Interruptions On Clinical Task Completion.  Article Critique

PAGES
4
WORDS
1254
Cite

The results of a study like this always poses considerable challenges, including how to logically as well as accurately presenting the statistics and discussion of the results. This is where the statistical experts involved in the study clearly provided their assistance. The results begin with a description fo the total time, number of individual task actions recorded, and total TOT. The main finding was that an average of 12.8% of physician time was spent multitasking. The discussion also made clear distinctions between the task types completed as well as the seniority of physicians. Specific interruption rates were recorded for each task category and seniority level as well as expertise were also recorded. Hence, the central premise and hypothesis of the article was substantiated by the findings, each of which related to a very specific and clear category. Interestingly, the main result supported the premise that an increase of interruptions also resulted in an increase in task compromise or error, regardless of expertise or seniority level of the professionals involved.

The tables are well positioned throughout the Results section, completing the information presented in the narrative of the section. These include the specific statistics that inform the results and further discussion of the study. Furthermore, the complexity level increases throughout the section, with complex calculations at the end of the Results section informed by the more basic statistical information provided at the beginnings.

The Discussion section begins with a brief summary of the statistical findings presented in the Results section. This is followed by a brief consideration of the remedies that physicians themselves created for their task completion rates, as well as those suggested by the findings of the study. This section also includes other similar investigations to inform the findings of the current study, as well as to suggest possible remedies for the challenges faced within the hospital setting.

Importantly,...

...

The fact that these two sections warranted a focus of their own indicates the relative lack of research attention that has been given to the specific premise of the study. One specific limitation was the relatively narrow scope of the investigation, including only one organization of focus. Hence, there is no differentiation in terms of work organization or internal culture, which could influence the results. This in itself is a basis to warrant further study. To mitigate this limitation, numerous other studies were sued for comparison purposes.
The main and most important finding was that the interruptive nature of the clinical environment is likely to impact upon patient safety. Hence, this is the most important premise of future study.

The Reference section includes an impressive range of empirical studies and academic resources, ranging from as early as 1993 to as recent as 2009. Clearly, each reference document was selected for its relevance to the study at hand. Busy clinical environments and interruption effects are not a new problem facing medical personnel and patients. Hence, the inclusion of earlier sources is warranted by the nature of the hypotheses investigated.

In general, the article appears to be very well written and organized, addressing the problem as clearly and concisely as possible. Although the limitation of focus is indeed an issue, this is addressed by including other studies and results, as well as comparing the specific results for the organization in question with those generally found across the profession.

Perhaps the article could have used more focus on suggestions for a remedy regarding the clinical environment and patient safety. However, the information as presented is ample to suggest future research of the kind and possible remedies that are perhaps beyond its current scope.

Sources Used in Documents:

Reference section includes an impressive range of empirical studies and academic resources, ranging from as early as 1993 to as recent as 2009. Clearly, each reference document was selected for its relevance to the study at hand. Busy clinical environments and interruption effects are not a new problem facing medical personnel and patients. Hence, the inclusion of earlier sources is warranted by the nature of the hypotheses investigated.

In general, the article appears to be very well written and organized, addressing the problem as clearly and concisely as possible. Although the limitation of focus is indeed an issue, this is addressed by including other studies and results, as well as comparing the specific results for the organization in question with those generally found across the profession.

Perhaps the article could have used more focus on suggestions for a remedy regarding the clinical environment and patient safety. However, the information as presented is ample to suggest future research of the kind and possible remedies that are perhaps beyond its current scope.


Cite this Document:

"Interruptions On Clinical Task Completion " (2011, March 18) Retrieved April 26, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/interruptions-on-clinical-task-completion-3622

"Interruptions On Clinical Task Completion " 18 March 2011. Web.26 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/interruptions-on-clinical-task-completion-3622>

"Interruptions On Clinical Task Completion ", 18 March 2011, Accessed.26 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/interruptions-on-clinical-task-completion-3622

Related Documents

Cell Phones (Technology) On Communication Cell phones and other cellular communication equipment are omnipresent in today's digital age, with roughly 1.5 billion cellular phones used, at present, across the globe; on an average, 75 billion SMSs are sent globally, in a month (Merry, Domlija & Mackenzie, 2005). While the use of cellular communication has greatly contributed to the area of communication, cellular interferences have hampered functioning in various contexts, including

Chang Proposal - Milestone #4 [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] NR 451- Capstone Project Milestone #4: Design for Change Proposal Christopher D'Ambrose NR 451 Capstone Course Quality of patient care is a paramount concern of healthcare professionals. When nurses experience interruptions while they are working, the quality of care patients receive can be negatively impacted. Interruptions have been shown to disrupt working memory, disrupt on-duty focus, induce frustration and stress, contribute to accidents,

Secured real time protocol (SRTP) is also being identified to enhance the security parameter of WAN and LAN network elements. "SRTP provides protection with encryption keys for wired and wireless networks including bandwidth limited channels." (Guillen and Chacon 2009 P. 690). There is also a growing use of IP secure to protect organization from the interception of data over the LAN and WAN environment. To enhance network security, Chen, Horng,

Business Plan for Health Care Informatics The purpose of this paper is to present a business plan for the implementation of syndromic surveillance system. The major sections of the business plan are: identification of the key objectives and scope of the project; the project life cycle, budget estimate, staff planning, and activity timeline; major risks and vulnerabilities of the project; success evaluation methods, and communication plan for the primary stakeholders. This

Family Nurse Practioner Family Nurse Practitioner (FNP) in family surburban clinic The paper provides information on an advanced nursing role (Family Nurse Practitioner). It consists of the requirements of the nursing role in terms of certification, education qualifications, and also the persons responsible for certifying nurses for this role. The paper discusses the job duties associated with the practice. It creates the understanding of collaborative associations that promote success of the nursing

Family Assessment Description of Family / Genogram Profile of Family The 'T' family has been chosen for the completion of this assignment. Mr. T is the 95-year-old patriarch. His wife and mother of their two children is Mrs. T, 92 years of age. Their children are Wilma and Leon; ages 60 and 62 respectively. Theirs is a nuclear family. Both husband and wife are quick to affirm their lives are full of joy