Healthcare Alcoholics And Liver Transplantation Article Critique

They also reject the argument that public support for transplantation will endure something bad if it becomes known that donated organs are being used for alcoholics. There is an extensive reluctance to consider people with alcoholic cirrhosis for liver transplantation. The authors of this article do a good job of presenting both sides of the argument about whether alcoholics should be eligible for liver transplants. They present both a moral argument and a medical argument and compare and contrast both sides before drawing their conclusion. They illustrate the screening and selection process for liver transplant contenders in a concise manner. At the end the authors dissect the objection to the moral argument and the medical argument of not allowing alcoholics to receive liver transplants. They reply to both of these objections with the reasons as to why alcoholics should be allowed to receive transplants. In the end they conclude...

...

It did a very good job of presenting the evidence in a way that someone who was not that familiar with the subject matter was still able to understand. This was a very informative article that lays out all the information necessary for a person to make an informed decision. Even though the authors come to their own conclusion on what is appropriate, the article leaves room for the reader to form their own opinion and draw their own conclusion.

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Cohen C & Benjamin M. (1991). Alcoholics and liver transplantation. The Ethics and Social

Impact Committee of the Transplant and Health Policy Center. Journal of American

Medical Association. 265, pp. 1299-1301


Cite this Document:

"Healthcare Alcoholics And Liver Transplantation" (2011, June 25) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/healthcare-alcoholics-and-liver-transplantation-42757

"Healthcare Alcoholics And Liver Transplantation" 25 June 2011. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/healthcare-alcoholics-and-liver-transplantation-42757>

"Healthcare Alcoholics And Liver Transplantation", 25 June 2011, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/healthcare-alcoholics-and-liver-transplantation-42757

Related Documents

2003, p. 247). The use of NSAID has been associated with increased risks of gastrointestinal bleeding in unselected patients, approximately five-fold for musculoskeletal pain and two fold for secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease with low-dose aspirin (Clinical Guideline 17: Dyspepsia 2004). Therefore, depending on the level of pain management required, a simple analgesic that can be used for pain management is paracetamol; this preparation does not cause bleeding of the

Bioethics: Transplant Case Study thorough examination of any "real life" ethical question involves the examination of all of the issues at hand. It is no different for issues of problematic bioethics. Thus, in consideration of the famous "botched heart transplant story," one must ask the salient questions, "what went wrong," "what should have been done," and "what can one do to insure that this issue will be less likely to

Program Proposal to Address Cirrhosis due to AlcoholismIntroductionThis proposal focuses on the issue of cirrhosis due to alcoholism, specifically targeting adults with alcohol use disorder (AUD) in the urban community of New Orleans, Louisiana. It describes the geographic region and population, the epidemiologic characteristics, and the health outcome it aims to improve. The program\\\'s design is culturally sensitive and incorporates ethical considerations for all eligible participants. The funding strategy combines

Ethics Abe and Mary had an extremely difficult decision to make. The couple did indeed have a child to save the life of Annisa. It could be possible that in the future Marissa-Eve's relationship could be harmed by this truth. Eve may feel as though her sister's life is more important than her own. In many ways Eve was treated as a means to an end because her life was

Insurance Discrimination The number of people who need a liver transplant is currently far greater than the number of donor livers available. Unfortunately, this can lead to discrimination by insurance companies against alcoholics who they believe have caused their own ill health and are, therefore, less deserving of the liver than other individuals. However, medical principles should guide treatment procedures not prejudice. Alcoholics should have the same access to health care

Christian Biotechnology: Not a Contradiction in Terms Presented with the idea of "Bioethics" most people in the scientific community today immediately get the impression of repressive, Luddite forces wishing to stifle research and advancement in the name of morality and God. Unfortunately, this stereotype too often holds true. If one looks over the many independent sites on the Internet regarding bioethics, reads popular magazines and publications, or browses library shelves for