Reconciling imprecatory psalms with New Testament Christian ethics

¶ … Christians pray the imprecatory psalms

Imprecatory refers to invocation of judgment, calamity, or curses on God's enemies, and one's enemies. In the Bible, many people chanted imprecatory, for example, Moses, Deborah, and Jeremiah.[footnoteRef:2] The morning prayer of Moses qualifies as an imprecatory, which aimed to scatter the enemies of God, and Moses. Deborah's song and Barak ends with an imprecation that God's enemies will perish. In regards to prophet Jeremiah, the prophet, in the Bible uses repeated imprecations against his enemies. The imprecations are not only evident in the Old Testament, but also in the New Testament. [2: Laney, J Carl. "A fresh look at the imprecatory Psalms." Bibliotheca Sacra 138, no. 549 (1981): 35-45]

However, some other portions of the New Testament are considered as imprecations, even though, some of these verses do not have particular prayers to the lord that there would be a possible judgment. Nonetheless, in several books, such as Acts, and Psalms to a greater degree, are quoted in the New Testament as having imprecations. In this context, vital to the definition of imprecations, the imprecatory, therefore, must be an invocation, prayer to address God. In addition, it must have a request whereby one's enemies or God's enemies will receive judgment and punishment. The imprecations found in the book of Psalms comprise the most complex theological issue.[footnoteRef:3] [3: Ellsworth, Roger. Opening up Psalms. Opening Up Commentary. (Leominster: Day One Publications, 2006)]

Notably, unlike other books of the Bible, the book of Psalm, in whole or part, comprise of the intercessory prayers, which the Psalmist wrote.[footnoteRef:4] However, the book is unique, and many users have continued to sing the Psalms. Moreover, the condemnations, curses, and imprecations for enemies have created many issues for scholars, pastors, theology students, and theologians. The main issue is the evident incitation of God's vengeance and the wrath supposedly will behold His enemies. The imprecatory induce revulsion, moral and ethical dilemmas for Christians, mainly because they are disciplined in the law of Christ.[footnoteRef:5] [4: Carl. "A fresh look at the imprecatory Psalms."] [5: Surburg, Raymond F. "Interpretation of the imprecatory Psalms." Springfielder 39, no. 3 (1975): 88-102]

In addition, the anger and rage shown in the imprecatory Psalms are crucial parts of human beings since the fall of Adam and Eve. On the other hand, when Christians read the Bible, especially the New Testament, particularly on the issue of blessings and curses, or love for enemies, and prayer for persecutors, has made Christians perceive imprecations differently.[footnoteRef:6] Therefore, some of them have rejected the concept of praying the imprecations. However, praying imprecations, as shown in the Bible, is under the same moral and ethical principles put forward by the New Testament. [6: Day, John N. "The imprecatory psalms and Christian ethics." Bibliotheca Sacra 159, no. 634 (2002): 166-186.]

In this context, referencing New Testament accounts of imprecations, and appreciating that God knows it all, then, it is conclusive that the imprecatory Psalms are important aspects of prayer life, which need revitalization.[footnoteRef:7] There are several studies on this issue, and some have reported that the New Testament appears to have contradictions on the same. This is mainly because of the tension created by two aspects, which appear formerly; loving and cursing. In response, some studies have commented that the tension between these two aspects can be harmonized, and God's people can deal with them adequately, in respect to the dispensation at which they occur.[footnoteRef:8] [7: Shedd, William Greenough Thayer. Dogmatic Theology. Edited by Alan W. Gomes. 3rd ed. (Phillipsburg, NJ: P & R. Pub., 2003)] [8: Raymond F. "Interpretation of the imprecatory Psalms."]

In this regard, the character of God remains the same; therefore, the importance of God's ethical principles remains intact. In addition, referencing to this, when the Old testament believers felt that the imprecatory was not appropriate, the New testament believers were bound to feel the same in due time. While loving and blessing are attributes of believers in the two Testaments, cursing and calling for God's vengeance are considered ethical, and justified for hardened, deceitful, violent, immoral, and unjust sinners.[footnoteRef:9] Therefore, even if Christians are to seek reconciliation and endurance, forgiveness, and kindness, there comes a time when there is a need to impose justice, regardless of the source; God or Christians. [9: John N. "The imprecatory psalms and Christian ethics."]

Conversely, some Christians have questioned whether it is right to lament for divine vengeance and violence, this is in reference to the book of Psalms. Owing to this question, many scholars have come out to try answering this, which has further led to the scrutiny of Book of Psalms. Regardless of the nature of questions that may appear, the Bible is very clear, and owing to the fact that God inspired the writers of the Bible, then when Christians pray the imprecatory, they stand justified.[footnoteRef:10] [10: Kelley, Page H. "Prayers of troubled saints." Review & Expositor 81, no. 3 (June 1, 1984): 377-383.]

The Imprecatory

In the Book of Psalms, imprecatory psalms are particular literary genre, and they have distinguishing aspects; they must invoke judgment, and have elements of curses, and condemnations. The language used in the book is central to invocation of divine judgment on enemies of the psalmist and those of God. In addition, the psalmist's distress appears in highly figurative language, which obscures the typical nature of the suffering. The most frequent complaint voiced in the imprecatory is central to the plotting of enemies, including machinations of the ungodly. In addition, the imprecatory show focus on identifying ungodly enemies from whom the psalmist laments God for deliverance.[footnoteRef:11] [11: Thayer. Dogmatic Theology. Edited by Alan W. Gomes]

In the Book of Psalm, the enemies identified include sorcerers, including practitioners of black magic, and the curses spoken against them are powerful, which may cause harm to targeted people in the society.[footnoteRef:12] Moreover, finding verses with imprecatory is easy mainly because it appears in eighteen Psalms; however, that does not comprise labeling, but one that there are elements of the imprecatory. For example, the books of Psalms 1-41; 42-72; 73-89; and 107-150 have shown elements of imprecations, maledictions, and curses. Even if students often refer to prior studies, and other literatures to grasp the imprecatory language, it is imperative to comprehend the theological background of the Old Testament.[footnoteRef:13] [12: Page H. "Prayers of troubled saints."] [13: Page H. "Prayers of troubled saints."]

This is because, although there are instances of imprecatory in the New Testament it is evident that imprecatory begun in the Old Testament, and understanding the language used will help in identifying possible imprecatory, even in other books of the Bible. This is because it is possible that there are Christians who may pray imprecatory to their personal enemies. In this regard, the imprecatory has been misused. In such a case, some theological studies have stated that central to the enemy, Christians should always attempt to seek reconciliation, prior to prayers of vengeance against them.[footnoteRef:14] [14: Raymond F. "Interpretation of the imprecatory Psalms."]

Justifications of Imprecatory Prayers

Although there appears that there will always be debates concerning the legitimacy of the imprecatory Psalms, the Bible has given a variety of justifications for the prayers. In this context, scholars have suggested that awareness of ethical and revelation objectives of the prayers will enable Christians to comprehend the imprecatory Psalms. The purpose of the imprecatory prayer is to establish the righteous. Several scholars have provided their views concerning the prayers, and have stated that imprecatory should be in use in reference to the light of the teaching of the bible.[footnoteRef:20] [20: Roger. Opening up Psalms. Opening Up Commentary]

Moreover, Christians should not use curses on personal enemies, and prior to this prayers, Christians should always pray for the repentance of the people. In the case of Israel, the prayers did not hide the desire for vengeance, even when they came before God. In addition, when the people prayed for vengeance, they did not commit violence towards their oppressor; they left all to God who would impose the punishment.[footnoteRef:21] In this regard, when God judges the evildoers, He also invoked to establish the righteous. This is provided in the Bible, which is the main point of reference for all the justifications provided. [21: Page H. "Prayers of troubled saints."]

Although the imprecatory prayers appear to be harsh, actually the objective is to praise God at the end. This is so after the psalmist has been delivered, and it is closely related to the anticipation of rejoicing, mainly after the psalmist witnesses the vindication happening. Alternatively, when the evil people recognize the reward of righteousness, and view God as the ultimate judge of the earth, they will repent and appreciate that God's objective is to enhance justice on earth. The imprecatory prayers also show that God is the sovereign rule of the entire universe.

Moreover, the imprecatory prayers aim to protect the wicked from enjoying the same blessings as those enjoyed by the righteous. In reference to David, the Bible says that he prayed that those who endure in doing evil might fail to appear in the book of life. In addition, the imprecatory prayers provide the sinners with an opportunity to repent. Apparently, God will also judge ad humiliate His enemies for them to find God and accept Him as sovereign. For these aims, it is notable that from a divine point-of-view, the lamentations for judgment, or rather the imprecatory prayers have justifications from the Bible.[footnoteRef:22] [22: Carl. "A fresh look at the imprecatory Psalms."]

If Christians still hold that imprecatory prayers are moral and ethical, then they would want to refer to quotations made by Jesus, particularly on Psalm 69 and 109. In this context, Jesus suggested that David was speaking divine inspiration. David supposedly had uttered words put to his mouth by the Holy Spirit, when avid had used imprecatory messages in the quoted verses. Overall, when some Christians appear to be opposing the use of imprecatory in the church or Christian life, they should consider the contribution of the Holy Spirit in writing the imprecatory messages. Therefore, Christians should accept imprecatory Psalms because they are inspired by the power of God. They should do this without apology without depreciating the Holy Spirit.[footnoteRef:23] [23: Raymond F. "Interpretation of the imprecatory Psalms."]

The imprecatory Psalm was attempting to reconcile the earlier teachings found in the Old Testament books, and the New Testament, including the teachings of Jesus Christ. Therefore, it may be understandable that some Christians have different views in relation to this; they should understand that imprecations are central to the covenant made by God and Abraham. This is so when reference is made to the promise made by God to Abraham. From this, it is conclusive that the Psalmist was appealing for God to keep the covenant promise. Alternatively, the concept of loving and cursing one's enemies also appears to contradict the concept of the Bible, but the Bible has provided a harmonization on the same. In this regard, God is the ultimate judge, and He alone should provide the judgment on evildoers, including persecutors.[footnoteRef:24] [24: John N. "The imprecatory psalms and Christian ethics."]

Instances of Imprecation

In the Bible, there are several instances of imprecations. For example, Jesus cursed a fig tree, which could not bear fruits. In interpretation, the cursing of the fig tree directed to the faithless and fruitless Israelites who had rejected Jesus. Moreover, the cursed fig tree later on withered, and this portrayed the punishment expected on the enemies of God and His people.[footnoteRef:25] There is also a renowned instance in the Bible when Simon the sorcerer wanted to buy the power of the Holy Spirit from Peter. In that instance, Peter cursed the sorcerer. [25: Carl. "A fresh look at the imprecatory Psalms."]

However, Peter did this by giving the sorcerer an opportunity to repent from his wickedness, and this shows that, despite the curse or imprecatory prayer, there is still an opportunity to repent. In the book of revelation, there is a cry from the saints. The lamentation seeks to know why God had refrained from avenging the saints from their enemies.[footnoteRef:26] In the Old Testament, curses appear justified. Apparently, in the Book of Genesis, God openly promised Abraham that He would bless those who blessed him and his posterity, and subsequently curse those who would curse Abraham. [26: John N. "The imprecatory psalms and Christian ethics."]

In this regard, it is clear when God judged Balaam. Evidently, Balaam, was unable to curse Israel, therefore, they were to receive punishment for the attempt on Israel. Another verse in the book of Psalms suggests that the people who deserve curses were the rulers. This is because the rulers imposed judgment on the people, but this judgment was unfair. In addition, the rulers were entirely unjust, dishonest, and wicked. Therefore, the vengeance was justified mainly because of the ignorance they had shown to their subjects. The rulers held positions in the society, such as in the judiciary, but they only exploited the power vested in them.[footnoteRef:27] [27: John N. "The imprecatory psalms and Christian ethics."]

In the book of Corinthians, Paul, in the case of the incestuous man, he condemned the man to destruction by the power of God. One can also see Paul praying for punishment to Alexander and Hymenaues because of what they had done to Paul. Similarly, in the book of Matthew, Jesus denounced the scribes and Pharisees, and he announces punishment among the unrepentant and evil. Subsequently, Jesus also predicted doom on Tyre, Sidon, Sodom, Bethsaida and other towns including Capernaum.

Conclusion

The condemnations, curses, and imprecations for enemies have resulted to confusion for scholars, pastors, theology students, and theologians. The main issue is the evident incitation of God's vengeance and the wrath supposedly will behold His enemies, which appears to go against the intended plan for God to their people. After referring to both the Old Testament, and the New Testament accounts of imprecations, it is beyond question that the imprecatory Psalms are essential elements of a Christian's prayer life, which may call for revitalization. However, some Christians have argued whether it is right to cry for divine vengeance and violence, this is in reference to the book of Psalms and others in the two testaments.

Owing to the question, many scholars have come out to try offer answers to this, which has further led to the examination of Book of Psalms, including others, which have elements of condemnations, curses for enemies. From the Christian point-of-view, the issue of prayers for imprecation, they will involve several considerations because of the ethics outlined in the Bible. The issue has slowly induced debates, particularly in relation to the languages used in both the New and Old Testaments.

Mainly, in the issue of loving and cursing, has created immense tension and further contributed to the rejection of imprecatory prayers. Regardless of the nature of questions that emerge in this context, the Bible is very clear, and owing to the fact that God inspired the writers of the Bible, then when Christians pray the imprecatory, they stand justified before God. Although the Bible provides evident justifications for the use of imprecatory prayers, there are evident tensions, and possible arguments concerning the justifications of the imprecatory prayers.

Therefore, Christians must be careful to recognize that the goals of the prayers were to achieve glory and honor. In addition, the prayers' objectives were to make God's enemies repent, and viewing the prayers in the context of the Psalms and the Old Testament will play an essential role in efforts to comprehend them. Failure of doing this, Christians will have to continue battling with the underlying issues including questions of imprecatory prayers, due to the different interpretations concerning the vengeance cries.