Skip to main content
Term Paper Undergraduate 961 words

George E. Nunn's critique of Magellan's Pacific voyage route

~5 min read History
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
Essay 961 words

Magellan's Route In The Pacific

In his article "Magellan's Route in the Pacific," author George E. Nunn proposes that the historically accepted account of the Portuguese explorer's route is inaccurate, based on falsified accounts from the unreliable log of Francisco Albo. The article directly pertains to any study of the Age of Exploration and is therefore wholly relevant to world history as well as geography. The author also questions and critiques popularly accepted primary sources. Nunn bases his arguments on nautical and geographic facts, historical evidence, and logical inferences based on the prevailing political climate of the time. As evidence, Nunn cites the discrepancies between the various expedition logs regarding the route, and discrepancies between the logs and geographic fact. Furthermore, Magellan and his crew deliberately falsified their accounts so that they could gain control over the Spice Islands and usurp Spain. The author argues that the true course of Magellan's expedition was actually parallel to the coast of South America, not traversing the Pacific directly as is commonly believed, and bases his thesis on three main issues: the point at which Magellan started to cross the Pacific; the latitude of San Pablo and Tiburones Islands; and the direction and distance of the expedition.

One of the reasons why the log of Francisco Albo is unreliable is because it includes no accounts of land being seen. Nunn notes that although the Pacific Ocean is massive, it is nevertheless "filled with evidence of land...what a marvelous occurrence it would have been...to miss all but two rocks in the entire Pacific," (620). To support his point, the author demonstrates that each of the many islands in the Pacific Ocean is enclosed by a radius of only fifty miles.

663 Words Hidden
Shore birds frequently fly greater distances than fifty miles from shore; because Magellan and his crew were aware of this fundamental fact of seafaring, it…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Magellan's Pacific voyage George E. Nunn Francisco Albo log Age of Exploration historical route verification Spice Islands primary source analysis
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2004). George E. Nunn's critique of Magellan's Pacific voyage route. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/magellan-route-in-the-pacific-165213

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.