Measurement error in the Bargh and Doyen walking speed priming studies
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Measurement Error Issue
Measurement Error
In the study done by Bargh, Chen, & Burrows (1996), measurement error was an issue when looking at whether priming concepts of old age caused people to walk out of the room more slowly. This issue came about because the measurement method that was used was imprecise. It relied on a person measuring walking speed with a stopwatch. While the stopwatch itself was accurate, the issue was focused on whether the person doing the measuring was pressing the start and stop buttons at the same point for each person he or she was measuring. Based on what the person was thinking, feeling, and doing, he or she could have easily pressed the button sooner or not as quickly for any particular person being observed. This may have been an unconscious behavior, but would still have a strong effect on the results of the study and how the information was analyzed. In the replication study done by Doyen, et al. (2012) this issue was addressed by using a timing method that was less likely to be subjective, and the result was that the Bargh, Chen, & Burrows (1996) study could not be replicated.
Doyen, et al. (2012) did two things differently. First, the experiment was conducted using an infrared beam as a measurement device, so it could not be affected by whether a person pressed a button at a specific time each and every time.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.