Moral Reasoning Essay

PAGES
2
WORDS
701
Cite

¶ … reasoning that moral reasoning is determining what is right or wrong in a situation is acceptable but confusion arise from understanding what is wrong and what is right. Though universal with intercultural variations, it cannot be argued that it is only based on the perception of right or wrong. As a support to this, it is correct that cultures have varying beliefs and opinions and view moral reasoning differently. In China for example, bowing down to elders is a moral act but in America nobody bows to the elders. Besides, Chinese focus on group welfare which is the opposite for American culture which favors individualism. Second Response

It is generally acceptable that moral reasoning varies based on people's reasoning and beliefs; this response upholds that morality depends on whether a person's act will harm the other or not which is a rational ideology. This belief is awkward since it is not possible to gauge a person's perception of your actions; whether good or bad that is what is good for you may be bad for the other person. Though Hindu and American morality concepts are contrasting; the American being more individualistic...

...

In support, it is true that culture shapes people's views concerning moral reasoning. Americans disregard collectivism attitudes which Hindus are great proponents.
Third Response

Determining what is wrong or right based on what you are taught is correct since society shapes our cultural thinking. However, whatever a particular society teaches may not be acceptable to everybody; this argument fails to convince a person why they should be morally upright. As an example, Africans view morality based on biblical teachings the same as Puerto Ricans. In both cultures, morality entails upholding the familial name by displaying good character to avoid tarnishing the family's reputation. Arguing that cultural differences regarding moral reasoning remain unclear is correct requiring further debate and research. Additionally, morality is unrelated to behavior despite the influence culture has on an individual's belief of morality; this argument is definitely correct and non-debatable.

Fourth Response

As a person develops so his perception of morality…

Cite this Document:

"Moral Reasoning" (2013, January 12) Retrieved April 24, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/moral-reasoning-104730

"Moral Reasoning" 12 January 2013. Web.24 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/moral-reasoning-104730>

"Moral Reasoning", 12 January 2013, Accessed.24 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/moral-reasoning-104730

Related Documents

Moral Reasoning Taps is a movie about a private military high school, where the school is facing closure. To prevent this the adolescents attending the campus take over the school; in terms of adolescent moral reasoning, the boys involved impulsively react instead of thinking things through. They arm themselves, feeling like they are taking initiative and working together as a team to accomplish a common goal. They react just as they

Moral Reasoning
PAGES 2 WORDS 719

Cultural Differences Moral Reasoning Moral reasoning: An intercultural comparison Until recently, many Western developmental theorists tended to see morality as a transcultural phenomenon, reflecting their belief that all cultures shared certain common moral assumptions. Both Piaget and Kohlberg stressed that moral development passes through a series of stages, just like the child's ability to understand other complex subjects like mass and volume (Jensen 2008; Sunac n.d). However, this tends to assume that the

Kohlberg's Moral Stages What would you do if confronted with this same dilemma? If I was confronted with this dilemma, I would tell the truth about my son and not let my wife take the blame. However, I would not do so out of higher moral principles but because I would tend to assume that law enforcement would likely figure out eventually what was the truth and then both my son and

Brannigan's Moral Reasoning Applied to a Specific Case Study Using Brannigan's six steps to moral reasoning, the situation involving the business man, his wife, and her lover can be broken down and analyzed from a moral perspective in order to arrive at an agreed upon moral option. The first step in using Brannigan's Moral Reasoning logic is to identify the fact. Since the case went to court, the article used to

Moral Dilemmas
PAGES 2 WORDS 700

I would have been thinking about social norms and categorical imperatives in Kohlberg's system -- or about the social value of self-sacrifice in Gilligan's. Instead I made a moral choice that reflects moral maturity: a level of caring that Gilligan would define as postconventional. Whether consciously or not, I was determined to preserve the dignity and promote the well-being of both my friends. I took myself out of the picture.

As Kohlberg proposed, children undergo "a sequence of qualitative changes in the way an individual thinks," (Nucci 2002). As children encounter new environmental stimuli including new peers, new social group situations, and new challenges to the developing ego, moral character begins to emerge. While it would be impossible to assess the Rising Star Montessori academy based on the Web copy on their site, it is safe to say that