Disparate impact and disparate treatment in employment discrimination cases
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Disparate Impact / Disparate Treatment
DISPARATE IMPACT - DISPARATE TREATMENT
The objective of this work is to prepare a case study that illustrates disparate impact and a different case that illustrates disparate treatment. Compare and contrast the two cases. Reviewed will be: (a) a brief description of the relevant facts; (b) the ruling and reasoning of the court; - the specific implications of the ruling; and (d) appropriate case citations.
Oftentimes the difference between the 'disparate treatment' and 'disparate impact' of employees is misunderstood. This review will examine two cases in order to make the differentiation in these two types of claims against employers. The first case examined in this study is one in which managers at the Ford Company in Michigan sued their employer on a 'disparate impact' claim. The second case examined is one in which an individual sued her employer in Louisiana under the 'disparate impact' claim and the court made it clear that the case was in actuality a 'disparate treatment' type case.
THE FACTS
In one case approximately 60 managers sued the Ford Company in a Michigan state court making the claim that the performance management process had a 'disparate impact' on older workers. Stated in the work entitled: "A Cutback that Cuts the Wrong Way" is that: "Employment discrimination claims generally are brought under one of two theories.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.