Critique Article Review Article Review

PAGES
5
WORDS
1817
Cite

Nurse-headed telephone triage has increasingly been employed for managing physician consultation demands in British general practice. Prior research works are vague when it comes to delineating the association between nurse triage call results and practical clinical experience. A majority of studies are restricted to scrutinizing out-of-hours nurse phone triage. This particular study has been performed within the framework of current knowledge, thereby contributing a solution angle highly relevant to the nursing profession. This study's key purpose was investigating whether or not primary care nursing staff's (who undertake digital decision-backed software phone triage) professional traits are associated with call disposition (Varley, et al., 2016). Literature Review

Telephone Triage

Telephone triage application is an approach utilized for tackling increasing nurse workloads. Nursing staff offer an effective and safe triage service within various settings such as primary care, in which they may prove efficient in terms of managing doctors' workload in out-of-hours and day-of-contact primary healthcare facilities.

1. Nursing Characteristics

Qualification levels, duration of experience in the field and other nursing traits can impact triage results as well. An analysis of as many as 60,794 calls that were handled by a total of 296 National Health Service Direct nurses revealed a positive link with call disposal trends and duration of experience. Relatively new nursing staff (not even ten years in the field) depicted lesser likelihood to dispose self-care calls as compared to nursing staff practicing for two decades or more. This finding is in line with other studies that note that more experienced nursing staff exhibit greater correctness/accuracy of selected triage results, decreased data acquisition levels in triage evaluations, and more inference/judgment-making on the basis of past experience.

This research on nursing elements represents a continuous endeavor being carried out for the last many years. It appears that numerous researches published several years back continue to apply in the present scenario. The researchers have referenced journal articles published between 1995 and 2016.

Theoretical Framework

1. This research hasn't directly applied theoretic concepts. It has only directly applied some general nursing-related research hypotheses and problems. Questionnaires of nursing staff delivering ESTEEM's nurse intervention branch effectively captured kind of role (i.e., NP (nurse practitioner) or practice nurse), duration of experience, status of prescriber, educational qualification, perceived triage readiness and past triage experience. The key result sought was: share of triaged nursing care patients who received follow-up recommendation in the practice (i.e., call disposition). This included all forms of contact (direct, house visits and telephonic), by nurses or doctors.

1. The study has employed nursing theory elements having relevance with regard to the research problem.

Every nurse participated in a customized training initiative for facilitating their application of CDSS (clinical decision support software) offered by software company, Plain Healthcare...

...

Every study subject potentially engaged in a triage role was expected to be provided with the standardized aforementioned training package relating to phone consultation skills and CDSS application. One point to bear in mind is that this support software aims at supporting nursing professional inpatient care-related decision-making. While nurses need to login to this software for all consultations, they need not abide by the software-generated recommendation, for the trial. Hence, the software usage intent was to facilitate nurse decision-making as well as offer them flexibility for applying their expertise and experience in deciding triage phone call outcomes.
1. Approach Framework

Yes, the step-wise strategy employed in this study is described below.

1. Extraction of patient information from clinician forms (primary result modeling),

1. Gleaning of likely explanatory factors from clinician forms,

1. Survey of nursing staff and

1. Data acquisition at practice level.

Variables/Hypotheses/Questions/Assumptions

1. What are the independent and dependent variables in this study?

Covariates at the patient level were:

1. Participant Sex (Reference-female);

1. Age categorized as: 0 to 4 years; 5 to 11 years; 16 to 24 years; 25 to 59 years (reference category); 60 to 74 years; 75+ years;

1. Duration of experience

1. Deprivation at patient level segregated into rank-based quintiles

1. Ethnicity

Covariates at the practice level were:

1. Location;

1. Deprivation at practice level; non-deprived: deprived; below average or average deprivation in case of England (reference group); and above average England-based deprivation; and

1. Size of practice list: small (8000 registered patients; this is the reference category); and medium (between 3500 and 8000 registered patients).

Every variable above is independent. The study purpose establishes call disposition as its dependent variable. Research content to support it is as follows.

Suggested call disposition was the chief outcome, dichotomized in binary variable form and suggesting whether practice follow-up was needed or not. Every statistical analysis was composed of logistical hierarchical models. Distinct patient examinations were nested in nurses and vice versa, hence, both practice and nurse are random effects in the study (Varley, et al., 2016)

1. Are the operational definitions of the variables given? If so, are they concrete and measurable?

Variable understanding, levels and context haven't been clearly delineated. However, researchers have mentioned a general survey parameter application.

1. Is the research question or the hypothesis stated? What is it?

The triage phone call disposition-nurse trait linkage was scrutinized for same-day patient visit requests within general practice by employing multivariable logistics regression modeling. Discrete nurse traits were studied for their link to follow-up. Another model encompassed all nursing traits. All significant nurse traits (individual or in the model of…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Campbell, J., Fletcher, L., Britten, E., Green, N., Holt, C., & Lattimer, V. (2015). . The clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of telephone triage for managing same-day consultation requests in general practice: a cluster randomised controlled trial comparing general practitioner-led and nurse-led management systems with care. Health Technology Access.

Varley, A., Warren, F., Richards, S., Calitri, R., Chaplin, K., Fletcher, E., . . . Campbell, J. (2016). The effect of nurses' preparedness and nurse practitioner status on triage call management in primary care: A secondary analysis of cross-sectional data from the ESTEEM trial. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 12 - 20.


Cite this Document:

"Critique Article Review" (2017, January 27) Retrieved April 20, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/critique-article-review-2163945

"Critique Article Review" 27 January 2017. Web.20 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/critique-article-review-2163945>

"Critique Article Review", 27 January 2017, Accessed.20 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/critique-article-review-2163945

Related Documents
Feminism Article Review
PAGES 2 WORDS 691

‘I’ve Been Pondering Whether You Can Be a Part-feminist’ This is an article by Kate Hughes that is based on a qualitative year-long study of young women and their perception of feminism. The author intended to establish if there are any changes in perception of gender within the personal lives of the women after they took the Women's Studies program (Hughes). It is clear that gender perceptions are based on an

Nursing problem addressed by this research is the level of confidence that patients in nursing homes and their family members have with respect to tests and treatments that occur in the residential nursing home rather than in a clinical or hospital setting. It is understandable that patients and family members might be concerned that the quality of care is not the same across all settings. And nursing homes are working

Sand-Jecklin, K., & Herman, J. (2014). A Quantitative Assessment of Patient and Nurse Outcomes of Bedside Nursing Report Implementation. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 23(19-20), 2854-2863. This particular research piece is quantitative in nature. The basic analysis element in a study of this kind as Keele (2011) points out is statistical analyses and numbers. This is more so the case given that it generates data that could be transmuted into operational statistics,

The Critique: Begin with a Brief Summary In this article, Burkett (2010) tries to identify the role that technology can help Paralympic athletes to compete in different sporting activities. The study focuses more on how technology can be made relevant to individual needs of Paralympic athletes. Moreover, it highlights the weaknesses and strengths in technologies used in the summer Paralympic games held in Athens and Beijing.  The objective of the study

fall of the former Soviet Union in the early 1990s spurred debate among policymakers and intellectuals about the shape of future of world politics, and the role that the U.S. would play in it. One of the greatest early voices in this debate was Samuel Huntington, who through his article, 'The Clash of Civilizations', took difference in civilization as the greatest source of conflict in the international political system

The data gathered is subjected to statistical analysis using statistical methods of linear regression and chi square testing. The main purpose of the study was to confirm the hypothesis that consultation with CNS or RN in a drug-monitoring clinic has a significant positive impact on the well being of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The study involved a single blinded randomized controlled trial over a period of three years. Subjects were