Balancing human rights and security in post-9/11 criminal justice
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Terror Results
The new landscape that has developed within the criminal justice system in recent times has presented many challenges that are difficult to solve and present no real easy solution. The ever present threat of terrorist activities has placed this system in a unique situation where a balance between human rights and the protection of the citizens. In legal attempts to thwart terrorist efforts, advanced and debatable interrogation techniques have begun taking place. The purpose of this essay is to discuss the ethical dilemma that is present in finding and achieving this balance between what is right and wrong. This essay will suggest that there is not general right or wrong and that each case must be handled with reason and rational thought in order for the criminal justice system to maintain a useful place within society.
Background
The 9/11 attacks collectively spooked out everyone in America, despite the relatively little damage that was done. Terrorist attacks have great psychological impacts on the targeted populations often causing extreme and irrational reactions. A successful terror attack, in my opinion, should aim to do just that. The ability to successfully distract the target population in any terrorist attack is a useful objective that can disrupt any efforts to thwart or combat such attacks.
The many knee-jerk reactions that occurred shortly after the 9/11 attacks demonstrated the success of the attacks. Furthermore no one has been legally captured and charged with those crimes. IN many ways the criminal justice system has desperately failed by not bringing anyone to justice under its legal means. This is certainly a black eye on the organization and vigilante efforts, perhaps misplaced, have been a common demonstration from this collective organization. The obvious failures by government on 9/11 have shown that weaknesses were not necessarily a legal problem but more of a leadership problem.
Changes to Legal System
9/11 demanded that some changes needed to be made. In haste it appears that some of the wrong changes were chosen.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.