United States Steel Corp v Research Paper

Download this Research Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Research Paper:

Therefore, it meets the threshold requirement for limited safe haven. Moreover, the provision of medical services appears to fall under the qualifications of the SCM that services be a controlled service transaction or a group of transactions. This provision of services is not one of the prohibited services including manufacturing, production, extraction of mineral resources, construction, reselling, research and development, engineering, financial, or insurance.

In United Parcel Service of America, Inc. v. Commissioner, 254 F.3d 1014 (11th Cir. 2001), the plan seemed designed for the purposes of tax evasion. UPS sought to shift income to a wholly owned subsidiary in Bermuda through the purchase of insurance on excess value charges for parcels with a value greater than $100. UPS distributed shares of the Bermuda subsidiary (OPL) as a taxable dividend to UPS shareholders. UPS then purchased an insurance policy for its customers from National Union, which then entered into a reinsurance contract with OPL. In other words, National Union served as a pass-through for OPL. The court determined that the transaction was not a sham because National Union and UPS had genuine contractual obligations to one another as did OPL and National Union. The limited safe haven option would not be available in this scenario because it is specifically prohibited when the purpose of the subsidiary corporation is to provide reinsurance. However, there was a real contractual obligation between UPS and National Union, which was recognized by the tax court. I would need more information about the ownership of National Union to understand why it would function as a straw man for UPS and OPL, because the conditions, as stated, which is that National Union paid all of its fees to OPL means that National Union made no profit off of its transaction. If it did not profit from the transaction, it would be difficult to make any type of comparability argument.

In the GAC produce scenario, GAC was one of several companies in Mexico and the United States owned by a single family. GAC entered into a contract with an unrelated company, Sun Country Produce, under which Sun Country paid a commission to GAC for the distribution and marketing of Sun Country Products. GAC repeatedly took a loss on its relationship with Sun Country, and the court determined that even though Sun Country was not owned by the same group as GAC, that the losses benefitted other members in the controlled group of companies, and therefore failed the arm's length standard. The arguments to defend GAC would simply be that it had made a bad bargain; sometimes companies do make contracts that involve losses, and I would attempt to put forth evidence that GAC was simply involved in that type of scenario by demonstrating contractual comparability between GAC's contract with Sun Country and other similar produce distribution contracts.

There have been significant changes to the tax code since the United States Steel Corp decision. In fact, even at the time that the decision was made, the courts were not unanimous in their approaches to the tax regulations, which created significant confusion due to the taxpayer having the bear the burden of proof (M.S.R., 1981). This is further complicated by the 1986 tax reforms, which changed transfer pricing methods. One of the problems that these regulations sought to deal with was the valuation of intangibles between related parties and how those should be taxed, which is becoming an increasing problem as intellectual property grows in relative economic value (Williams, 1991).

While many corporations have been globalized for years, the increase in globalization is leading to increasing double-taxation problem, which present issues even for companies that are not formed for income-tax avoidance purposes but for wholly legitimate business purposes. One commentator, Robert Clark, suggests that the U.S. income tax regulations, alone, will be inadequate to deal with the transfer pricing disputes that are sure to result from increasing globalization. According to Clark, "The problem of transfer pricing disputes is not new, but it is expanding at an ever-increasing rate. International unity will be the only means to avoid an avalanche of double taxation disputes. Surviving that upheaval will require learning the lessons taught by previous disputes. That in turn will require open communication among tax authorities and taxpayers in ways that are not yet available under international conventions" (Clark, 1993).


26 C.F.R. § 1.482(d)(3)(i).

26 C.F.R. § 1.482(d)(3)(ii).

Clark, R. (1993). Comment: Transfer pricing, section 482, and international tax conflict: Getting harmonized income allocation measures from multinational cacophony. The American University Law Review, 42, 1155-1212.

M.S.R. (1981). Note & comment: Du Pont and U.S. Steel: Different approaches to Section 482

intercompany pricing regulations. Va. Tex. Rev., 1, 399.

Williams, D. (1991). Ttax on the international transfer of information. Andover: Sweet &…[continue]

Cite This Research Paper:

"United States Steel Corp V " (2012, February 14) Retrieved December 11, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/united-states-steel-corp-v-54249

"United States Steel Corp V " 14 February 2012. Web.11 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/united-states-steel-corp-v-54249>

"United States Steel Corp V ", 14 February 2012, Accessed.11 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/united-states-steel-corp-v-54249

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • US Presidential Elections

    Presidential Elections Because of the extreme conditions of the 1930s depression, the New Deal under Franklin Roosevelt went further in expanding the powers of the federal government than any previous administration in history, certainly far beyond the very limited role permitted to it by the conservative administrations of Warren G. Harding, Calvin Coolidge and Herbert Hoover in 1921-33. It was the worst depression in U.S. history, and led not only to

  • History of Steel Industry From 1875 1920 in Great Lakes Region

    (Macdonagh-Dumler and Pebbles et al. 1-14) The Marquette Range, which consisted of huge deposits of high quality iron ore, was discovered in the year 1844, the operations were initiated in the year 1846. Other ranges that were opened by the year 1910, included the Menominee, Gogebic, Vermilion, Cuyuna, and, the Mesabi range in Minnesota, in the year 1892. (Macdonagh-Dumler and Pebbles et al. 1-14) In the year 1844 the first great

  • States Rights vs National Government

    RIGHTS VS. NATIONAL LAWS National laws formulated and implemented by the federal government have often been criticized for their centralizing effect and for restraining/restricting the power of state laws. In a republican form of government, state laws have enormous significance as this form of government allows "people . . . To pass their own laws in virtue of the legislative power reposed in representative bodies, whose legitimate acts may be

  • Dicenzo v Best Products Company Inc Dicenzo

    DiCenzo v. Best Products Company, Inc. (Dicenzo v. A-Best Products Co., Inc., 2008), is actually a compilation of several different personal injury actions filed against approximately 90 different defendants. Such filings are not unusual in the products liability field particularly in cases involving asbestos manufacture, sale and distribution. The wide use of asbestos and its popularity as a fireproofing and insulating material resulted in many firms becoming involved in

  • Humana and Tata Steel Humana

    The costs of raw materials continued to escalate as well, further impacting profitability. More environmental regulations - There are many industrial regulations on the steel industries including the Kyoto doctrine that concentrates on green-based government initiatives to save the environment. All of these regulations further increase the costs that Tata must incur to continue operating. Humana References Jaimy Lee. (2008, April). Humana engages public on health-sector solutions. PRweek, 11(17), 2. Retrieved February

  • Mondragon Cooperative Corporation s Basic Principles Four Main

    Mondragon Cooperative Corporation's Basic Principles. Four main factors stand out: 1) the Mondragon Cooperative Corporation's rapidly advancing concept of Work Environment, in accordance with Finance, 2) reasons people change and the nemesis which causes the ever-growing sense of improvement (perceived as advancement) in Retail, 3) Benefits of Autonomy and Self-Reliance in Industry, and 4) the self-determination from which all knowledge is based. By all means, knowledge poses as the central

  • Jp Morgan Banking Institution and

    It was from Pecora's hearings that many of the standards and regulations affecting the financial industry emerged, and continue to govern the way the 'street' does business today. It was also the time of the Glass-Steagall Act. The roaring twenties gave way to the Depression Era of the 1930's and still J.P. Morgan bore the standard for financial firms on Wall Street. The firm was the first one to be investigated

Read Full Research Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved