Skip to main content
Article Critique Undergraduate 932 words

Needs-based planning model for Canada's registered nursing shortage

~5 min read 1 section
Abstract

Historically, medical worker shortages have been calculated using provider to patient ratios or estimates of demand, but both methods have significant problems because neither directly addresses patient need. Murphy and colleagues (2012) developed and tested a needs-based model to predict nursing shortages in Canada for the next 10 years; however, the real value of this model is its ability to test interventions for the desired outcomes by health policy makers. Based this model, simply increasing the nursing education enrollment will not address the nursing shortage, a finding that undermines the validity of the most common nursing-shortage policy intervention in use today. In addition, the model revealed that a combination of other interventions could easily alleviate the current and future nursing shortage.

✍️ How to write this paper — writing tools ▾
Essay 932 words

¶ … Planning: Canadian RN Shortage

Applied Needs-Based Planning: Canadian RN Shortage

Murphy and colleagues (2012) investigated possible interventions to eliminate the growing registered nursing (RNs) shortage in Canada's health system. Rather that base their model on a patient to provider ratio, which ignores changes in health needs across demographics, or a demand-based model, which ignores inequalities in health care access, they proposed a more responsive needs-based model. In essence, the health of the population is quantified, specific goals established, and then the number of nurses needed to achieve these population-wide goals estimated. Using this approach also provides considerable latitude in determining the appropriate ratio of doctors to nurses to aids, which will provide the optimum outcome. In other words, Murphy and colleagues view the needs-based model as the best way to determine interventions intended to eliminate staffing inefficiencies in the health care system.

A system dynamics-based simulation model was used to calculate the difference between the requirements for RNs and supply (Murphy et al., 2012). The data fed into the model included the size of the served population, the prevalence of health and illness, risks for future illness, and RN and provider productivity in full time equivalents (FTE). This model was designed to allow policymakers to experiment with the impact of increasing or reducing different variables, rather than to simply make future predictions, thereby determining which policy decisions could have the greatest positive impact on health care delivery efficiency. The validity of the model, according to the authors, depends on the quality of the data used.

Plugging relevant data currently available into the model predicted a shortage of 10,000 FTE RNs for 2007 (Murphy et al., 2012).

629 Words Hidden
Based on current health trends among the Canadian population, such as an expanding elderly demographic and continued increases in the prevalence of obesity, diabetes, and…
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2013). Needs-based planning model for Canada's registered nursing shortage. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/planning-canadian-rn-shortage-applied-98214

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.