Homeric Epics -- A Comparison Term Paper

PAGES
6
WORDS
2127
Cite

There is a sense of will in Achilles' gentleness towards the man, and his willingness to touch Priam's sleeve that night. In other words, human and divine reconciliation and pity is not simply a law, humans must accept the will of the gods, but they are also capable of choosing to add or subtract the misery of the world by showing pity to their fellow humans. Odysseus' cleverness, although aided by the gods, is also partly drawn from his own resourcefulness and character, as well as merely because Athena helps him. Achilles makes what is said to be the greatest gift to Priam, that of Hector's body. In Greek custom, gifts were customary to give to visitors. With such a gift, Achilles gives up his determination to mourn Patroclus for all time, and becomes the 'perfect' host who puts his own needs aside for the needs of his guest. In contrast, the suitors abuse the notions of hospitality of the gods, eating all of Odysseus' food and wine, and paying court to his wife to convince her that her husband is dead and she should marry again. The vulnerability of humankind is most evident when one is a stranger in a strange land, hence the need to protect one's guest, even if one's guest is an enemy -- thus by acknowledging human vulnerability, one acknowledges the will of the gods again, but still shows one's own strength of character and refusal to add to the miseries of Zeus' jar.

A combination of deference and will is what is necessary to achieve the ultimate goal, the ability to carry on a legacy through one's son. This is validated from Book I on in the "Odyssey" as Telemachus seeks his father, to bring order once again to the kingdom. Telemachus has a life-fulfilling...

...

He is a son who is a living legacy of his father, who will carry on his father's name if he can bring the kingdom to right and drive the suitors out. In contrast, Priam has a dead legacy -- he is grateful to gain Hector's body once again, but his other sons Paris and Astyanax will not replace the greatness of Hector, and he is burying his child before his time. Likewise, Peleus and Achilles do not have an equal fulfillment of a legacy that will be carried on. This is not because Odysseus is better than the other fathers, or more pious, but because of the capricious will of the gods.
Thus survival is a mix of reliance upon good hospitality, one's piety and luck, and also one's destiny. Odysseus is more pious and beloved by Athena than his crew, thus he survives and they do not -- however, Achilles is not more pious than Hector, yet it is he who bestows the body of Hector upon the gods. Even the gods themselves doubt about the best way to extract Hector's body. Thus, rather than a coherent statement about the folly of humankind that develops from "Iliad" to "Odyssey," it would be more apt to say that the books have similar themes, but cannot come to a strict resolution about the single, unified 'right' way to behave in a world where one can never be sure of one's fate, only be sure that the best way to live is not to add more misery through impiety and violence towards one's host or guest in an already frustrating world.

Works Cited

Homer. "The Iliad." Trans. Robert Fagles. New York: Penguin, 1990.

Homer. "The Odyssey." Trans. Robert Fagles. New York: Penguin, 1996

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Homer. "The Iliad." Trans. Robert Fagles. New York: Penguin, 1990.

Homer. "The Odyssey." Trans. Robert Fagles. New York: Penguin, 1996


Cite this Document:

"Homeric Epics -- A Comparison" (2005, November 02) Retrieved April 18, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/homeric-epics-a-comparison-69172

"Homeric Epics -- A Comparison" 02 November 2005. Web.18 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/homeric-epics-a-comparison-69172>

"Homeric Epics -- A Comparison", 02 November 2005, Accessed.18 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/homeric-epics-a-comparison-69172

Related Documents

Zeus of the Greeks The pantheon of Greek gods is still with us today: our planets are named after them (or, rather, after their Roman titles); their stories still enthrall ; and their narratives have shaped entire continents (Europe takes her name from Europa -- carried off on the back of Zeus who had changed himself into a bull). This paper will analyze Zeus as the greatest of the Greek gods

Zeus -- the Father of
PAGES 6 WORDS 1973

The figure of Zeus in the form of a human being also played a great role in Greek art. The Greek sculptor Lysippos was widely known and admired for his monumental statues of Zeus. Perhaps this is why he was asked to create a full-size portrait of Alexander the Great now known as the Scraper, a Roman copy after the original bronze statue made around 330 B.C.E. According to legend, Lysippos

Zeus also acted on principle to create social order at Olympia by waging war on his own father. However, Zeus was just in his treatment of the vanquished Titans, eventually granting their freedom (Morford & Lenardon p. 78). Zeus's story mirrors that of the Greeks in their skillful fashioning of political and social structures out of disparate and geographically distinct peoples. Zeus can even suggest the evolution from a polytheistic

Greek Mythology and Zeus
PAGES 3 WORDS 1332

ABC/123 Version X Divine Roles Across Cultures HUM/105 Version Divine Roles Across Cultures Select one common divine role that recurs in world mythology. Possible options of divine roles include the following: father or mother divinities, divinities of war, home or hearth divinities, divinities of love, divinities of wisdom, divinities of medicine or health, divinities of the wind, divinities of agriculture, divinities of the sky, ruler of all the gods, and so on. Identify the role

Peace or War in Homer
PAGES 6 WORDS 2107

Is it a sign of inconsistency in Athena that at the end of the Odyssey she echoes the sentiment of Zeus and sues for peace whereas in Book 4 of the Iliad she is all too eager to ignore the sentiment of her father and manipulate the warriors into shedding more blood? Again -- not necessarily. While, were it up to Zeus he would gladly see men work out their

As well I can see that she has wore royal headdress that usually a king wears but the uraeus (cobra) is linked with the female individuals, though both kings and queens use it. The uraeus is linked to the sun god. Here I remember and you also know dear Zeus one of our beliefs that God took the eyes from Sun. This uraeus in front of her headdress makes me