Experimental Medicine in History Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Claude Bernard and Experimental Medicine

Claude Bernard is regarded as one of the first physicians, surgeons, to embrace scientific experimentation as a means of defining medicine. He believed that people who conducted statistical experimentation and stated statistically derived numbers without a definite purpose were in error. His belief was that there should always be a definite article that the experiment was looking for. He gave several examples of his belief in experimentation toward a goal in which he was able to relate his idea of the ridiculousness of just spouting numbers for their sakes. He relates the study of spinal root nerves that found that sometimes they were sensitive and other times they were not. He argued that this experimentation yielded nothing of value because it specified nothing.[footnoteRef:1] He next put forth the example of an individual who conducted a series of operations for the same condition and said that they resulted in a 40% mortality rate.[footnoteRef:2] Bernard again contended that this result meant nothing because it did not say under what conditions the person would be expected to live or die upon receiving the operation. Thus, his biggest complaint was that the so-called medical scientists did not provide true scientific findings that could either be verified or refuted. Their method was lacking. [1: Claude Bernard, An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine, translated by Henry Copley Green (New York: Dover Publications, 1957), 137.] [2: Ibid]

It is the tendency of people to believe in their own observations and trust the statistics that they have compiled. For example, the doctor who gave a 40% fatality rate for his particular surgery may have understood what made one patient live and one die, but he did not share this with the rest of the world, at least not according to Bernard. This misuse of statistics occurs currently just as much as it did in the past. One researcher gave the example of a recent United States census that found that there was a "high correlation between location of churches and violent crime."[footnoteRef:3] Whereas it is a surety in most people's minds that this fact does not exist in reality, the correlation can still be made. The reason for this is that at times people believe just because something correlates with something else they are related. It is poor science not to look farther and discover exactly what is going on to make the statistic seem to work. The reality is that there are a great number of churches, and that many different occurrences, such as violent crime location can be related to the location of churches because they are prolific. Bernard was saying much the same thing. He looked at the so-called scientific experiments that were being done with clinical cases and realized that because doctors were not applying the correct rules of scientific inquiry they were reaching false conclusion, or, at the very least, conclusions that meant exactly nothing when applied. [3: Rahul Dodhia, "Misuse of Statistics," Raven Analytics (accessed Nov 13, 2012) ]

His first argument is that statistics cannot be applied to medicine because it should be what he calls a "determinate" rather than an "indeterminate" science.[footnoteRef:4] He says that he realizes that much of medicine is conjectural, but that physicians should be working toward making it less so. The way that they can do that is with scientific experimentation rather than by believing that medical practice is somehow an art form.[footnoteRef:5] He gives another argument which is the use of the law of large numbers.[footnoteRef:6] His statement regarding this practice is that it is fine in an indeterminate science because they need large numbers to make any sense of what they are looking at many times. It is the argument against a small sample size that they are making, and this applies to most types of science where the numbers are large and can be accessed. However, he says that this does not apply, to any great degree, to medicine. Most of the time a physician is not dealing with a large number of cases. He or she must examine what is available to them and not be afraid to use this experimentation just because there are not a large number of patients with a particular disease of disorder. [4: Claude Bernard, An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine, translated by Henry Copley Green (New York: Dover Publications, 1957), 139.] [5: Ibid.] [6: Ibid,…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Experimental Medicine In History" (2012, November 15) Retrieved October 22, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/experimental-medicine-in-history-107188

"Experimental Medicine In History" 15 November 2012. Web.22 October. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/experimental-medicine-in-history-107188>

"Experimental Medicine In History", 15 November 2012, Accessed.22 October. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/experimental-medicine-in-history-107188

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • History of Surgery

    History of Surgery had been started from the prehistoric time with its appropriate technique and tools applicable during the age. There was no sophisticated care of hygiene and anatomic knowledge in the early days; the basic research was started using trial and error on every case and it had set a very strong basic which still makes sense and counts into modern practice. The following summary of history of surgery

  • History of Science Patronage Guiding Thinkers

    Therefore, it can be said that the patronage of Federico Cesi was important for Galileo because it placed him in contact with well-known scientists, it offered him the possibility to conduct research by consulting materials from a variety of fields, thus broadening the spectrum of his analysis, and, at the same time, it enabled him to conduct research that would probably bring him prestige and fortune due to the

  • Experimental Method Design Project

    Experimental Method Design Project Impact of different types of support systems on postpartum depression in women The research question under study is the degree to which support structures can affect the severity of the symptoms of postpartum depression. Other questions that may be considered include whether certain support structures are more valuable than others, such as the father of the child vs. family members and friends, or formal, professional supportive structures such

  • History of Modern Medicine Looking

    As evidence, one need look no further than contemporary political battles over certain medical procedures and, more generally, over the relationships among and between government, society, and medicine. Conclusion The history of modern medicine is not one that traveled linearly; it is a history that represents overlapping stages of earlier influences and more modern approaches. Nor did medicine evolve uniformly in the entire human community. In most cases, even the best

  • History of Project Management in

    A more definitive explanation is; "... A proposed explanation for a phenomenon." (Scientific Reference) a hypothesis should be able to be tested and functions as a directive for further research. In my research study for example, the hypothesis that was explored was that certain circumstances in different historical periods affect the development of the areas of expertise and their application to project activities. These circumstances include social and cultural movements;

  • Medicine Yogurt Consumption Lowers Colorectal Cancer Risk

    Medicine Yogurt Consumption Lowers Colorectal Cancer Risk Colorectal cancer is the third most common cancer in the world, with over a million people developing the disease each year (reviewed by Touvier et al., 2011; Aune et al., 2011; Pala et al., 2011; van Duijnhoven et al., 2009). The worldwide distribution of this disease is uneven though, with developed economies like North American and Western Europe generally having the highest prevalence rates.

  • History and Advancements in Diagnosis

    misconception in people that having an aneurysm means bleeding in the brain. An aneurysm is in fact a balloon-like swelling in a blood vessel that can affect any large vessel in your body; these larger vessels being arteries. Aneurysms pose a risk to health from the potential for rupture, clotting, or dissecting. It is the pressure of the blood passing through a weak part of the blood vessel that

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved