" (Zias) the assumption was that these graves were not an unplanned military grave because the normal thing to do at the time was to bury soldiers in mass graves. The Qumran Cemetery was a well planned sight that was too well organized and it showed a great deal of coordinated planning and use over time.
The women and children discovered on the Qumran sight could have put doubt in the theory that the sight was in fact Essene. But there were other theories to would justify a woman or child being buried at that particular cemetery. "Elder poses some interesting solutions to this difficulty, based upon the literary and archaeological evidence found at the cemetery of Qumran, in that celibate males lived and were buried in Qumran whereas non-celibate males and females and their families lived at Ain Feshkha and Ain el-Ghuweir even though no cemetery was found at the former site." (Zias) and other philosophies exist such as the graves of the women and children could simply have represented the death of someone that passed away during a holiday visit could explain the discrepancy.
There was an overwhelming amount of evidence to discredit the notion that there were women and children living at the Essene site. For starters, the direction of the graves of the women and children were not consistent with the direction of the male graves implying that these graves may have been put there at a different period or they did not hold the same significance to those who maintained the cemetery. Other details such as the dental remains showed that the individuals who lived in the Essene community were males that migrated to this area later in age so there were few to no children in the community and the children in the graves were not...
"The surprisingly little wear on the posterior dentition was clear evidence of a differing diet and environmental history between the two groups. Therefore, it is clear from the dental evidence that the males interred in the main cemetery were not indigenous to the desert region but came to the site after their formative years, thus explaining the differential between the contrasting dental pathologies seen in the two populations." (Zias) These and other factors all point out that the Qumran sight was used by the Essene all male community whether they were celibate of not and the discovery of women and children at the cemetery sight does not change those facts.
Discussion
This report was a review of the journal article called "Celibacy: Confusion Laid to Rest?" written by Joe Zias and published in the Dead Sea Discoveries journal, volume 7 in the year 2000. The author confirmed that the Qumran Cemetery was used by a known all male celibate Essene community who may have been the holders of the Dead Sea Scrolls discovered in caves near Qumran. The author's approach was to resolve outstanding concerns that arose because there were controversial discoveries made of women and children in the cemetery considered male celibate. By using archaeological, anthropological, historical and literary disciplines to prove his theory, the author did an outstanding job pointing out some of the nuances of the Qumran cemetery, historical burial techniques and the Essene community.
Works Cited
Zias, Joe. "Celibacy: Confusion Laid to Rest?" Dead Sea Discoveries Vol. 7 (2000): pp. 220-53. Retrieved on 3 Nov. 2004, from www.joezias.com/QumranCemetry.htm.
Peer Review
But a multi-disciplinary approach is always useful. 4. Should archaeology students be required to take ethnographic methods classes? Yes, because that knowledge is necessary in understanding the cultures of local communities or indigenous people on whose territory an archeologist studies sites and artifacts. Local communities are also affected by excavations and the knowledge about them is essential for doing archaeology. 5. Why is timely publication important? The data are already old! One of
In this way, material culture and social paradigm were embedded in the cultural mythology of any given time in the past. This once again emphasizes the inaccuracy of the Christian myth as the sole archaeological paradigm of research. The recognition of myth and indeed the "other" in the past provides the archaeologist with a fresh view of the past, which is much richer and wider than might previously have been
Archaeology After brushing off all the debris, the team of archaeologists lifted the time capsule with a great sense of satisfaction and placed it on the research table. Inside we found five items that will enhance our understanding of life in the United States of America, circa 1969. The first two items we unearthed from the time capsule were bundled together using a piece of rough twine. The larger of the
Archaeology The Archaeological and Historical Consequences of the U.S. Invasion of Iraq Like any war, the war waged against Iraq by U.S. forces has resulted in the destruction of more than just military sites. Many of Iraq's cultural sites, including museums, libraries and significant ancient sites have been the victims of destruction. According to article by National Geographic News, "although U.S. bombs have spared most sites and treasures, some ancient locations have been
Archaeology The issue at hand with respect to Olmec pottery relates to the chemical composition of the pottery sherds, and the implications that these chemical compositions have for the trade of pottery among the people of the Mexican highlands. There are two positions posited in the readings, and Sharer (2006) does a good job of explaining the issue. All of the researchers use instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) to determine the
Recent Great Discovery in Archaeology: The Lost Golden City of Luxor in EgyptFor decades, experts had examined the pottery of the Moche, an early civilization of farmers and fishermen who flourished between 1,900 and 1,200 years ago along Peru�s north coast (Benson, 1-22). Throughout the years, archeologists have actively undertaken exploration projects to discover some of the renowned ancient civilizations and various aspects of man, including the remains of early