Robert A Dahl's on Democracy Believe We Book Report

Download this Book Report in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Book Report:

Robert A. Dahl's On Democracy believe we are on an irreversible trend toward more freedom and democracy - but that could change.

Dan Quayle (1947 -), 5/22/89

The term, democracy, means many things in popular discourse. One has only to turn on the television to hear presidential speeches, public discussion, or news commentators espousing its virtues -- "goodness," "virtue," and "liberty," almost as if the term has become synonymous with freedom itself. In fact this trend is becoming so prevalent, that I find myself checking with each new release of Microsoft Word, if ther term "democracy" might yield "freedom" in its thesaurus.

Although today's average rabid patriot (a species won't to exclaim statements like, "Our boys are over there in eye-rak fighting for our freedom!") may see nothing amiss with this notion, there remains the issue of the tremendous disservice that results from the simplistic coupling of the two terms, for if democracy is a form of government to be touted, championed, and, allegedly fought for, it follows that the masses of men and women who do "tout" should also be informed about its features in some depth.

Robert A Dahl's book, On Democracy, does exactly that. According to the front flap blurb at the beginning of the 1998 hard-cover edition:

Robert Dahl begins with an overview of the early history of democracy. He goes on to discuss differences among democracies, criteria for a democratic process, basic institutions necessary for advancing the goals of democracy, and the social and economic conditions that favor the development and maintenance of these institutions.

Indeed, Dahl discusses democracy in clear, simple terms, covering basic themes, issues, and questions of the governmental system as practiced, and not by dipping into complex themes of theory and discourse.

This makes the book tremendously readable, be one rabid patriot or no.

The theory that Dahl does cover is at its most basic, and is focused on democracy, not as a merely "American" institution, nor limited to the United States as context. Instead, he covers the basics of what "constitutes a democracy" in general, which he often illustrates with "group/organization" examples or examples from other nations. He comes up with the following criteria:

What is democracy?

Democracy provides opportunities for:

Effective participation

Equality in voting

Gaining enlightened understanding

Exercising final control over the agenda

Inclusion of Adults

Interestingly, Dahl's style in the book often explains democracy, not in the terms of a single large national representative government (especially, as one might expect, the American), but by instead using descriptions of how a small group of people or an organization might arrange itself to accommodate the equality and "voice" of all of its members. This, I believe, he does, in order to separate the definition of democracy from its popular associations.

Indeed, Dahl uses an extremely basic (in terms of example) method to come to his main criteria for true democracy, namely "political equality." He writes:

to be democratic the government of a state must satisfy a standard. Let me put it this way: Full inclusion. The citizen body in a democratically governed state must include all persons subject to the laws of that state except transients and person[s] proved to be incapable of caring for them (78).

Although Dahl does simplify his description of democracy, this does not prevent him from illuminating some of its practical difficulties. For example, he acknowledges the fact that, although all individuals hold an equal vote, a small group of "elites" may control the agenda. If this is the case, democracy is flawed, saying, "...if some members are given greater opportunities than others for expressing their views, their policies are more likely to prevail" (39). Further, he acknowledges that this, especially due to financial factors, can result in the formation of organized groups that, in effect, appropriate a great portion of the public "voice" and use it to further their own interests and agendas (especially in consideration of today's special interest groups).

It is this from this idea that Dahl's most interesting argument in relationship to the United States springs, that this control of the agenda, through a greater "voice" (which arises out of inequalities in opportunity, financial resources, and education, to name a few) cripples democracy.

Further, he raises the issue of the role of non-homogenous groups of people (either a growing, or an original factor in many countries, including the United States), and the relationship of race/ethnicity/minority status to "voice" and achieving adequate representation in that voice.

Dahl also touches on…[continue]

Cite This Book Report:

"Robert A Dahl's On Democracy Believe We" (2003, December 18) Retrieved December 10, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/robert-a-dahl-on-democracy-believe-we-161367

"Robert A Dahl's On Democracy Believe We" 18 December 2003. Web.10 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/robert-a-dahl-on-democracy-believe-we-161367>

"Robert A Dahl's On Democracy Believe We", 18 December 2003, Accessed.10 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/robert-a-dahl-on-democracy-believe-we-161367

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Economic Democracy Comparing and Contrast

    Instead Dahl assumes the notion that it would be best to have "a system of economic enterprises collectively owned and democratically governed by all the people who work in them," meaning that he differs from the notions of Okun and the Friedman's by proposing something radically different to promote the ultimate goal of democracy (Dahl 92). Neither equality nor freedom is necessary to fix the relationship between the economy and democracy, but rather a completely different

  • Americans National Identity Rests Largely Upon Ethnic

    Americans' national identity rests largely upon ethnic kinshi common language. shared political ideals. religion. federal law. The American ideal of equality promotes the idea that all citizens should be equal in their standard of living. is fully consistent with individualism. does not include the idea that everyone is entitled to fair treatment under the law. has helped minority groups to achieve their goals. has always been fully implemented in U.S. history. The American political culture includes all of the following ideals except liberty. equality. self-government. individualism. economic

  • Nursing Scholarship Program in Pursuing

    One of the invaluable experiences I had working with underserved communities was between the years 2007 and 2008, when I was fortunate enough to be involved as a volunteer conducting missionary work in Atotonilco, Mexico. As a community nurse for the mission, I was responsible for taking the glucose level, vital signs and educated the general public about diabetes and heart disease. I have found my work in Mexico

  • Creative Writing in English Singapore

    Over time British rule affected every aspect of life in Singapore including education. Gupta (1998) explains that "The educational impact of the political developments was essentially a move from the private to the public. As the British government became increasingly directly involved in Singapore, an education policy began to develop (Bloom 1986, Gupta 1994). In the early years education was largely in the hands of private organisations, churches, and charitable bodies.

  • Autonomy Metaphor Men as Leaves

    (Leaves, 680) Similarly Whitman informs us: Stop this day and night with me and you shall possess the origin of all poems, You shall possess the good of the earth and sun…there are millions of suns left, You shall no longer take things at second or third hand…nor look through the eyes of the dead…nor feed on the specters in books, You shall not look through my eyes either, nor take things from me.

  • Political Science Domhoff Shapiro

    Putnam (2000) suggests that trust already exists within societies, when clearly there is evidence that it does not exist, and that people are not confident in who is in control (Domhoff, 2005). Putnam (2000) argues that it is important to have a strong and very active and aggressive civil society within the United States to consolidate democracy. Many of the traditions of independent civic engagement have been lost according

  • Interventionism From the Perspective of Realism vs

    interventionism from the perspective of realism vs. idealism. Realism is defined in relationship to states' national interests whereas idealism is defined in relation to the UN's Responsibility to Protect doctrine -- a doctrine heavily influenced by Western rhetoric over the past decade. By addressing the question of interventionism from this standpoint, by way of a case study of Libya and Syria, a picture of the realistic implications of "humanitarian


Read Full Book Report
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved