Skinner, Pavlov, and Kohn on behaviorism and constructivism in learning

¶ … behaviorism and constructivism using the beliefs of Skinner, Pavlov, and Kohn as a way of explaining behavior and learning. This also includes my personal critique. A comparison and critique of the philosophy undergirding behaviorism and constructivism is also carried out. My own thoughts regarding the employment of these practices in classrooms as well as the critique of authors such as Skinner, Pavlov, and Kohn and the rest is also carried out.

The concept of behaviorism and constructivism has long dominated the domain of learning as well as behavior analysis. This is due to their in-depth and critical viewpoints regarding the reasons as to why people behave in certain ways and also their processes of learning various skills and habits in the course of their daily lives.

Behaviorism as a learning theory

Behaviorism as a learning theory is traced back to Aristotle. The trace lands in his essay "Memory" which was focused on the association that exists between events like thunder and lightning. The other philosophers that evolved their theories from the works of Aristotle are Hobbs, Hume, Brown, Bain, Ebbinghause, Black, Pavlov, Watson, Thorndike and then Skinner who later developed the behaviorism theory into detail. In deed Watson is the one who is credited for coining the term itself. Behaviorism theory views learning as a straightforward process that occurs on the basis of certain stimuli.

The corresponding reward or rather reinforcement is said to be responsible for the strengthening of the response which in turn results in behavioral change. The main test in this school of thought is to judge whether learning had taken place. It is said that "the behaviorist perspective, associated with B.F. Skinner, holds that the mind at work cannot be observed, tested, or understood; thus, behaviorists are concerned with actions (behavior) as the sites of knowing, teaching, and learning" (Spillane,2002).

Skinner's belief of behaviorism

His theory of behaviorism is based on the idea of learning as a function of change in behaviors that are overt (Skinner,1954).It postulates that changes in an individual's behavior are due to their response to certain events (stimuli) which are existent in the environment. He summed it up as operant conditioning.

In a nutshell his behaviorist theory identified the following:

Certain pleasant experiences (like rewards and praise) being positive reinforcers. These causes the learners to make certain desirable connections between the stimuli and the corresponding responses.

Certain pleasant experiences (like punishment) which are negative reinforcers. These cause the learner to avoid the undesirable responses to a certain stimuli.

The continuous reinforcement does increase the rate of learning.

The intermittent reinforcement that contributes to a longer retention of the learnt material

The positive and negative reinforcement do shape behavior.

A lack of any form of reinforcement may also shape behavior. This is because is a person receives no form of acknowledgement of their behavior, they would most likely modify that behavior up to the time when they receive some form of reinforcement.

Kohn's belief of behaviorism

Kohn's belief is the most controversial since he believes that the other behaviorist theory is not entirely correct. For example, he believes that arrogance is an individual's authority as well as status and the willingness, eagerness to enforce an individual's theory through the exertion of control on other persons as outlined by others (Curran,1998)

Criticisms

It contradicts Darwin's ideas of natural selection-Darwinsm does contradict skinner's theory of operant conditioning. This is because Darwin believed that humans are constantly in a process of improving themselves in order to gain control of themselves (self-control).However "to increase self-control means to increase liberty" or rather free-will is a concept denied by Skinner (Dahlbom, 1984, p. 486)

Constructivism as a learning theory

Constructivism's meaning changes in regards to one's perspective as well as position. In the domain of education, various philosophical interpretation of constructivism exists. There is the personal constructivism as pointed out by Piaget (1967).There also exists educational constructivism as described by Matthews (1998).

Skinner's belief of constructivism

He believed that the beginning of human behavior can be contributed to constructivism.later on the behaviorism aspects starts to take over. This is evident when he said that "the variables of which human behavior is a function lie in the environment " (Skinner,1977,p.1)

Kohn's belief of constructivism

Core favors constructivism. His opinion can be summarized as

"… the process of learning does indeed require that meaning, ethical or otherwise, be actively invented and reinvented, from the inside out. It requires that children be given the opportunity to make sense of such concepts as fairness or courage, regardless of how long the concepts themselves have been around. (p. 435, 1997)

My opinion

My opinion on constructivism is that it does not act alone in the learning process. Other elements such as the environment and genetics also play a big role in the process. Therefore for a constructivist classroom, the creative process should be made part and parcel of the learning process.

Criticism

The main criticism is that it contradicts other findings (Matthews, 2000)

It is elitist. Various Critics do say that constructivism and as well as other "progressive" theories of education have favored children from privileged backgrounds with outstanding teachers, parents who are committed, and rich residential environments while not favoring children from disadvantaged backgrounds who lack resources.

Leads to "group think" which makes opinions from the majority group discussions thwart those of the minority groups in classrooms.

Behaviorism and Constructivism in Classroom

Social constructivisms as well as educational constructivism (theories of learning as well as pedagogy) have been noted to be influential in the classroom situation have great impacts on both instruction as well as in the design of curriculum. The teaching as well as the learning process depends heavily in constructivist-based methods of instruction which has been noted to put priority to the classroom learning process. Behaviorist theory was previously in use but was dropped as a result of frustrations it casused.Currently it has been replaced with the constructionist approach due to its success.