Skip to main content
Term Paper Undergraduate 962 words

Kass's argument against selective abortion for fetal birth defects

~5 min read
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Essay 962 words

Communication: The "Goodness of Existence"

Exterminating a fetus simply because the life may have birth defects, according to Kass, is to obliterate the notion that life in and of itself is good. Existence is good, despite its nature according to Kass. There are currently no standards which dictate how such situations might be handled. These ideas are explored in greater detail below. Kass is very much opposed to the notion of interfering with nature, as well as producing a separate standard of existence for children who are artificially or "naturally" born with defects. Kass would argue that to punish the mother in one circumstance but not another "is blatantly anti-life, making it an offense to keep the baby alive and bring it to birth" (168).

Kass would definitely support the notion that even a "modest prolongation of life" would be satisfying. There is no virtue in the death of a young child according to Kass, or the untimely demise of anyone. He suggests that in fact all human beings must die, but it is not a state that should be inappropriately assigned to anyone.

Both decisions are value-based decisions; there are logical basis for sanctioning women who damage their children, or who engage in activities that are known to be harmful to unborn children, assuming their children are wanted to begin with.

Kass has noted that there are no standards established that adequately determine whether the benefit of certain technologies, such as the ability to reduce a life, is good or bad. He believes that humans, all humans, should be afforded some sort of dignity. The problem with exterminating a fetus simply because it has birth defects falls into the realm of ethics. To do so without regard to the fetuses potential to live a happy existence is to dehumanize that which is human.

659 Words Hidden
For example, exterminating a fetus merely out of preference to have a "normal" child is saying that the baby is not worthy of humanistic consideration.…
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2004). Kass's argument against selective abortion for fetal birth defects. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/communication-the-goodness-of-existence-169661

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.