Clear and effective communication goals were met using positive educational interventions.

Longitudinal and sample size.

Good basic, lacks lengthy literature review. Data may be extrapolated, but further work needs to be done using larger, more diverse sample.

Melnyk, B., et.al.

Evidence-based Practice: Step-by-Step Igniting a Spirit of Inquiry.

2009

What is the effectiveness of an evidence-based practice format on collaborative inquiry.

Meta-Analysis and presentation of package.

None other than previous research.

Literature review and meta-analysis.

This is a presentation of a model approach suggested by an experienced nursing professor.

None for type of study.

Shows nurses how to use knowledge and skills to implement EBP consistently as part of the best practices of contemporary nursing care.
Nadzan, D. And Westergaard, F.

Pediatric Safety in the Emergency Department

2008

What are the basic risk factors in contemporary neonatal medicine?

Meta-Analysis and literature review.

Thirteen studies and previous recommendations

Commission update and policy recommendation

Risk factors differ for children and adults; enhanced pediatric presence is important to mitigate this difference.

Small meta-analysis, greater identification of problem and solution.

Developed for lay political audience, not as scientifically robust as one might expect or need.