IBM Case Study Compare and Contrast the essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

IBM Case Study

Compare and contrast the project portfolio management approaches that IBM and Deloitte Consulting used to rank and select the projects for their respective portfolios.

IBM uses the Q-sort approach to manage their project portfolio. This approach enables them to analyze opinions raised by groups based on rankings given by each group member. The company embraced this strategy as a way of measuring the relationship between opinions of different employees. This approach seeks to find out correlations between the views expressed by individuals. The company uses this approach to prioritize their projects. This process involves rounds, which consist of people making assessments through group discussions. Each group member writes down a short description of a project on a card. The card is duplicated and distributed to group members. They hold discussions and improver their understanding of the project (Denney, 2005).

On the other hand, Deloitte uses the real options analysis. This method involves evaluating assets and projects based on concepts used to evaluate financial options. According to Deloitte, this approach has been useful in making capital budget decisions where there are significant uncertainties. Moreover, Deloitte has used this approach because the management has been flexible in adapting decisions concerning new developments. For example, the company has used the approach to acquire and merge, expand their facilities, prioritize R&D and contract valuation (Sanwal, 2007).

Unlike the Q. sort approach; this strategy is based on the acknowledgement that there is a critical comparison between business projects and financial investments. Deloitte's shareholders are not forced to purchase fixed shares within a specified period when stocks are unstable. On a similar perspective, there are options for each project. Shareholders at Deloitte are free to assess the options and purchase the stocks at an appropriate time. Deloitte's project to establish new units offer options of postponing construction in case the economy goes down. Construction of new units involves options of temporarily shutting down or abandoning some plants in order to reduce losses. This will pave the way to generate unexpected need for additional production. These options have been termed as real and have been distinguished form classic financial options (Cooper, Scott J. & Elko, 2008).

Evaluate and discuss the strengths and the weaknesses of both approaches.

A key strength of the real options analysis is the provision of insights used to manage projects in order to leverage flexibility while limiting downside risks. However, it has not been possible or practical to apply sophisticated techniques associated with this approach to value projects. On the contrary, this approach has demonstrated how simple methods such as MUA and ENPV can be employed to account for value options. This can be achieved through recognizing a wide range of decision infrastructure and improved accounting to cater for risks (Sanwal, 2007).

The Q. sort approach appears to be popular:…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"IBM Case Study Compare And Contrast The" (2013, February 11) Retrieved October 27, 2016, from

"IBM Case Study Compare And Contrast The" 11 February 2013. Web.27 October. 2016. <>

"IBM Case Study Compare And Contrast The", 11 February 2013, Accessed.27 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Marketing Communications Mini Case Study Marketing

    It is perfectly aligned with the message of the city and its reputation. Marketing Communications Question This approach to defining a price adjustment driven by the strength of the Canadian dollar is not as effective as concentrating on why Chrysler as a brand in general, and specific models in particular, are worth considering over competing brands and models. Only focusing on price tends to drive down the value of a brand

  • Study the Potential of Moving Bahrain Ministries it Services Into...

    Bahrain Ministries IT Service Studying the Potential of Moving Bahrain Ministries IT Services Into Private Cloud Computing Information technology (IT) is not only an important part of life for many people, but it is also a booming business (Amies, et al., 2012). One of the most significant steps IT has made in recent years is the advent of cloud computing. This is similar to the old style of storing information, where everything

  • Behavioral Finance Human Interaction a Study of the Decision Making...

    Behavioral Finance and Human Interaction a Study of the Decision-Making Processes Impacting Financial Markets Understanding the Stock Market Contrasting Financial Theories Flaws of the Efficient Market Hypothesis Financial Bubbles and Chaos The stock market's dominant theory, the efficient market hypothesis (EMH) has been greatly criticized recently for its failure to account for human errors, heuristic bias, use of misinformation, psychological tendencies, in determining future expected performance and obtainable profits. Existing evidence indicates that past confidence in the

  • Grandparent Caregivers Societal Antecedents as

    It is not always easy to keep childcare arrangements running smoothly and problems may arise from time to time. . In addition to these stresses, familial stresses might occur. For instance, Grandparents and parents may have different views about raising children. Parents' expectations of grandparents may exceed their resources. Grandchildren may not always obey or comply with grandparents' rules. Grandparents may not like the role of strict disciplinarian when discipline

  • E Manufacturing A New Link

    Ayers (2000, p. 4) describes a supply chain as "Life cycle processes supporting physical, information, financial, and knowledge flows for moving products and services from suppliers to end-users." A supply chain can be short, as in the case of a cottage industry, or quite long and complex as in the manufacture, distribution, and sales of automobiles. In fact, the automobile supply chain has its origin in the mining of the

  • Harmonizing Personal and Professional Balance Study of

    HARMONIZING PERSONAL AND PROFESSIONAL BALANCE: STUDY OF EMPLOYERS' FAMILY FRIENDLY POLICIES IN THE U.K. This study seeks to show that there are several different family friendly policies being utilized by employers in the U.K. And that these have been necessary for some time. The three main policies are: part-time work, flex-time (flexible start and finish times) and teleworking. All three of these policies are important for working mums and others that

  • Adult Children of Alcoholic Parents Compared With Adult Children...

    Adult Children of Alcoholic Parents Compared with Adult Children of Non-Alcoholic Parents I Situations Faced by Children of Alcoholic Parent(s) II Behavior of Children with Alcoholic Parent(s) II Hypothesis #2 I The Possibility of Developing Alcoholism on ACOA's II ACOA's have Lower Self-Esteem Compared to Non-ACOA's Comparing the Differences Between ACOAs and Non-ACOAs in Terms of Social and Intimate Relationships IV Protective Factors For Resiliency I Participants II Instruments Annotated Bibliography Children of Alcoholics Screening Test Are You an Alcoholic? Intimate Bond Measure Emotional

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved