Migration and Crime Immigration is one of the major issues that attracted significant attention in the United States, especially because of the increase in security concerns in the country and throughout the world. The significance of this issue is demonstrated in the role immigration policies played in the recent presidential campaigns. Additionally, international migration has found its way to the forefront of security policies, agendas and issues in the United States. As the number of immigrants to the United States has increased rapidly in recent years, the perception of immigration as a security threat has also developed. Apart from attracting concerns from policymakers, the relationship between migration and crime has also been the subject of news publications and opinion pieces. For instance, Rick Gladstone recently published an opinion piece in the New York Times to demonstrate that there is no link between migration and crime in the United States.

Article Analysis

The United States has witnessed anti-immigrant backlashes in the recent past based on the perceptions that foreigners (immigrants) cause crimes and other problems (Gladstone, 2016). Despite the increase of these backlashes and concerns, Gladstone (2016) states that statistical studies in the United States show that immigrants are more law-abiding residents than natives despite of their education, race or class. Therefore, immigrants are usually utilized as scapegoats on the issue of crime despite the lack of concrete evidence to demonstrate any causal link between migration and crime in the country. Based on the findings of a recent study that utilized FBI data, census data, and other statistical data, the incarceration rates of native-born Americans are considerably higher than those of migrants (Gladstone, 2016). These findings support the results of previous researches for more than a century that have indicated that there is no link between migration and crime in the United States.

While immigrants have always been targeted by the public and policymakers, most of them are not criminals as shown by the commonly accepted definitions of this term. In this article, Gladstone (2016) argues that there is no link between migration and crime simply because immigrants come to the United States to work hard rather than to commit crimes. This is essentially means that the reason for the less incarceration rates among immigrants as compared to those of native-born Americans is attributable to the fact that they work harder than native-born Americans. Despite the lack of substantial evidence, the perception that immigrants commit crimes has continued to thrive over the years.

This article highlights the debate and controversies that have dominated policy making initiatives in the United States regarding immigration and crime. According to Morawetz & Das (2009), concerns on whether local police officers should engage in the enforcement of federal immigration law has generated numerous controversies and debates in the current political climate. The controversy is largely fueled by the perception that there is causal link between migration and crime as highlighted in the article. Gladstone (2016) recognizes these perceptions and their impact on immigration policies though current statistical...

One of the missing elements in the article on this issue is the violation of immigration rules, which has played a critical role in shaping perceptions of the link between migration and crime. Some immigrants come to the United States by violating existing immigration policies and laws, which contributes to heightened concerns on crime rates among these people. While the status of immigrants in the United States has changed significantly in the recent past, the change does not provide a loophole for immigrants to enter the country illegally. In this case, the outright violation of immigration policies by some immigrants who enter the country is considered a criminal offense in itself. The violation of immigration policies when entering the United States has in turn acted as the basis of deportation. Actually, permanent immigrant residents have been the subject of deportation due to criminal offenses, which was enhanced by the enactment of AEDPA and IIRIA in 1996 (Morawetz, 2000). The significance and role of immigration policies should have been considered in this article when examining the link between migration and crime.
The second important element in the consideration of the relationship between migration and crime is the United States-Mexico border, which has been the subject of most immigration debates and policy initiatives. Curry et al. (2012) states that the number of agents deployed in America's northern border including the U.S.-Mexico border has increased significantly over the past few years i.e. since 9/11 terror attacks. This increase has been prompted by the ever-growing security threats posed by illegal immigrants to the United States. The extent of law enforcement in the borders is an important consideration when analyzing the link between migration and crime. In the article, Gladstone (2016) does not include this consideration but only focuses on existing statistical data on migration and crime. The inclusion of this element in the consideration could have helped in determining whether the decreased rate of crime among immigrants is partly influenced by enhanced security measures along the northern border.

While the article does not include these important considerations, its findings are supported by other publications that examine this issue. Riley (2015) argued that studies that date back to more than a century have shown that immigrants are less likely to engage in criminal activities and be incarcerated regardless of their nationality and legal status in the United States. According to a recent report by the Immigration Policy Center, the number of illegal immigrant population in the U.S. has tripped between 1990 and 2013 (Riley, 2015). During the same period, statistics by the Federal Bureau of Investigation indicate that the rate of violent crimes in the country has decreased by 48%. The decline has also occurred in other crimes include murder, aggravated assault, rape, and robbery. Immigrants also account for the lowest incarceration rates among young men for every ethnic group.

Law enforcement officers have fueled perceptions that there is a link between migration and crime through their actions. In this case, when an immigrant is arrested and convicted for crimes, he/she is mistakenly taken to be a representative of the entire immigrant population. For instance, the recent arrest of a Mexican national who was involved in the killing of a young woman in San Francisco should…