Gun Control Has Been A Controversial Subject Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 6 Subject: Law - Constitutional Law Type: Essay Paper: #89134033 Related Topics: Gun Control, Gun Control Laws, Controversial Issues, Arms Control
Excerpt from Essay :

Gun control has been a controversial subject for the public and the government. Obama administration has come under attack for its silence on the issue. In September 2008, the president promised people that he wouldn't take away their guns, and since then, he has not done anything to introduce stricter laws thus attracting serious criticism from many quarters including the Brady campaign in 2010. (Altman, 2011) With gun-related incidents on the rise, many wonder why gun control is not a priority for our government. In this country, we definitely needed stricter gun control laws to be able to better address the alarming rise in gun-related incidents.

Gun laws in the country have become tougher over the years but still they are not as strict as some may desire. The result is series of horrific incidents in which tens of young men and women lost their lives. School shootings such as the one that occurred last year at Virginia Tech University have generated serious uproar together with parents' desperate pleas for stricter gun control laws.

The grief the followed such incidents also resulted in political measures that had some influence on gun control laws. However these laws are still too broad and thus fail to provide adequate protection against gun-related violence. By broad, we mean, federal laws do not offer specific legislation on guns on the campus or guns held for a certain purpose. Instead it offer an umbrella protection to everyone by making laws which are definitely worth their weight in gold but are not actually imposed by all states. The gaps between state and federal gun control laws make the problem even worse.

Federal gun control policy is simple: firearms must not reach irresponsible or dangerous people. This approach is particularly uncontroversial and hence approved by most quarters. Some of the key laws in this regard...


These laws should have been good enough to stop some incidents like the Virginia Tech massacre but the reason they failed lies in gaps existing between state and federal laws. Due to these gaps, Seung-Hui Cho was never reported to the federal police as he has already been termed mentally ill. According to 1968 federal law, people who are "adjudicated as a mental defective" are prohibited from possessing firearms. This is probably the most significant piece of legislation on gun control in last 50 years. Even though attempts have been made to pass other laws too, none have been as significant in their impact as the Gun Control Act of 1968. The main objectives of the Act were as follows:

(1) Eliminating the interstate traffic in firearms and ammunition that had previously frustrated state and local efforts to license, register, or restrict ownership of guns.

(2) Denying access to firearms to certain congressionally defined groups, including minors, convicted felons, and persons who had been adjudicated as mental defectives or committed to mental institutions.

(3) Ending the importation of all surplus military firearms and all other guns unless certified by the Secretary of the Treasury as "particularly suitable for ... sporting purposes."

The country needs stricter gun control laws but a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision may give another message. In June 2008, U.S. Supreme court gave an emphatic nod to firearm owners when it overturned a Washington DC ban on possession of guns. No other recent decision was as vital in significance as this one since it offered an interpretation of the Second Amendment and also explained how constitution treats the subject. In writing the majority opinion, Justice Scalia, ruled that the Constitute does not infer "the absolute prohibition of handguns held and used for self-defense in the home.

For this reason gun control laws are definitely one of the most controversial issues in the country. Even though we acknowledge the need for stricter gun control laws, the Supreme Court interpretations of the Constitutions and other rights, often create a hurdle for the implementation and passing of these laws. Jenson (2007) writes: "Gun control legislation has had a long and inconsistent history in the…

Sources Used in Documents:


Jeffrey M. Jenson, "Aggression and Violence in the United States: Reflections on the Virginia Tech Shootings," Social Work Research 31.3 (2007)

Altman, Alex. 2011. "Why Obama's silence on gun control pleases no one" Time magazine. Feb 07.

Gwen Fill, Brady Gun-Control Bill Imperiled by Rules Dispute.

Alex Altman, Future of Gun Control, 2008, Accessed 04/28/11 from,8599,1818325,00.html

Cite this Document:

"Gun Control Has Been A Controversial Subject" (2011, April 28) Retrieved August 2, 2021, from

"Gun Control Has Been A Controversial Subject" 28 April 2011. Web.2 August. 2021. <>

"Gun Control Has Been A Controversial Subject", 28 April 2011, Accessed.2 August. 2021,

Related Documents
Gun Control and Ownership in the U.S.
Words: 3138 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Law - Constitutional Law Paper #: 98208421

Gun Control in United States Gun control Gun control is a particularly controversial topic in the contemporary society, as especially in the U.S. people have been accustomed to living in a culture focused on guns. Factors like the Second Amendment in the Bill of Rights influenced people to identify with an environment that is widely supportive with regard to the masses having access to guns. The U.S.' history made it possible for

Gun Control and Laws Regulating
Words: 1035 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Law - Constitutional Law Paper #: 52456408

The NRA has furthermore involved itself in controversial issues related to the right to possess firearms. One such issue revolves around an advertisement involving a demonstrator having been beaten by soldiers. The premise of the ad was that all persons should be allowed to carry guns in order to defend themselves and their constitutionally guaranteed rights. Furthermore a dichotomy was proposed between tyranny and armed citizens. According to the

Gun Control: Argumentative
Words: 1411 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Law - Constitutional Law Paper #: 60997289

Gun control is one of the most polarizing issues of our time. Because this is such a controversial subject, it is actually harder to make a coherent case -- others are arguing in circles, twisting facts to suit their agendas, and misusing statistics as a matter of routine. This does not mean that we cannot have a reasonable discussion about the subject of gun control, just that we seldom do.

Gun Control Restricting Rights or Protecting People
Words: 1201 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Law - Constitutional Law Paper #: 88436473

Gun Control: Restricting Rights or Protecting People The leading nation in the number of deaths resulting from gun related violence is United States. It is also noteworthy that about half of all the American homes possess a gun. The United States have consequently, taken the initiative to control the possession and distribution of guns. However, this is not without challenges and criticisms. Some of the people support gun ownership control, whereas

Gun Control in the 21st
Words: 5200 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Law - Constitutional Law Paper #: 51492225

Hence, while ratifying the U.S. Constitution, the Virginia convention passed a resolution specifying: "That the people have a right to keep and bear arms; that a well-regulated militia, composed of the body of the people trained to arms, is the proper, natural, and safe defense of a free state;" It is, therefore, clear that the central issue that led to the adoption of the Second Amendment, as part of the

Gun Control Advocates Argue That
Words: 4264 Length: 16 Pages Topic: Law - Constitutional Law Paper #: 92626149

Opponents of gun control became more proactive and in 1977 after the capture of NRA leader, they began to harm the reputation of the GCA officers and executives. They aimed to scare the gun owners into thinking that they will be harassed and prosecuted for possessing guns. Opponents of gun control pushed the Carter administration to remove the proposals which aimed at changing the execution of the laws. After this