Campbell Freedom And Want The Essay

PAGES
1
WORDS
368
Cite

Campbell

Freedom and Want

The concept of freedom involves being able to make a choice, which Campbell recognizes when he writes that moral freedom means that you could have done otherwise in a certain situation, all variables remaining equal. For example, I remember a situation in grade school on the playground. I pushed a girl into the mud. I pretended like it was an accident, and everyone believed me, but it was not. I had pushed her on purpose. Campbell would say that I was free to make the decision to push or not to push, and I decided to push. In the same situation, I could have made the choice not to push. This is freedom. Soft determinists, however, would say that one variable changes this -- the variable of want. I could only have chosen not to push the girl if I had wanted to refrain from pushing her. I wanted to push her. I remember that clearly. Was I free not to push her despite that want? Yes.

Campbell's view can explain my decision much better than the soft determinist view. I remember, in the instant that I pushed the girl, thinking about it, and making a conscious choice. I remember making that decision to push her, as awful as it might seem. I do not know what possessed me to want to push her, but I know that, whether or not I wanted to, I did push her, and I could have done otherwise. True freedom means being able to make a choice in spite of all variables -- want being one of them. There are many times that we want to do something, but it is not good for us, so we choose to do what is more positive for us in the long run than what we want to do right now. We are free to make that choice, as is exemplified by the times that we choose to do what we want to do over what is right or what would serve us better in the long run. Freedom must mean we have the ability to choose from at least two choices in any given situation. Thus, Campbell's view is sufficient.

Cite this Document:

"Campbell Freedom And Want The" (2009, April 15) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/campbell-freedom-and-want-the-22938

"Campbell Freedom And Want The" 15 April 2009. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/campbell-freedom-and-want-the-22938>

"Campbell Freedom And Want The", 15 April 2009, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/campbell-freedom-and-want-the-22938

Related Documents

Battlefield Contractors The use of private contractors to assist the U.S. military forces in times of conflict is not a new concept. According to author Gordon Campbell, Washington has "always" used contractors in times of war. There are many contemporary issues and potential problems when the U.S. military signs deals with private contractors, as it did in Iraq and is currently doing in Afghanistan. The main issue revolves around the concept

Man's Ability To Treat Humans Like Animals It is a vivid fact that the feelings of cruelty, discrimination and racial distribution are embedded well in to human nature since its very inception. This world depicts several cases where humans treat other humans like animals and ignore their right of living peacefully and according to their own will. This article highlights the work of several writers who have depicted the different ways

First Amendment, the Constitution, and the Supreme Court Freedom of and from religion and freedom of speech are the distinct provisions of the First Amendment; it gives citizens of the United States the unalienable human right to assembly and speech. However, the language is intentionally vague. The framers of the Constitution, anticipating unknown applications of the amendment, gave power to the Supreme Court to act as ultimate arbiter in matters

(1996) This separation of individuals and groups from the wrongs that have been perpetrated against them in the rhetoric and reality dehumanizes them to a degree and allows discourse on redress and resolution to falter. Having discussed the main premises of these three, for lack of a better word, philosophers one must now look to Nyers, who discusses the political nature of the status of "refugee" and how in the

Vikings and the Slave Trade Vikings were Norse explorers who traveled around the waters of the North Atlantic raiding, trading, pirating, and colonizing lands wherever their boats could travel. They are historically known as a rough group of individuals with raucous personalities and innate brutality. They are credited with having been the first to discover the New World and to have reached locations which had not seen foreign invaders before the

Native Americans Describe what is known of the tribe's pre-Columbian history, including settlement dates and any known cultural details. Before Columbus came to the "New World," the pre-Columbian era, the Cherokee occupied an area that today is western North Carolina, eastern Tennessee and northern Georgia (Waddington 2006). The Cherokee traveled even further past these areas, however, to hunt and to trade their wares. The Cherokee had occupied this area for a good