Leadership Vs. Management Research Paper

Length: 5 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Business - Law Type: Research Paper Paper: #31977485 Related Topics: Expert Witness, Leadership Development, Team Leadership, Leadership
Excerpt from Research Paper :

Leadership and Power 12 Angry Men

It is clear that Juror 8 is the typical example of Expert Power. Expert Power is based on the idea that knowledge drives the power of the individual in an organization or a group (Merchant, Media n.a.). Expaning this idea, the Expert Power means that an individual in an organization reaches a level where he can impose his leadership and power because he is able to work with particular terms, in a particular area and to bring relevant knowledge to a certain part of the discussion and analysis.

This is the case with Juror 8. Although he appears, in the beginning of the movie, as someone who is just not able to sentence someone to death without a prior discussion (the immediate condemnation bears the death penalty), he argues very thoroughly and applied the case. He shows that the evidence seems to be circumstantial, that two witnesses seem to be less reliable than initially believed, that the murder weapon is a strange choice and that, overall, there is reasonable doubt to the defendant's guilt. Juror 8 presents the case, although in a humble manner, as a veritable detective, showing the weaknesses of the accusation.

Coercive Power is defined as using threats and punishments, among other coercive instruments to impose one's will on the others. Juror 3 is the Coercive Power. He is the last that decides to change his vote and does so only to relieve his own problems with his son. Throughout the movie, he is the one who applies pressure on the other jurors, through different means. He verbally abuses Juror 5, when the latter switches his vote, of doing so out of subjectivism. He rants on different occasions and shouts "I will kill you!" To Juror 8 at one point.

Referent Power is linked to interpersonal relationships, to the way that an individual pushes and supports his position in a group by forming relationships with other individuals. I believe that Juror 8 is again the best example for this. Initially, he is entirely isolated in his position. However, he builds specific alliances with individuals he feels are isolated too, in their lives. These are Jurors number 5 and 11. This shows a very specific and pertinent knowledge of how psychology works:

...

Legitimate Power derives from some sort of recognition of an official power. There is nothing of this type here, although the jury has a nominal person in charge of coordinating operations such as voting. He is not necessarily influential in the way that the voting takes place or in the subsequent alliances between the jurors.

Reward Power is usually associated with incentives, namely that power derives from the use of incentives to support a certain position. In the case of the movie, we see a similar process with the Juror 7, who has tickets to a baseball game and who, as such, is willing to vote in whatever manner is necessary to obtain his freedom and passage to the game.

The Harvard Business Review is the best place to start an analysis of the differences between management and leadership. Nayar (2013) lists three main differences between management and leadership. These are counting vs. creating value, circles of influences vs. circles of power and leading people vs. managing work.

According to HBR, managers only count value rather than focus on creating value. At the same time, they look to creating circles of power and are set on controlling a group of people so that they can impose their decisions. As the following paragraphs will show, the movie shows the differences between management and leadership on all these different levels.

I think the discussion between management and leadership can only be understood in a contrast between Juror 3 and Juror 8. Juror 3 is obviously the managerial type. Throughout the movie, he is in a position to manage the jury and obtain a final guilty verdict. From this perspective, he is not necessarily a bad manager: he communicates well with his human resource, has a fixed objective and continuously pushes that objective to the other jurors.

He is, however, an unsuccessful manager because he is obtuse and does not look to outside facts to redefine his options. He is not flexible and cannot…

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

1. 5 Sources of Power in Organizations. On the Internet at http://smallbusiness.chron.com/5-sources-power-organizations-14467.html. Last retrieved on March 7, 2014

2. Nayar, Vineet, (2013), Three Differences Between Managers and Leaders. Harvard Business Review. On the Internet at http://blogs.hbr.org/2013/08/tests-of-a-leadership-transiti/. Last retrieved on March 7, 2014

3. N.a. (2009), 4 Stages of Group Development. On the Internet at http://www.leadershipjot.com/2009/04/20/4-stages-of-group-development/. Last retrieved on March 7, 2014


Cite this Document:

"Leadership Vs Management" (2014, March 07) Retrieved May 6, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-vs-management-184565

"Leadership Vs Management" 07 March 2014. Web.6 May. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-vs-management-184565>

"Leadership Vs Management", 07 March 2014, Accessed.6 May. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-vs-management-184565

Related Documents
Leadership Management Literature Abounds With
Words: 1436 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 63143910

Indeed, without these legitimacy criteria, a leader would not be able to influence followers to either change or progress towards organizational goals: "The acceptance of leadership from another person involves an implicit contract in which followers sacrifice some level of personal autonomy and pledge loyalty and effort to the leader.... The followers must be sure that the leader has the competency to lead effectively and the trustworthiness and loyalty

Leadership Management Assessment of Transformational
Words: 906 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 78255087

Sixth, his service commitment is exceptional, as he has been known to work with many customers to solve problems and help them get to their goals as hospitals and healthcare providers. Seventh, he is exceptionally resourceful and willing to move beyond traditional boundaries to accomplish greater tasks than would have been possible otherwise. Eighth, his focus on rewards and recognition is well-known throughout the entire healthcare industry, as is

Leadership Management Leadership Roles and
Words: 606 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 70265329

Therefore, I am finding that there is a benefit in creating an Assistant Manager position, through which these scheduling duties may be performed. This allows me the freedom to focus on the important matters of budgeting and financial planning. Indeed, during my years as the owner/operator at Southwest, I have become increasingly adept at the maintenance and interpretation of financial records, budgetary concerns, inventory flow and adherence to appropriate accounting

Leadership Management Effective Approaches Leadership Management...
Words: 1524 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 27902467

Leadership Management Effective Approaches Leadership Management Different personalities practice different management styles, while different management styles are suited to different personalities. It is very important for a manager to make sure that their employees are motivated and their work rates are up to the mark. The employees of any organization need to be motivated in order to maintain a fair attendance at the office along with enough motivation that employees would

Leadership Capability Relation Accepted Model Leadership Management....
Words: 2025 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 13210304

leadership capability relation accepted model leadership management. Part 1. 'Situational leadership redundant a task .' As a future leader teams, present arguments statement. Situational leadership The internal environment within economic agents is suffering dramatic changes within the modern day society and this is the result of numerous pressures from the internal and external environments, such as technology, competition or increasing demands from the various categories of stakeholders. In such a setting,

Educational Leadership Management Effectiveness Vs.
Words: 654 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 24178741

In that regard, a leader who gets things done through coercion as opposed to consensus could be regarded a successful but not an effective leader. Looked at from another perspective, successful leadership differs from effective leadership on the basis of emphasis. While emphasis in successful leadership is on power and position, the emphasis when it comes to effective leadership is often on the personal attributes of a leader. It