Self in World Religions Although Religion Is Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Self in World Religions

Although religion is primarily a social activity -- even the most solitary and mystical of religious practitioners require an existing creed subscribed to by other people -- to a certain degree religion is required to define the self. In practice, the religious conception of selfhood can work in a number of ways -- either by setting limits to acceptable thought and behavior by the self by establishing doctrine or taboo, or else by defining the nature of that self in terms of those essential characteristics which relate specifically to religious practice (as in religions which hold to concepts of the soul or of an afterlife). From this standpoint it is worth surveying the concept of self in the various non-Western religions -- Confucianism, Taoism, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Shintoism -- to examine how they contribute to, or define, the self.

It is worth noting at the outset that Confucianism itself is not a religion, per se, but a set of first principles of social organization and behavior: there are no larger otherworldly implications to the Confucian precepts for the self. Instead, the self is defined in Confucianism by means of its relation to the larger social unit, and in terms of its social relationships. For Confucius, life consists of ethical principles: the central problem with humanity is anything which exacerbates human tendencies towards social disharmony. The Confucian system is one in which social order is paramount: Douglas Soccio defines Confucius not as a religious figure or philosopher per se, but as "the social sage" (Soccio 33). Confucius offers no prescriptions about deities or the afterlife, but instead gives rules of conduct -- in essence a manual of etiquette, which manages to raise etiquette to the level of a moral imperative. For Confucius, the goal for the self is to exist in the greatest possible harmony within society, which means adhering to specifically-defined social roles. In some sense, Confucianism places its most religious-seeming reverent attitudes towards the idea of education -- Confucius himself is presented as no more than a teacher (of right behavior, of rules of conduct, more than a teacher of moral inquiry) and good education is central to the Confucian concept of good behavior and for its fairly circumscribed sense of any the larger goals of human life. For Confucius the chief rule of life is chung-yung, which is the Chinese equivalent of the Western Classical idea of the Golden Mean: chung-yung literally means "centrality and universality," and it implies not only accordance with moral law but also a larger societal balance and harmony. The ideal self, according to Confucius, obeys the rules of chung-yung. There are several key concepts that must be understood in Confucius' system of behavior. The first of these is "li" usually translated as "ritual" or "rules of proper behavior" -- it denotes a concept of respect for the accepted forms of behavior, and an adherence to their right conduct. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, li comprises rules and behaviors "through which one expresses respect for superiors and enacts his role in society in such a way that he himself is worthy of respect and admiration" ("Confucius," n.p.) The ideal individual, according to Confucius, is not individualistic: he or she obeys the accepted traditions of correct behavior, raising etiquette to the level of moral duty. The proper role of the self is to be subordinated to this harmonious social behavior.

But in terms of relation to others, the largest Confucian concept for the self is "ren," usually translated as "goodness" or "virtue." The concept, however, is one which governs relations of the self with others: it is goodness or virtue as practiced in relations between the individual and the larger social order. The ideal self exhibits ren in terms of the "five relationships" established by Confucius: these are the relations of a parent to a child, of an older sibling to a younger sibling, of a husband to a wife, of an older person to a younger person, and of a ruler toward a subject. In other words, relationships which might risk a potential power imbalance are governed by right rules of conduct. Other Confucian concepts enlarge upon this view of the relation of the self to others. For Confucius, the ideal person would also exhibit a very traditional Chinese virtue, "xiao," which is the injunction to filial piety: the respect of children for parents. (A western parallel might be found in the Ten Commandments, with "honor thy father and thy mother." ) Similarly the Confucian concept of "Shu" is also close to most western ethical teachings -- it can be translated as "consideration" or "reciprocity," and indicates the basic notion of not doing unto others what you would not have others do unto you, as per the western idea of the "golden rule." But in terms of the larger social good, the Confucian concept of "wen" indicates a respect for the arts, or more particularly the "arts of peace." By this notion, Confucius encourages his ideal person to exist in harmony with society, and with useful or contemplative activity as exemplified in the arts -- the self here does not exist in a vacuum.

The Taoist conception of self has a certain amount of overlap with the Confucian, although it does have altogether a more obviously religious cast. For Lao-Tzu, the goal for the self is to exist in greatest harmony with nature and the natural scheme of things. The emphasis on harmony with a larger entity is similar to Confucius, but it is not defined socially and it ultimately takes on a much more mystical character. Lao-Tzu is also, crucially, deliberately vague in refusing to define goals specifically: to some extent, Lao-Tzu believes that part of the "Way" that is advertised in the title of his short scripture is being perpetually able to respond to what life presents on an ad hoc basis, and not according to ossified dogmatic precepts. As Soccio notes, Lao-Tzu himself states outright that it is impossible to capture the Way in mere words, but nonetheless offers his moral precepts as parables or poetic images. For Lao Tzu the central problem with the self lies in its attempts to exert a kind of control or even "will to power" over the way of nature: Lao Tzu sees all achievement as impermanent, and this recognition of the fundamental vanity of human endeavor accounts for the prominence in his worldview of the concept of "wu wei," or the path of least resistance -- perhaps better understood, as Soccio suggests, as the path in greatest harmony with nature and the natural course of events. "Wu Wei" represents, to a certain degree, Lao Tzu's solution for the central problem facing humanity -- the desire for strife and overreaching, and the sort of debased behavior that marked the societal collapse of Lao Tzu's own contemporary China, in what historians have termed the "Period of the Warring States," a time of nonstop violence and civil unrest. The ethical teachings of Lao Tzu reflect a reaction against this kind of societal chaos, and they preach a strong quietism, perhaps reflecting their origins in a time of civil war. This may be another sign of the fundamental difference between Lao Tzu and Confucius: in a time of societal collapse, the notion of defining selfhood by its right relation to society must seem fairly useless. Taoism therefore takes an inward turn, concentrating on the nature of the will within the self. However it is worth noting that, to the extent that Taoism has a definition of evil, it is located within the self, in the faculty of will. If the Taoist concept of wu-wei, or the path of least resistance, represents the ideal for the self, the "wei" in wu-wei stands for some concept of the human will, that aspect of the human personality which attempts to impose itself by force on others and onto nature. If "wu-wei" is the ethical ideal, "wei" represents more or less the Taoist concept of evil: this is any action that is performed not in accordance with the Tao, any action that is caused purely by the human assertive will, and any state of life that is marked by sufferings caused by these eleemnts of human willfulness. There is no metaphysical component to this Taoist conception of evil, however; as Hsu notes, if the human will is the chief obstacle to harmony with nature, and if such harmony is man's most desirable state, it makes sense that "all the sufferings in the world are supposedly man-made" (Hsu 307). But more than being manmade, they derive from this aspect of the self that tries to impose upon the external world. Yet it is crucial to realize that this aspect of the self in Taoism can even apply to behavior that, in many religious traditions, might seem like an ethical obligation. In terms of right action for the self, it is interesting to note that, in the Tao…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Self In World Religions Although Religion Is" (2012, April 16) Retrieved December 11, 2016, from

"Self In World Religions Although Religion Is" 16 April 2012. Web.11 December. 2016. <>

"Self In World Religions Although Religion Is", 16 April 2012, Accessed.11 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Religion Although Europe Is Becoming

    With regard to strong network ties, religions like Mormonism and Jehovah's Witnesses will grow in communities with strong social connections that already exist. Thus, a few core members of the community become converted. Those core members are trusted in the community, and therefore community members are far more likely to embrace the faith through their trusted friends, neighbors, or family members than by total strangers. The growth of Mormonism and

  • Religion Anselm Aquinas and Hume

    Thus, Sam argues that although the world often seems unjust (and is filled with innumerable instances of evil), yet P. is solved through the belief that every condition (good, in this case) necessitates an equal and opposite condition (evil, as it were.) However, Gretchen counters by asking whether those who behave in an evil way are ever punished for their transgressions, and whether there is any motivation for people to

  • World Religions the World s Great

    Taoism is another ancient religion practiced within Eastern Asia. It shares beliefs and practices with Confucianism and is mainly practiced in various parts of China. It is a polytheistic religion that has a wide variety of gods within its spiritual arsenal. Like Hinduism, Taoism is a name that covers a wide variety of smaller religious sects that can be found in various parts of China and its neighboring countries, although

  • Religion Should Be Eliminated From

    Essentially, science utilizes the power of reason and logic in its search for the truth while religion depends almost wholly upon faith, being a belief in something without any evidence whatsoever to support it. In the realms of science, investigators seek to understand natural phenomena through direct observation and experimentation which makes it mandatory that all interpretations of the facts be provisional and testable. Statements made by any authority, revelation

  • Religion of Buddhism First Just

    Dharma is related to "karma," another basic Buddhist principle that governs reincarnation and rebirth. Karma is the idea that a person must perform moral deeds throughout his life to attain a higher level of reincarnation and rebirth. Karma governs these moral deeds, and a person must "pay" in the next life if they do not act morally and spiritually in this life. Thus, karma governs more than one life,

  • Religion Be Sure to Include

    At the church I visited, many of the parents had returned to regular church-going for the sake of their children, because they wanted their children to have a spiritual foundation. However, the manifestation of their spirituality was social, not simply individual. Many of the children were part of a youth group, and knew one another as friends. They went on retreats together, bonded at prayer meetings, as well as talked

  • Religion of Islam Compatible With

    No doubt, such feelings are greatly exacerbated by the current hard-line policies of the U.S. government in the Middle East, Conclusion There is a general perception in the Western world that the religion of Islam is inherently incompatible with the ideals of democracy such as individual liberties and freedom of speech. The recent controversy over the cartoons of Prophet Muhammad, published by a Danish newspaper, and the violent reaction of Muslims

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved