesign A substantial part of Italian construction legacy was destroyed during World War II and

  • Microeconomics Over the Last Few Years it

    Microeconomics Over the last few years, it is evident that the airline industry in the U.S. has been experiencing long standing as well as novel challenges (The American Antitrust Institute, 2012). These includes the increase in the price of fuel, slowing demand for air travel and pressures to expand globally. Consolidation among various airlines across the country is the most common remedy that most of the airline firms are applying. In

  • Organization Behavior Over the Last

    As they felt that his tactics were designed to reduce their wages and compensation for the benefit of the stockholders. This would change the way the firm is working with their unions and the current labor agreements that were in place. If Joyce had communicated more and listened to the ideas of employees, he would have been able to receive similar concessions from the arbitration. This would have allowed

  • Leadership Lessons Learned From Herb

    The transformation was so effective in the company that it eventually changed an entire industry as well (Lawless, 1998). Another aspect of leadership lessons learned from Her Keller include his tolerance for individuality and non-conformity on the part of his employees, and how the culture of the company became known as a haven for those who wanted to work hard yet also have fun (Lubans, 2009). Not every leader can


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved