Progress and Problems of Women in One Particular Occupation Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

Women in Corporate Professions

The American workforce is increasingly reflecting the changing American demographic. "Minorities" like women and people of color are occupying more management and leadership positions in the business world and corporate America. Their presence has begun to trigger changes in how companies are managed and in the broader areas of corporate culture.

However, in many ways, women in business continue to face unique problems because of their gender. This paper discusses how these difficulties continue to form barriers for women in the business world. The effects of gender stereotypes and expectations can be seen in virtually all aspects of employment -- from hiring practices to wages, from chances for advancement to retirement benefits. This paper examines how factors like unequal pay and a male-dominated corporate culture help to ensure that the American corporate world remains largely an enclave of men.

Unfair hiring and advancement practices

In a study designed to examine double standards in the hiring process due to gender, researchers found that women faced a double set of expectations. First, they had to be able to perform competently and exhibit typical masculine qualities such as "assertiveness." However, particularly when vying for high-status jobs, women are also expected to demonstrate "feminine" traits like empathy and tact. The women who did not have these so-called "feminine" traits were considered less suitable for employment. However, male applicants were not judged based on the presence or absence of these "feminine" traits (SooHoo).

Women who are hired face obstacles to advancement. Despite the greater number of women in the workforce, there still exists a clear sex segregation in employment. In most modern nations such as the United States, majority of the domestic work is still assigned to women. In addition, even in the paid labor force, many women are still assigned to supportive functions (Cejka and Eagly).

This socialization into gender roles has significant implications for women seeking positions in management. To begin with, despite the publicized success of CEOs like Hewlett Packard's Carly Fiorina and TLC Beatrice's Loida Nicholas Lewis, there remains a dearth of women in top managerial positions. All but a few Fortune 500 companies remain run by men (Book 28).

Gender Wage Gap

Such inequity is also evidenced in the gender wage gap. Despite pay equity laws and a growing awareness of gender discrimination and women's rights, salary disparities continue to exist between men and women across a broad range of occupations.

Despite these gains, however, differences in pay equity, access to power and decision-making status continue to exist between the genders. Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that women earn only an estimated 76 cents to the dollar that men are paid for the same jobs. Though they now comprise around half of the American workforce, majority of them are in lower-level positions. Women remain underrepresented in managerial and other decision-making posts. In fact, women occupy only 20% of middle management and a mere 5% of all executive positions (Bureau of Labor Statistics). The growing number of women in the workforce and their lack of access to positions of power thus pave the way for the increasing instances of sexual harassment.

The gender wage gap continues to persist across a diversity of occupations, after controlling for factors like age and education levels. Clearly, gender plays a key role in determining a person's salary.

Statistics further show that the gender wage gap is exacerbated by race. Thus, the median weekly salary of African-American women who worked fulltime was $429, compared to $669 for Caucasian men. Over a year, this means that a black woman generally earns $12,000 less than a white man for the same job (Bureau of Labor Statistics).

Part of the reason is the poor enforcement of wage discrimination laws. Funding for the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the federal body charged with bringing civil suits against discriminatory employers, continues to be inadequate. As a result, many women are dissuaded from pursuing legal action, due to the long wait and the cumbersome bureaucracy (Gibelman).

Many women face lower pay levels as soon as they are hired. Part of the reason is socialization, as some employers maintain that women do not negotiate for higher wages. However, analysts believe that the greater fault lies with the employers, who continue to ignore the Equal Pay Act.

Male corporate culture

Studies have shown that the culture in many corporations remain male. Leadership is equated with being "strong" and "masculine." Such expectations contrast sharply with the way men and women are socialized as they are growing up.

Though they are not as sharply defined or discriminatory as in other countries, American society has prescribed gender roles for men and women. This polarization is evident in daily life interactions, such as language. Studies of linguistic variations between men and women show that men are generally more direct and aggressive in their speech. Female speech is supposedly more polite, as women use more adjectives, interjections and conversational tag, and display a greater sensitivity. These differences, however, are a result of socialized gender roles (Eckert, 28).

In addition to different ways of communication, men and women are perceived differently when they talk. Studies have found that men are more likely to be opposing such as joking and teasing. Women, on the other hand, are more likely to be sharing. However, women who adopt male communication styles, they are less likely to be attended to and may even end up being perceived in a bad light (Page, 126).

This socialization into gender roles has significant implications for women in corporate leadership positions. To begin with, despite the publicized success of CEOs like Hewlett Packard's Carly Fiorina and TLC Beatrice's Loida Nicholas Lewis, there remains a dearth of women in top managerial positions. All but a few Fortune 500 companies remain run by men (Book 67).

There are many reasons for the small number of women in these positions of leadership. Esther Wachs Book points to a strict hierarchical bureaucracy and the lack of consultative communication between chiefs and workers as one reason. However, the main reason for this lack of women is a masculine corporate culture that remains resistant to change. Fortune 500 companies demanded CEOs who had a "tough, aggressive, taking no prisoners and winning at all cost" style (Book 67).

These same qualities, however, are considered unfeminine. Women who rose up the corporate ladder in the 1970s and the 1980s thus had to assume the similar traits of aggressiveness and toughness. Linda Wachner, for example, showed seemingly unfeminine ruthlessness when she assumed leadership of Warnaco in 1986. Wachner slashed costs and decimated the management staff from 200 to seven. She bought out companies and led a hostile takeover of her parent company (Book 71).

By showing she can muscle her way into big business, Wachner showed that she can act just like a man in a Fortune 500 corporate setting. However, this was exactly how she was perceived, as a man. To achieve corporate success at Warnaco, Wachner had to consciously assume male-associated traits and to constantly define her actions in terms of what other male CEOs would do.

The traditional business structure that characterizes Warnaco and most other Fortune 500 companies was adopted from military hierarchy after World War II. The lack of women in the military and the association with war thus resulted in a strong masculine culture in the business world.

Leaders were equated with military generals, who were traditionally viewed as direct, decisive and highly individualistic. For decades after the war, Connell writes, "commercial capitalism calls on a calculative masculinity ... Their combination, competitiveness, in institutionalized in 'business' and becomes a central ... In the new form of hegemonic masculinity" (Connell, 156).

Women, on the other hand, were seen as more adapted to teamwork and supportive behavior. In the militarized hierarchy of business, this translates women being relegated to supportive roles of administrative and secretarial positions. While there is certainly nothing wrong with these occupations, the perception of women as "supportive" is another obstacle for female executives who are trying to climb the ladder of corporate leadership.

Sexual harassment

The socialization and expectation that women will fulfill certain roles also gives rise to hostility for women who refuse to fit in the box. Many female executives who aspire to corporate executive positions are also routinely subjected to sexual harassment, even among Fortune 500 companies.

For example, in 1998, following a class action lawsuit for sexual harassment, financial giant Salomon Smith Barney set aside $15 million to enact policy changes to ensure a more hospitable work environment for women. This landmark settlement came after the brokerage firm was found guilty of practices like intimidation, explicit sexual talk, excluding them from meetings and hiring strippers for company entertainment parties held at the firm's infamous "boom room" (Antilla 28). The publicity devoted to this case helped to increase awareness, showing that sexual harassment can invade the boardrooms as well.

The presence of women in management is helping to address…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Progress And Problems Of Women In One Particular Occupation" (2004, November 07) Retrieved December 9, 2016, from

"Progress And Problems Of Women In One Particular Occupation" 07 November 2004. Web.9 December. 2016. <>

"Progress And Problems Of Women In One Particular Occupation", 07 November 2004, Accessed.9 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Career Counseling This Analysis of

    From the list of personal dimensions of development produced by the Association for Multicultural Counseling and Development (Arredondo et al., 1996), gender is the dimension most neglected or ignored, in spite of the fact that gender intersects with all other dimensions across cultures (see Hansen, Gama, & Harkins, 2002). Whether internal or external, one major weakness is the need to motivate more counselor educators to value career counseling and to

  • Women Representation in Law Enforcement

    In this regard, Lott points out, "Between 70% and 80% of police departments explicitly use norming of physical standards in their hiring practices. However, most of the departments that use objective standards do not enforce these rules. Women who fail to meet the absolute standards during academy training are unlikely to be failed out of the program" (p. 276). This lack of consistency in how these standards are applied

  • Women in the Workforce Training Plan Breaking

    Women in the Workforce Training Plan: Breaking the Glass Ceiling at Intuit Intuit revolutionized the accounting industry with innovative applications that assist with financial analysis and tax preparation. Since 1983 Intuit has been a proud leader providing our most famous products: Quicken and TurboTax to a wide variety of customers from individuals to small businesses and corporations. We have prided ourselves on providing an excellent workplace that sparks creativity and builds long-term

  • Career Counseling and Multicultural Students in School to Work Transition...

    Career Counseling and Multicultural Students in School-to-Work Transition Good career counseling always takes place within a cultural context, which is true regardless of ethnicity. Current theoretical models may not be adequate to explain the career behavior of racial and ethnic minorities. Vocational assessment has to be culturally sensitive, and only culturally appropriate tools should be used in vocational assessment. The goal of career counseling is to help clients make career choices that

  • Women in Nigeria the Rank

    The Ministry of Women Affairs had been present always; however it was a waning organization under the military rule. In some of the states the Ministry of women affairs was headed by men, but ever since the initiation of the democratic era, the Commissions are presently made responsible to the Ministry of Women Affairs since they are functioning collaboratively with civil society functionaries. (Nigerian women fairing well) Nigeria authorized the

  • Women and Iran

    Women and Iran Iran has long been an extremely conservative nation, greatly influenced by Islam and its teachings. What is usually regarded as common social practice in many parts of the world is regarded as a taboo in the Islamic republic. Traditionally an all male 'patriarchal' society, Iran has little to offer women in terms of roles and position. In accordance with traditional Muslim culture, women are restricted more to their

  • Women and Gender Bias the

    Under these circumstances, an ethical dilemma is born. Should society control its development or leave it to chance? And in the case that it should control it, which categories should it help? If the person in the above mentioned example is helped, we could assume that in a certain way, the person who was not helped because he or she already disposed of the necessary means, the latter one might

Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved