There are definitely some parallels that are found between the passages in the book of James II and Hosea that are examined within this documents. In general, the former denotes a concept that the latter provides very specific examples for. What is key about this relationship is that these passages have contemporary relevance.
Scriptures of James and Hosea
There are a few poignant similarities between the messages in the scriptures of James 2: 8-11 and Hosea 11: 1-3. A thorough analysis of these passages indicates that they each adhere to the same thematic issues and deal with similar subject matter. However, there appears to be a hierarchy in the way that these two scriptures relate to one another. The passage in James sets forth a specific principle in which the passage in Hosea provides an example.
The dominant theme found in the aforementioned verses from James is for individuals to heed the word of God. The word of God is law, and is referenced in this passage as royal law -- which is an allusion to the Ten Commandments. In buttressing this theme, the author of this passage expressly forbids favoritism and keeping some, yet not all, of God's commandments. However, the principle theme is that Christians must follow God's words as commandments and as law. The allusion to "royal law" (James, 1973) is important, because it refers to the time period in which Moses was leading the Israelites from Egypt. This time period is referred to in the previously mentioned passage in Hosea, in which God recollects that "out of Egypt I called my son" Israel (James, 1973). The main theme of this passage is obedience, or the lack thereof that the Israelites exhibited. In these verses God also recalls that there were Israelites who did not obey him and his words (with which he "called" the Israelites). Failure to obey God's words is a failure to obey his law. This passage also refers explicitly to the Ten Commandments, as there is a reference in the passage to Israelites worshipping other things instead of God "Baals" and "images" (Hosea, 1973). These examples of failure to heed the commandment of worshipping nothing else other than God are an example of the theme of failure to heed God's law in James.
These two passages primarily function at the personal and corporate levels of application. At the personal level, it is important to understand that these themes of heeding God's word and obedience, respectively, are not abstract concepts, especially when considered in their "cultural, historical, or theological context" (Akers, 2005). Each person who commits himself to God and to the religion of Christianity must also commit himself or herself to God's commandments and laws. Personally, these passages are eloquent reminders of these facts, and actually serve as warnings for people not to transgress God's word. By personifying Israel as a child, the Hosea scriptures are actually reinforcing the idea of obedience at a personal level. Additionally, the personal level of application is strongly suggested in the passage from James by the frequency of the use of the pronoun "you" (James, 1973), in which the individual is emphasized. In this respect, the nation of Israel is a specific example of those who must follow God's law, which is the principle theme of the James passage.
The second level of application (at the corporate level) is just as important as the first one, and evinced within the scriptures just as much. The collective notion of Christianity as a religion encompassing a group of people -- and not just a few individuals -- exists in both passages. In James, this fact is implied by the choice of diction. The term 'law' is one which is applicable to many people of various differences. Laws do not exist for single people, they are used to govern groups. The corporate level of application is found in these particular verses in Hosea in the reference to the nation of Israel. As such, the reader can understand that the call to obedience does not just apply to individuals, but to the nation with which God formally (through his commandments) established his covenant. Again, this fact provides a tangible example of the theme found in James.
The areas of application related to these scriptures include those of doctrine and of worship and devotion. The maintaining of the law of God's words is a basic tenet of the theology of Christianity. The theme of obedience to God illustrated in the Hosea passage is aligned with the concept of maintaining God's law, and also plays an integral part in how Christians should manifest their devotion to God -- by doing that which he has ordained. On the one hand obeying God's commandments are an important theological idea; practically, one must adhere to these themes in order to properly worship God at both the corporate and personal levels.
In terms of applying these themes to contemporary matters and relevance to modern society, it is difficult to distinguish their applications at the personal and corporate levels because both levels actually incorporate the same idea. For every individual who is part of the Christian faith, it is necessary that he or she obeys God's commandments in a highly pragmatic fashion. The law of the Ten Commandments governs both personal and collective behavior. From a personal perspective, it helps provide a series of moral guidelines to dictate behavior that is worthy of Christianity -- such as by keeping one from stealing the property of another.
You’re 85% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.