The Cultural Revolution in Li Zhisui, Chen Jo-hsi, and Tian Zhuangzhuang's works

Autographic style book by Dr. Li Zhisui ( the private life of chairman mao pp433-546), and the short stories by Chen Jo-hsi, and the movie The Blue Kites, are all about these authors' and director's experiences of the tumultuous year of the Cultural Revolution and its aftermath. In what way do you think their works (book and movie) are valuable as historical documents?

The Communist Revolution in China was fighting against corruption and government officials who were out of touch with the people. Once they were in power, the communists had their support to a certain extent. However, these views began to change as a series of brutal crackdowns resulted in many people losing faith in their leaders. (Schrecker) (Gao)

To fully understand what was happening, a series of works were created which are highlighting these shifts. The most notable include: the Private Life of Chairman Moa, short stories by Chen Jo-Hsi and the movie The Blue Kites. Each one serves as a historical backdrop of these events and the lasting impact on everyone. This offers specific insights of these events and how they influenced various social attitudes during this time.

The Mid 1950s to the Early 1960s

Two of the different works start out by showing how the Communist Revolution was about dealing with the challenges which had plagued China for many years. The most notable include: corruption, brutality (at the hands of the state) and incompetent leaders. At first, many people supported the communists. This is because they were challenging the status quo and offered hope. These changes occurred with them promising to redistribute the concentration of wealth, provide greater opportunities and help China to become a world power.

For instance, in the film The Blue Kites, the beginning is set in the 1950s. This is when China is changing with everyone having their own opinions of the revolution. Yet, these transformations are so new that no one fully understands what is happening or the lasting impacts it will have. These ideas are demonstrated with the Father being seen as hopeful about what was happening during the Hundred Flowers Campaign. This is when everyone is encouraged to express their ideas about building a new China. ("The Blue Kite")

On the surface, it seems like China is changing and become more responsive to the needs of the people. However, Chairman Moa changes his mind and subsequently goes after dissent. This is problematic, as the family is torn between supporting the revolution and going against the new policies. That is introduced by the central government. ("The Blue Kite")

Moreover, the Private Life of Chairman Moa is discussing how he was open to change and wanted to create a new China during the mid 1950s. However, he became increasingly paranoid about different rivalries and infighting within the Communist Party. As his personal physician, he saw these changes first hand with many of those close to him quickly being thought of as rivals. This led to the changes in attitudes about what was happening in China and the lasting effects on him. The result is that Moa suddenly reversed course and began going after anyone who he felt was a direct threat to him. (Zhisui)

The basic idea was to utilize these areas as a way to protect the integrity of the revolution. This meant quelling any kind of discontent, with these changes by sending millions of people to hard labor camps. During this process, they were taught about how their limited views were making China worse off. At the same time, they were encouraged to repent their beliefs in order to become more aligned with the communist ideal. This was Moa's way of dealing with possible threats by trying to reform the new society. Throughout the mid 1950s and early 1960s, this became a program he used to build hope that China was slowly changing for the better. (Zhisui)

In this case, both works are useful in illustrating how these shifts had an influence on the Communist Revolution. This occurred with people having hope about the future in the mid 1950s. After the crackdown and reversal by Chairman Mao, is when they were subject to a reign of terror. This is from his paranoia with those around him and what they stood for. The result is that society saw their ability question the government squashed. (Schrecker)

These events are illustrating how society went from hope to despair. Yet, they became afraid to speak out against what was happening with them. Once this happened, is the point many were sent to labor and reeducation camps. The basic idea was to purge the individual of their old ideas from the previous regime. After they have renounced them, is when they could be trusted and were subsequent ally released. (Zhisui)

This was a part of the program known as the Great Leap Forward. During this process, Moa wanted to shift society from an agrarian society to one that was industrialized. These changes occurred; through collectivization and shifting the focus of society towards embracing the communist ideals. (Zhisui)

The two works are showing the transformations from the views of the ordinary person and the inside Chairman Moa's inner circle. These shifts were something where many people had hope for the future. Yet, this was quickly destroyed based upon the fact that Moa began to impose more radical policies that were designed to lead China forward. The problem was that the reforms led to the Great Famine and they were so radical that the average person was worse off in contrast with the old regime. (Zhisui)

The Mid 1960s to 1976

All three works are illustrating the sense of dejection society has towards Moa, his policies and revolution itself. This takes place from the mid-1960 until Moa's death in 1976. During this time frame, Moa feels that the revolution has been sabotaged by the old guard in the Communist Party. They are continuing to secretly embrace these polices of the former regime and are plotting against him even more. (Gao)

The problem has become so pronounced, that he feels it has affected party officials on the local level. In response to these challenges, he creates a new revolution called the Cultural Revolution. He encouraged a violent class struggle to remove these individuals from society and force everyone to embrace the new ways of life. This is when various programs will become more effective by supporting them in the longer term. (Gao)

In the movie, The Blue Kites these ideas are illustrated in the final part. This is when there is no wedding ceremony or feeling at all. Instead, the marriage is designed to save Li's son and former wife from poverty. While at the same time, it is focused on providing protection against forces who are accusing innocent people of being against the revolution. ("The Blue Kite")

In this case, the younger generation is going after anyone who is believed to be corroborating with them. They have formed their own secret police called the Red Guard. Li's former wife is dragged away based upon her association with a Communist Party official accused of corruption. While the son, is left to fend for himself and is subsequently beaten up by them. After this incident, he lies there looking at the Blue Kite which is symbolizing hope about the future in the mid 1950s. ("The Blue Kite")

Zhisui is illustrating how these views were supported by Moa. This is because he became frustrated with the pace of the changes and the refusal of society to abandon its old ways. The result is that he felt more radical measures must be taken to purge China of these undesirable individuals. This is demonstrating how Moa has become more socially disconnected and believes that he has enemies all around them. To support these actions he will often use patriotism and tired worn out slogans to encourage society to fight off these elements. (Zhisui)

In this case, these two works are showing how the attitudes of the Chinese people went from disillusionment to disgust. These shifts were taking place with everyone feeling as if they had sacrificed for the good of the nation. Yet, they were punished and accused of collaborating with elitist elements. When all they wanted to do, was help to build a strong and prosperous China. Zhisui is taking these ideas and he is using them as a way to demonstrate how Moa's views shifted over time. In the beginning, he had a sense of admiration for him and everything he stood for. However, as time went by, he shared similar beliefs with him looking at Moa as selfish, paranoid and brutal. The combination of these factors made him dislike Moa as a person and everything he stood for. (Zhisui)

Moreover, the various stories by Chen Jo-Hsi (1979) are further illustrating this sense of anger and frustration with the Cultural Revolution. This occurs with her family living there for seven years during this time period. In all of her stories, she shows how the people are supportive of the revolution. This is taking place with them reading the poetry and writings of Moa. (Hsi)

However, in response they are accused of being a part of the subversive element who is trying to sabotage the revolution. In the story titled Moa is a Rotten Egg, there is focus on the brutality and secrecy inside this society. As everyone was forced to live in conditions of poverty and survive off of the daily rations that were provided. This included everything from coal to food. (Hsi)

To make matters worse, China began to impose its one child policy and forced families to have abortions to prevent the population from growing too large. This created a sense of frustration about what was happening and the long-term impacts on the people. Yet, they could not speak out against these policies. This is because they were fearful that someone would overhear them and go after anyone who supported anti-government activities. (Hsi)

During one evening, some said that Chairman Moa is a Rotten Egg. This created fear about how the Red Guard would attack the family. They more than likely will accuse them of being a part of the subversive elements, who are trying to derail the Cultural Revolution. This created a sense of fear and anger about what was happening. When this took place, there were concerns that these frustrations could result in the family or select individuals being sent to a work camp. (Hsi)

The problem was that they were frustrated with their way of life and they wanted something more. However, they were powerless to control these events around them and became disillusioned with the revolution. This is from them continuing to sacrifice and support the cause. Yet, they were never able to live a better quality of life and the promises made the Communists fell short. (Hsi)

In this case, Chen Jo-Hsi is illustrating the sense of disgust everyone was having with Chairman Moa and his policies. This is taking place, with him trying to reshape society and more evenly distribute the wealth to large segments of the population through collectivization. The problem was that these policies were too radical and often harmed his main supporters. If they spoke out against what was happening, there is the possibility they would be arrested and sent to jail. (Hsi)

Conclusion

Clearly, all these works are illustrating how the people were in support of the Communist Revolution in the beginning. However, over the course of time, the government and its polices created attitudes of disillusionment. This is because these shifts were very extreme and the people suffered tremendous amounts of adversity in the process. To make matters worse, Moa felt that his programs were being sabotaged by elements from the old society. The best way to rid themselves of these individuals was to utilize the younger generation to go after them in the Cultural Revolution. This added to the sense of anger and frustrations many people felt in the process. As a result, each one is offering insights about why this happened and how it changed the attitudes of the people during this time. This makes them invaluable historical documents, which are underscoring these shifts and the lasting effects on Chinese society.