Psychological Disengagement Research Paper

Download this Research Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Research Paper:

Race and Academic Disengagement

Psychological Disengagement

Psychological disengagement represents a coping mechanism that preserves a person's sense of self-worth in the face of negative feedback. For example, a student may discount a bad grade on an exam by framing it as an aberration, thereby preserving a 'good student' self-identity. Employing this coping mechanism has specific advantages, such as allowing the student to be persistent about achieving academic success despite receiving negative feedback (Nussbaum and Steele, 2007). On the other hand, psychological disengagement could facilitate a student framing academic success as irrelevant to their personal goals and future. Such students tend to perform poorly in school and suffer from increased dropout rates (reviewed by Stephan, Caudroit, Boiche, and Sarrazin, 2011). In contrast, students who are academically successful tend not to disengage, despite receiving a negative evaluation, and self-perceptions of their academic competency suffers accordingly. Understanding the mechanisms that encourages psychological disengagement therefore has important implications for academic success.

Self-Determination Theory proposes that the nature of academic motivation can have a significant impact on the prevalence and type of psychological disengagement. Students motivated by an intrinsic desire to be successful, who have integrated academic success into their value system or simply feel it is important to succeed academically, tend not to disengage (reviewed by Stephan, Caudroit, Boiche, and Sarrazin, 2011). In contrast, students who are not motivated (amotivated) to succeed academically tend to be chronically disengaged from the academic domain as a whole. The nature of the motivation for academic success therefore plays an important role in determining the likelihood of becoming psychologically disengaged from academic feedback.

Another factor that influences academic disengagement is race or ethnicity. Major and colleagues (1998) compared levels of disengagement between African-American and Caucasian (White) students after they took a test designed to measure their intellectual abilities. African-American students appear to be primed to protect themselves from negative academic feedback, by relying on a generalized assumption that academic tests in the United States are racially biased against them. This was revealed by the finding that the self-esteem of African-American students was higher than their White counterparts after a negative evaluation, but only if first primed to think about the possible racial bias in the test. This suggests that African-American students are chronically disengaged from academic evaluations.

This theme of a propensity to disengage academically along racial lines was expanded to include Hispanics by Schmader and colleagues (2001), who found that disengagement can take many forms. This study revealed that the self-esteem of White students depends on academic feedback and therefore poor academic performance is a reliable predictor of disengagement. In contrast, African-American students were found to rely on devaluing the academic domain as a whole, because they tend to assume U.S. schools are ethnically biased against them. Academic performance was therefore not found to be a good predictor of disengagement in this population. The propensity of Hispanic students to disengage seemed to lie in between these two extremes, such that discounting of situation-specific negative feedback predicted disengagement, as did poor academic performance. These results were confirmed in part by a more recent study in the Netherlands, which revealed academic performance was a reliable predictor of disengagement for White students only (Verkuyten and Brug, 2003).

The research results discussed here suggests that a racially diverse student body in a New York City college would rely on psychological disengagement in different ways and for different reasons, depending on which racial group they identify with. Academic performance would be a reliable predictor of disengagement for White, but not African-American students. Although Schmader and colleagues (2001) revealed that academic performance did predict disengagement for Hispanics, this was true only for students with low academic performance. Given the relatively small study sample utilized in the present study, we predict that academic achievement will not be a significant predictor of disengagement for Hispanics.



Our sample consisted of 354 undergraduate students (58.5% female) from John Jay College in New York City. Of these, 116 were African-American, 121 Hispanic, and 117 White descendents of Northern Europeans. The age of the study subjects ranged from 17 to 35 (M = 21.01). The relative contributions from the different academic rankings were 47 freshman, 88 sophomores, 121 juniors, and 96 seniors. No information was collected that could identify the…[continue]

Cite This Research Paper:

"Psychological Disengagement" (2012, March 18) Retrieved October 28, 2016, from

"Psychological Disengagement" 18 March 2012. Web.28 October. 2016. <>

"Psychological Disengagement", 18 March 2012, Accessed.28 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Bandura A 1999 Moral Disengagement in the

    Bandura, A. (1999). Moral Disengagement in the Perpetration of Inhumanities. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 3(3), 193-209. Discusses the moral agency embedded in socio-cognitive theory and other self-regulatory mechanisms responsible for restraining immoral personal behavior. Focuses primarily on specific factors that lead to moral disengagement, in which individual root justification for immoral behavior. Author sheds light on the importance of having a moral agency and dangers of not have one. He

  • Aggression Comparison Between Two Races

    Race on Aggression Race and Aggression The roots of violence are of interest because of the toll it takes on the lives and minds of all citizens. Each year, an estimated 50,000 citizens die from violence in the United States and another 2.2 million will need medical treatment for injuries (reviewed by Corso, Mercy, Simon, Finkelstein, and Miller, 2007). Although the costs on a personal level are incalculable, the costs to

  • Racialized Body

    Race: Hazards and Benefits Corporeal Manifestation of Race Race represents the recognition of otherness, but in contrast to the many other ways that people choose to group individuals, the outward differences society associates with race is inherently unchangeable. This means that individuals who are persecuted or marginalized for something they have no control over find themselves struggling with an identity that has brought suffering into their lives and the lives of

  • Does Age Matter in Relationships

    Age Matter? Differences in age between romantic partners can elicit a number of reactions, depending on the age of the youngest partner. Hollywood celebrities, who marry much younger partners, are often made fun of in the entertainment media; however, if the younger partner is still a teenager, or worse yet, a minor, then the mainstream media may weigh in with their own brand of demonization directed at the older partner.

  • Relationship Between Self Esteem and Academic Intellectual Performance...

    Self-esteem and Academic/Intellectual Performance The research on the relationship between self-esteem and intellectual performance places has a lot of emphases on the gap of achievement, and is concerned with identifying factors that bring about differential intellectual results among other categories of gender. According to Antonio (1999) much focus has been given in eliminating the gap between intellectualachievement in the academic life of various male and female students across the world.

  • Teacher Stress

    Occupational Stress for Teachers of Students with Emotional and Behavioral Disorders" by Nelson and company discusses the increased associated risk of stress attributed to teachers working with students who have emotional and behavioral disorders. The article reviews the fact that occupational stress among teachers working with this particular demographic is most certainly greater than the average stress associated with the teaching profession. The literature review goes on to discuss the

  • Harry B Sturges K M & Klinger J K

    Harry, B., Sturges, K.M., & Klinger, J.K. (2005). Mapping the process: An exemplar of process and challenge in grounded theory analysis. Educational Researcher, 34(2), 3-13. Read the article listed above and provide your impressions. In one page, summarize the authors' experiences in conducting a grounded theory study in an educational setting. What were some of the challenges they faced? What are your thoughts in general on conducting qualitative research in the

Read Full Research Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved