Congressional speeches on slavery during the Compromise of 1850
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
¶ … Compromise of 1850
Forming a critical and objective response to these three speeches is far easier said than done. The issues involved, slavery and secession, are both fraught with implications both inside and out of the political realm, which can make objectivity simply impossible. A fair examination of the law during that period seems to necessitate racism, as the laws of slavery were inherently racist. At the same time, any other interpretation other than a completely fair one is, by definition, unfair. The three very different views expressed by William H. Seward, John C. Calhoun, and Daniel Webster illustrate the fact that these same issues were being dealt with during the time of the Compromise. It was impossible to give an answer that was both entirely consistent with law and the Constitution while at the same time upholding emerging moral sensibilities that are considered normative today, and each of these three men had to choose a compromise of their own in coming to their decision, some with greater success than others.
Despite the length and breadth of Seward's argument, it is rather too emotionally and rhetorically driven to be considered a serious scholarly answer to suggestions of compromise.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.