Essay Doctorate 4,752 words

Administrative problems facing local governments in developing countries

Last reviewed: November 19, 2012 ~24 min read
Abstract

The paper tackles the issue of administration in the local and national governance system in Brazil. It looks at the issue of decentralization, how it is implemented, how it affects the administration system and the possible challenges. It also looks at the public policies and how their implementation affects governance.

Public Administration in Brazil

PUBLIC ADMINSTRATION IN BRAZIL

The grassroots and rural development happen to be the main concern and responsibility of any responsive government in a political system. This because the power of political participation is significant in any developmental process of a country which has persistently eluded many people at the grassroots level. Brazil as a developing country needs to take into consideration the significant of efficient administrative responsibilities in all aspects of development. The local governments act a vital tool in promoting development and bringing positive change to the people. Presently the local governments have been mirrored with challenges that have made the entity inefficient to the local people. Development process is insignificant in instances that it does not impact the lives of the people positively in relation to the decision making process.

Public administration in Brazil

The Brazilian government, therefore, main objective of creating the local government was to deal with the efficient delivery of services to all the Brazilian people. It is evident that the local government has been faced with numerous challenges in the process of economic development, in the country. The main challenge facing the local governments in Brazil is provision of better quality life to the people. The local government urban initiatives have seen an increase from deviation of significant activities such as road construction, and other development programs to comprehensive maintenance and improvement of the residential environments. In the background, there are negative elements related to progress in terms of urbanization and national development that integrates Brazil economic growth (Burchfield et al. 2006). The country's rich green environment has been lost because of water pollution, disintegration of urban and rural societies, destruction of the waterside environment and traditional culture loss. The once beautiful scenery in many areas is gone because of a shift on emphasis that the country's economic growth has been coupled with setbacks. Administrative policies together with foregoing emphasis can be collectively termed as amenity-related initiatives.

Creation of comfy urban environments; defending and fostering of urban exquisiteness and charm is vital. The process entails preservation of areas found in the urban areas that have historic value for the country. Development of urban landscapes, as well as protection of water attachment areas is necessary for the people. The local governments need to develop suitable priority programs that protect the natural environment by incorporating them into the amenity-related agenda. The start of amenity related administration can easily be traced back to 1960s when people started becoming aware of the repercussions of environmental destruction and citizens role in the preservation. The process led to municipalities adopting sovereign bylaws and executing policies to defend areas having historic value.

The enactment of related legislation and review of associated policies were started at all levels. Apart from protection of such areas a rising number of local governments in the country are currently adopting bylaws and initiatives such as tree preservation, tree-planting, and safeguarding of notable clean water supply as part of the natural environment conservation. Other laws involving protection of the urban environment have been enacted. Inventive local authorities have put into practice policies that aggressively promote the conception of quality urban areas as well as stress on environmental conservation, which is a preventive measure. Many authorities have also adopted environmental policies, which take into consideration global environment and the local environments being part of amenity-related programs (Burchfield et al. 2006). Global founded local environmental laws ranging from recycling of wastes to building of recycling facilities to fight global warming will become extremely vital in the future, in Brazil.

IT revolution

The IT revolution which has taken over most parts of the country from the industrial to the economic sector and government administration forms the foundation of the contemporary society. The situation is evident in the application of the sophisticated information and technology in the creation of both the "e-government," and "local e-governments." The implementation of the new technological invention in Brazil for the local government has proved challenging in the efforts geared towards the provision of quality and efficient services. The objective of the mechanism is to enhance and facilitate smooth communication in government entities such as local government and establish the basis for advanced information.

The mechanism involves sharing and at the same time connecting the local governments in the entire country. In addition, the connection with other networks such as inter-ministerial network has been instrumental in linking up all the government sectors. At the same time, the development of the IT revolution have led to an increase of strict security measures in relation to those opposed to cyber attacks, cyber terrorism, internet crimes and web page tampering (Bengston, Fletcher, Nelson 2004). These elements have proved as setbacks in implementation of the process coupled with financial aspects. In the current, sophisticated world information and society persistent advances regarding information and technology seem to be in considerable demand. To ensure people needs are met a comprehensive approach in terms of development technology, system and management has to be considered. At the same time, a system adapted to the novel IT society is required as Local government entities need to adopt accordingly with advances in the technological revolution.

Decentralization

Political decentralization has to offer citizens and their elected representatives with enough power to make decisions regarding national issues. Ii is usually related to pluralistic politics as well as representative government and can also support democratization in terms of offering citizens and their representatives, authority in the formulation and policies implementation. Many advocates for political decentralization state that decisions made with total participation of the people are relevant and well informed. This is because they take into consideration the needs and interests of the local people contrary to those made by the national authorities. Brazil has embraced the notion by selection representatives from the local electorate which allows citizens to know their political representatives better. The situation also gives the elected officials a chance to understand the needs of their constituents. Political decentralization requires constitutional and statutory reforms pluralistic development of political parties, strengthening of legislatures, encouragement of efficient public interest groupings and development of local political units.

Constitution often codifies the rules touching on decentralized system by stating how they are supposed to function. Structurally, the advantageous architecture of such rules are quite straightforward as the constitutions need to be used to preserve the broad values of decentralization. Other elements include the responsibilities as well as rights of the different levels of government such as descriptions and foremost role of institutions at the local and national levels (Bengston, Fletcher, Nelson 2004). Brazilian government has put more laws which defines certain parameters associated with intergovernmental fiscal system as well as the institutional aspects of the local government organization. The mechanism involves accountabilities, procedures, remedies, key structures and regulations linked to each law that interpreted and explained practices of the policies. Laws that relate to tasks shared between sub-national and national governments need to be included in intergovernmental relations. Considerably greater aspect and specificity are offered in moving down the platform architecture all the way from Constitution down to Regulations. Equally, greater difficulty and an advanced degree of power are necessary to modify the provisions when moving from Regulations and the Constitution.

As decentralization seem to be an intricate social experiment alt need to be undertaken to ensure flexibility in changing of specificity involving implementation instruments., At the same time, enshrining both political and philosophical ideologies in the Constitution and the operation structures in terms of the laws is significant. Apart from the substantive law, a country's bureaucratic laws can have reflective impacts on the decentralization success efforts. For instance, when local expenditures have to be audited by a central authority, then rigidities must be introduced to make the benefits of decentralization difficult to attain (Heinelt & Kubler 2005). The country needs to review the legal structure for decentralization as it has proved insufficient in examining all the decentralization laws. Such laws include aspects of budgeting, civil service, service delivery to ensure a steady approach. Treatment of vital issues in both the legal and dictatorial framework has to be shaped by the government regardless of whether the process seems federal or unitary Under other federal systems, for instance local governments are totally under the influence of the State and Provincial level governments.

The Federal government becomes limited in terms of relationships it establishes with the local level government and seeks to impact on the local behavior and results through the states and provinces. A decentralization policy that has been established in Brazil is considerably complicated by one element. Participation, as well as decentralization has a close relationship. Successful decentralization needs some aspects of local participation. Sub-national governments' closeness to their constituents enables them to react quickly to the local needs and competently match public expenditure to private needs. There has to be a flow of information between the local governments and citizens for efficient service delivery. The decentralization process can enhance the opportunities for public contribution by placing more influence and resources at a close, familiar, influenced the degree in a government. In environments with restricted citizen involvement, decentralization can act as a vital first step in developing regular and conservative opportunities for all citizens and state communication. The symbiotic connection between decentralization and contribution results to conflicting policy guidelines. Mechanisms for locals' participation need to be considered as a helpful pre-condition in evaluating the opportunities for successful decentralization. The design for decentralization needs to consider the opportunities and limitations imposed by present channels of local participation.

Lack of contribution mechanisms can be considered an inspiration for decentralization and helps in the creation of local demand to incorporate more participatory channels which voice local preferences. Participation acts as a means to flourishing decentralization and as an objective of decentralization. The broad mechanisms for participation of citizens is essential for economic growth in a country as they define the decentralization policy parameters (Heinelt & Kubler2005). These institutional structures, entrenched in the national political setting and developed over period, cannot be distorted quickly by basic regulation. The country needs to come up with smaller and specific avenues to incorporate citizen participation that can be developed in the decentralization process. This incremental transformation can in the long run lead to broader opportunities for citizen contribution as well as democratic governance.

Accountability in Brazil

Although development is unsustainable as cases of poverty, rampant corruption and accountability challenges in Brazil remains evident. The public has lost hope in politicians with a growing apathy from different quarters for an apparent failure to transform n dialogues and enterprises into tangible and scalable results for the poor citizens in the country. Brazil has been in the forefront for setting formidable accountability strategies with the innovations in the country. The main challenge remains finding ways on how different sectors would embrace new responsibilities in a transparent manner. The government needs to come up with fame work as well as indicators which encourage accountability as a compliance mechanism. In most instances, attention is often placed on pressing issues like getting action rapid disregarding accountability. The window of opportunity to create mutual accountability among unequal partners and beneficiaries can easily disappear. Practitioners need to make time for establishing governance system. Collaborative governance starts with simple and an adaptive process which gives room for review to take place.

The governance systems need to enhance the participation in decision-making, and open door for innovations as their core strategy (Gennaio, Hersperger & Burgi, 2009). Governance systems need to be weighty, but should cover the entire extent of the collaboration vision and strategy. The process should include structures and performance, reporting and engagement of all stakeholders. Other research on governance systems needs to consider the evaluation of developmental goals. For instance, the governance on health partnerships in comparison to micro finance as Geographic significance such as the ones used in Brazil shows some resemblance, but also exclusive cultural qualities. The complexity of such program entails bilateral deal among a large company and an international NGO, to a compound open forum comprising multiple representatives. The interaction with public accountability systems which support collaboration's governance in Brazil has to b experimented. The governance which incorporates collaborative initiatives makes accountability to be a dynamic driver in terms of performance contrary to a compliance requirement. This means the process encompasses the mutual compact of balancing power rather that gaining developmental goals. Usage of tools like accountability governance ensures cooperation among people when working together.

Governments need to offer the regulatory setting in an environment of accountability. They play a vital role in encouraging providential governance as well as the capability for democratic scrutiny by negotiating trade regulations and other trade policies. Public policies and regulations have to encourage accountability mostly public-private partnerships involved with the provisions of infrastructure and public services. The process has to be transparent with clear provisions of accountability and admission to, contractual documents concerning governance procedures. The government needs to ensure evaluation of performance including auditing partnerships which is available for public scrutiny. Governments using regulatory agencies and other regulatory bodies should demand a promise that Collaborative Initiatives would take into account the key interests of stakeholders mostly the poor. The process should make use of stakeholder commitment mechanisms as well as reporting to encourage accountability.

The Public sector representatives and government agencies need support in terms of capacity building to enhance their skills growth. Incentives and other systems to guarantee reliable governance as well as adequate civil society contribution in the plan and collaborative governance are vital. The influence of donors and investors together with private philanthropists in both business and communal multilateral institutions offers the most significant external set of enticement for accountability in development. In order for the system to be efficient investors and donors need to ensure the ventures they fund are planned, operated and reported in accordance with a joint framework. Development of a common agenda for governance in terms of collaborations, emphasizing and prioritizing accountability remains vital to the ultimate, beneficiaries. The establishment of a rating system provides consistent and similar response to donors, citizens and governments on the authenticity of such arrangements and also enforces the use of external incentives to advance accountability (Gennaio, Hersperger, & M. Burgi 2009).

Investment in supporting information networks that gives analysis and share experiences on efficient leadership and accountability is necessary in supporting society development. Although some aspects of such knowledge apparently exist, the subject is locked up in specific networks and confidential evaluations. The government needs to publish and state the procedure which they evaluate accountability of the programs they support.

Review and improvement of their accountability mechanisms in terms of Collaborative Framework, is instrumental in encouraging accountability in Brazil. The process ensures they offer the strongest example in terms of the programs they support. Organizational standards have to play a vital role in offering both informal and formal incentives for designating of efficient policies together with management systems. Standard-setting in institutions need to develop tools for partnerships to make use of management systems, as well as reporting processes. Accountability as a standards theme aims at fostering economical in developing countries such as Brazil and brings positive transformation. Most development collaborations are established with the main purpose of gradually taking the role of creation of global standards. These global partnerships have to demonstrate best practice in their leadership and accountability systems. '

Urban policies in developing countries

The rapid changing patterns in terms of population distribution, as well as financial activities in developing countries such as Brazil have led to inequalities in terms of economic growth. Other notable disparities are found in employment conditions, industrial structure, household incomes earnings and degree of services which are enthusiastically felt by decision makers together with social groups. These inequalities include those found between the urban, rural sectors, cities, and social groupings in large cities. The situation has prompted policymakers in Brazil to experiment with spatial contemplation in the national financial policy schemes. For instance, the government is now concerned about the investment composition of projects as well as differentiated effects in the growth of both cities and regions. In Brazil as a developing country, the decentralization of financial activity from large and congested capital locations and losing of the gap between the poor and the rich are part of the urban policy.

The justifications for executing decentralization in urban areas by the government aims at reducing the mounting acute managerial problems linked to financial and social costs. The other issue is the challenge of provision of quality services in key cities. The urge to reduce large regional disparities in a country and the notion that there are more investment opportunities outside the biggest urban regions has encouraged decentralization in Brazil as one of the urban policies. The urban policies are viewed as equitable and financially viable. The decentralization policies regarding the urban centers in Brazil are founded on the possibility that decentralization of a population from the big cities is possible. A national population strategy on decentralization in the country entails many objectives. The multiplicity of the process calls for usage of comparable multiplicity and identification of appropriate policies in a country with given degree of development.

Contemporary planning of the urban areas and policy making has originated from a long tradition, initially based on modernist notions, which found a fruitful ground in Brazil. The modern architecture involving planning of new cities, trendy housing sites initiatives are entirely planned and financed by the state.AS the world faces a predicament in comprehensive planning linked to the deeper challenges brought by capitalist modernity, original alternatives have to be pursued. Most of the policymakers in Brazil have tried to add the collective action on practice knowledge of planning. The state, which was in past viewed as an enemy, has gradually become a crucial partner in matters touching on urban and social policies. Planning and active participation started to amalgamate mostly in the nineties, after the country got a new constitution in the year. The era saw a rejuvenated urban regulation which had spread through the local governments in the country. On the other hand, planning mostly at the grassroots level started the incorporation of what is termed as the real city in the contemporary world. The situation entails the totality of all urban settlements with both their disparities and differences.

The changes seem parallel to the formal changes taking place in the urban arena as in the seventies, lots of environmental thought emerged and spread by different social movements, policy making and academic studies. Its evolution led to various different paths from a common concern on the nature and the urge to protect natural spaces from the incessant progress of urban-industrial effects of production .The country has witnessed profound discussion on the developmental concept and the sustainability challenges. In the seventies and eighties, popular movements started to bring their demand s in the open because of the state incapability to provide them with quality standards of living and living conditions. Initially the groups were organized to fight against the worsening conditions in the urban areas. The urban movement progressively turned into organized social groupings. In such an environment, individual participation was compulsory as technical knowledge was viewed as secondary in the early phases.

Participatory schemes and initiatives that were viewed as a response to the conventional planning transformed into significant methodological as well as political criteria. The state proved to be instrumental in implementation of the urban policies. The period saw the struggle between the state and citizens in regard to quality urban setting. The social groupings demanded better access to urbanization benefits, which reaffirmed the significance of the urban question that is presently redefined as a social setting. In fact, after many years of debate, it was evident that the state plays a crucial role in the policies affecting the urban areas in Brazil. Although, it is challenging to find a consistent and theoretical attempt in analyzing both the formulations of the urban environment the notion of creating political, ecology in relation to urbanization remains a theoretical dilemma. At such a level, many people argue that the merger between the social and urban environment seems obvious and promising.

The institutional, as well as political arrangements is evident in the urban development policy accepted in the framework of the Ministry concerned with Cities in Brazil is an encouraging example. It is common knowledge that large cities have apparent advantages in terms of global financial competition and great potential in enhancing the social conditions of the residents. The projection for sustained growth mostly depends on the ability of a country's cities to contend with the present globalization context. Making cities function efficiently to attract investment, job creation and income is obviously crucial. Brazil need to have a significant head start in the present worldwide economic competition with its superior stage in terms of urban transition, many large cities, developed network of cities and high degrees of urbanization. Indeed around 90 per cent of Brazil GNP is by now produced in the cities. In addition to issue, the country does not have to deal with immense immigration to the cities and high levels of the general population growth in that the rapid fertility decline was as a result of precocious urbanization. Impact of the legal system on the administration of Brazil

Nevertheless, it is evident that Brazil has yet to attain transformation in terms of theoretical advantages resulting from past urban transition to reality. The past 15 years in the 20th century, the country's cities witnessed low productivity in terms of growth mostly in larger cities. The situation can be linked to increased levels in crime, violence and worsening basic infrastructure. The focus on demographic growth has changed from urban centers to the margin of larger cities, and as the expansion is mainly composed of the poor, poor infrastructures and insufficient services for new settlements seem inadequate (Peet Watts 1996). While segregation keeps on increasing as gated communities spring up in such areas. The situation shows challenging in reducing, even though, the general urban growth degrees peaked many decades ago as cities become politically and managerially fragmented as they keep on expanding.

You’re 80% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.

Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log in
130,000+ paper examples AI writing assistant Citation generator Cancel anytime
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2012). Administrative problems facing local governments in developing countries. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/public-administration-in-brazil-public-adminstration-83118

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.