Martin Buber's I-it and I-thou relational principles
✍️ How to write this paper — writing tools ▾
it vs. Thou
Let us assume that life can be led according to different principles. These principles could be the one of "it" and "thou." They would naturally dictate our values and beliefs and with those would built our expectations and desires. Naturally, the final result would be a behaviour perfectly patterned according to the primary belief. The two principles could be translated into the ones of "to have" and "to be" according to one of their potential meanings. The present paper has the purpose of presenting the implications which arise from adopting one or the other.
Let us think for example of a day in life in which everything is treated as an It. Treating everything as an it means objectifying everything. It is normal to treat things as an it because this is what they are. There are however people who get extremely attached to their earthly possessions treating things in a very possessive manner. But generally treating things as mere tools which serve for achieving a purpose or another implies a certain detached attitude.
What happens when you treat other people as being it? The same attitude of detachment is installed. In terms of relationships, this detachment is nothing less but indifference. In other words, one will not care less about the lives of the others. One would be indifferent to the pain and suffering of the others. This could be easy considering how exciting the perspective of caring for yourself only is. But since people live in communities, interact with each other and depend on one each other even if this happens involuntarily, the only possible consequence is general conflict. Homo homini lupus becomes the most accurate phrase to describe the situation.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.