Same-Sex Marriage An Idea Whose essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

But those sections can no longer be used, as they were by the California Supreme Court, to provide gay couples with the liberty and privacy rights of equal access to civil marriage," as the Court did previously (Feldblum 2009).

Despite the presence of Bishop Robinson at the inaugural, President Obama himself has been admittedly less stalwart in his support of gay marriage: in response to a "1996 Outlines newspaper question on marriage" Obama said "I favor legalizing same-sex marriages, and would fight efforts to prohibit such marriages…There was no use of the phrase civil unions" as he advocates today, as a replacement for gay marriage (Linkins 2009). Obama has had to tread a careful line, given that many Catholic, blue-collar workers and Latino voters are often social conservatives -- these voters are often 'swing' votes for Democrats. All were his most difficult constituencies to win during the election, and he has little to gain, given that many gay voters vote for more liberal candidates (Newman 2009). Although they may be disappointed in his withdrawal of support for gay marriage, unlike Latino voters on the opposite side, gay voters are unlikely to withdraw their support for Obama. Obama clearly wishes, at the national level, to avoid polarization and divisiveness. Yet even while Obama backs off his earlier position, and despite the setback of Proposition 8, this cannot diminish the slow and steady gains in Iowa, Vermont, Massachusetts, New York, and elsewhere.

When examining the rhetoric of those advocating Proposition 8: "What was particularly striking about the campaign to enact Prop 8 was the extent to which proponents went out of their way to claim that the new provision would not take rights away from gay couples. In a Frequently Asked Questions document, for example, they raise the question, 'Will Proposition 8 take away any rights for gay and lesbian domestic partners?' only to reply: 'No. Proposition 8 is about preserving marriage; it is not an attack on the gay lifestyle. Proposition 8 does not take any rights away from gays and lesbians in domestic partnerships. Under California law, domestic partners shall have the same rights, protections, and benefits' as married spouses. There are no exceptions. Proposition 8 will not change this'" (Feldblum 2009). In other words, even anti-gay crusaders had to tread carefully in their rhetoric -- an odd victory, but a victory of sorts for advocates of same-sex marriage, and a harbinger of hope that a more vocally mobilized gay rights opposition might be able to strike Proposition 8 down in the future, if they are able to explain its terms and the suffering it causes with greater clarity to the electorate.

Works Cited

The battle over inter-racial marriage in the United States (2009). Religious Tolerance. Retrieved June 6, 2009 at

Boston, Rob. (2009). Freedom for me but not for thee: Marriage and Mormons in California. The Humanist, 69(1), 35-36. Retrieved June 6, 2009, from ProQuest

Religion database. (Document ID: 1622272771).

Couples who are/were not permitted to marry. (2009). Religious Tolerance. Retrieved June 6,

2009 a

Feldblum, Chai. (2009). The selling of Proposition 8. The Gay & Lesbian Review

Worldwide, 16(1), 34-36. Retrieved June 6, 2009, from GenderWatch (GW) database.

(Document ID: 1632645171).

Garrison, Jessica; Cara Mia DiMassa & Richard C. Paddock (2009, November 5). Voters

approve Proposition 8 banning same-sex marriages. The Los Angeles Times.

Retrieved June 6, 2009 at,0,1545381.story

Goodnough, Abbey. (2009, June 3). New Hampshire. The New York Times. Retrieved June 6,

2009 at

How marriages have changed. (2009). Religious tolerance Retrieved June 6, 2009


King, John. (2009, March 29). Same-sex marriage debate heats up in New York. CNN.

Retrieved June 6, 2009 at

Linkins, Jeff. (2009, January 13). Obama once supported same-sex marriage unequivocally.

The Huffington Post. Retrieved June 6, 2009 at

Newman, Brian. (2009). A matter of faith: Religion in the 2004 Presidential Election.

Presidential Studies Quarterly, 39(1), 155-157. Retrieved June 6, 2009, from Platinum

Periodicals database. (Document ID: 1644365431).

Richburg, Keith. (2009, April 7). Vermont legislature legalizes same-sex marriages.

The Washington Post. Retrieved June 6, 2009 at

Same-sex marriages (SSM), civil unions & domestic partnerships. (2009). Religious Tolerance.

Retrieved June 6, 2009 at

Same-sex marriage in Iowa (SSM): Excerpt from the Varnum v. Brien ruling by Judge Robert B. Hanson, Polk County, Iowa. (2007, August 30). Religious Tolerance.

Retrieved June 6, 2009 at

Weiner, Rachel. (2009, January 12). Gene Robinson. The Huffington Post.

Retrieved June…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Same-Sex Marriage An Idea Whose" (2009, June 06) Retrieved December 7, 2016, from

"Same-Sex Marriage An Idea Whose" 06 June 2009. Web.7 December. 2016. <>

"Same-Sex Marriage An Idea Whose", 06 June 2009, Accessed.7 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Same Sex Marriage There Are

    " In other words, being gay was an "illness" but the gay person wasn't necessarily to be "blamed" because the origins of homosexuality were unknown at the time, Nugent continues. By claiming that gay people had illnesses, that gave some organized religions the opportunity to "…supply limited spiritual remedies" as a kind of "cure" for the condition (Nugent, 12). Whereas in much earlier days "ecclesiastical exorcisms" had been carried out to

  • Same Sex Marriage

    Same Sex Marriage HAVEN IN A HEARTLESS WORLD Marriage is seen as a sacred institution which lays down specific responsibilities on the man and the woman concerned. It puts man under the responsibility of providing bread to the family and the woman to take care of the household, raise the children and nurture them. Further a woman's role since history has been to mold the character of the child and like Freud

  • Same Sex Marriage and Policy Should Same

    Same Sex Marriage and Policy Should Same Sex Marriage be Legalized Should Same Sex Marriages be legalized? Hunter, writing in 1991, described same-sex marriage as a possibility that "shimmers or lurks-depending on one's point-of-view -- on the horizon of the law" (p. 10). Over the last fifteen years, homosexual's rights have emerged as one of the most contentious issues in American politics. Increasing number of friends and family members has "come out," interest groups

  • Same Sex Marriage the Challenge

    The wrong are dammed to hell and the argument shuts down. These clear lines in the sand ignore the nuanced nature of human sexuality and the freedom of choice given to all persons. Additionally, despite of the many attempts to cure persons of their homosexual orientation there has been little proven success. The question concerning sexual orientation is one that requires attention because it is the basis of many ill

  • Same Sex Marriage

    Same Sex Marriage Marriage is a socially sanctioned union that is, in most societies, generally guided by rule of exogamy, the obligation to marry outside a group (Marriage pp). However, some societies follow the rules of endogamy, the obligation to marry within a group (Marriage pp). Groups are generally defined as kinship such as clan or lineage, residential groups, and social groups such as ethnic, caste or class (Marriage pp). Although

  • Same Sex Marriage This Subject Interests Me From

    same-sex marriage. This subject interests me from both a moral and a legal standpoint. The topic has gained national as well as global attention. The debate is especially heated in the United States where the matter is being decided on a state by state basis. The essential question that surrounds this topic is if same-sex marriage good for society. The ongoing debate over same-sex marriage often generates more heat than

  • Pros and Cons of Same Sex Marriage

    Same Sex Marriage The legalization of same-sex marriage may be one of the most controversial social issues in the modern American political climate, and, in fact, throughout the Western world. While it may seem as if this highly polarizing issue has come out of nowhere, cultural norms about homosexuality and the acceptability of same-sex romantic relationships have always existed. Some societies have been accepting of same-sex relationships, others have violently

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved