New Breast Cancer Screening Guidelines Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Healthcare Type: Term Paper Paper: #97455247 Related Topics: Physician Assistant, Breast Cancer, American Cancer Society, Cancer
Excerpt from Term Paper :



Dr. Robb-Nicholson's data best supports the scenario that more incidents of breast cancer will be discovered due to the reduced number of screenings that the new guidelines suggest. According to the numbers she gives, the mortality rate for breast cancer decreases every year and this decrease can be attributed to the previous screening guidelines. She writes that the USPSTF has based the new guidelines on statistics rather than clinical data and the message that they are conveying to the public is that the number of deaths that regular screenings at beginning at the age of forty is too small to keep the guidelines as they were previously. (6)

The best approach would be to keep the guidelines the way they were before the change. There was not enough clinical data to support the change in guidelines. Also, because the mortality rate for breast cancer has steadily declined with women following the previous guidelines, there is no rational behind the change. If there are changes to be made to the guidelines, they should be based on clinical data and not just statistics alone. The statistics do not give us a true and clear picture of the mortality rates of breast cancer. And for the USPSTF to state that the number of deaths is too small to stay with the previous guidelines shows a lack of concern for public health issues and in particular, the health of women altogether. They have sent a strong message to the public of what matters and what doesn't matter to them.

The USPSTF needs to carefully review the new guidelines and perhaps wait until there is more clinical data to support it. If there is not enough clinical data to support the change in guidelines, they should remain as they were previously. Even though the incidence of a woman developing breast cancer at the age of fifty is slightly greatly that those in their forties, the fact that the mortality rate for this disease has continued to decrease over past years cannot be ignored. Mammograms and self-examinations are the most useful means of early detection, so it is not reasonable or practical to change anything regarding these processes.

The American Cancer Society (ACS) still displays the former breast screening guidelines on their website. This organization has been in existence since 1946 and can be considered a leading authority on the early detection and prevention of various forms of cancer. The organization provides education on cancer prevention and it works to find a cure for cancer. The website states that the best chances of survival is if the disease if detected early. Regular screenings and self-examinations are listed by the organization as the most important methods of early detection. Of note and interest is that the organization has not changed its guidelines to coincide with those of the USPSTF. (http://www.cancer.org/docroot/ped/content/ped_2_3x_acs_cancer_detection_guidelines_36.asp). This should be a red flag since the American Cancer Society has been a leading authority...

...

It affects all family members. Regular breast screening and self-examinations are an important part of the early detection process. Studies have shown that annual screenings beginning at the age of forty and monthly breast self-exams are very good methods of early detection. The fact that the mortality rate has decreased by at least two percent over the past thirty years is also a good sign that we were on the right path regarding the guidelines. The USPSTF feels otherwise and has made a drastic change in the age in which women should begin regular screenings. There is a ten-year difference in the age of the previous guidelines and the new guidelines. A lot can happen in ten years.

The decision of the USPSTF seems rushed because they made it based solely on statistical data since not enough clinical data was available at the time. They felt that the mortality rate was so small for women between the ages of forty and forty-nine, that the guidelines could be changed. What they are not considering is the health of the underserved populations which are minority women and women from low income households. Women in these categories often do not get the regular screenings that are necessary for early detection of breast cancer. Because of the new guidelines, these women who are usually at a higher risk of getting the disease may be fooled into thinking that they can delay regular screening until the age of fifty instead of forty.

Given all of the potential negative scenarios that could happen based on the new breast cancer screening guidelines, it makes senses for women to take charge of their health and continue to follow the previous guidelines until substantial clinical data can be found to support the new guidelines that the USPSTF has set forth. If women start following the new guidelines, there is a strong possibility that we could begin to see a steady increase per year in the mortality rate. This would take us backwards instead of forward and moving forward is the direction we would like to continue to head in.

References Cited

1. Cancer Weekly. Concerned Federal Screening Mammography Guidelines to Limit Access for Younger Women. Susan G. Komen for the Cure. 2010: 1665.

2. Earthtimes.org. Stick with Older Mammography Recommendations. Stanford Experts Say. March 3, 2010 (Press Release from Stanford Hospital & Clinics).

3. Hoppel, Ann M. To screen, and when to screen: the mammography age divide. Clinician Reviews. 2009: 19.12.

4. Journal of the American Academy of Physicians Assistants. USP-STF: no routine mammography for women younger than 50 years. 2010; 23.2, p.66.

5. Mandeblatt, Jeanne, Saha, Somnath, et. al. The cost-effectiveness of screening mammography beyond age 65 years: A systematic review for the U.S. preventive services task force. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2003; 139(10): 835-843.

6. Robb-Nicholson, Celeste. A doctors talks about: Screening mammography. Harvard Women's Health Watch. 2010: General Reference Center Gold.

7. Sarff, MaryClare, Schmidt, Katherine and Vetto, John T. Targeted breast cancer screening in women younger than 40: results from a statewide program. 2008; 195(5): 626-630.

8. Saywell, Jr., Robert M. Champion, Victoria L., Sugg-Skinner, Celette and Joanne Daggy. A cost-effectiveness comparison of three tailored interventions to increase mammography screening. Journal of Women's Health. 2004; 13(8): 909-918.

9. Sutton, Sharyn M., Eisner, Ellen J., Bloom, Diane L., and Bloom, Paul N. The Mammography Guidelines Controversy: What Do Women Think? Advances in Consumer Research. 1994; 13: 387-391.

10. Urrea, Jamee. Mammography: Testing the…

Sources Used in Documents:

References Cited

1. Cancer Weekly. Concerned Federal Screening Mammography Guidelines to Limit Access for Younger Women. Susan G. Komen for the Cure. 2010: 1665.

2. Earthtimes.org. Stick with Older Mammography Recommendations. Stanford Experts Say. March 3, 2010 (Press Release from Stanford Hospital & Clinics).

3. Hoppel, Ann M. To screen, and when to screen: the mammography age divide. Clinician Reviews. 2009: 19.12.

4. Journal of the American Academy of Physicians Assistants. USP-STF: no routine mammography for women younger than 50 years. 2010; 23.2, p.66.
http://www.cancer.org/docroot/ped/content/ped_2_3x_acs_cancer_detection_guidelines_36.asp


Cite this Document:

"New Breast Cancer Screening Guidelines" (2010, April 13) Retrieved July 3, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/new-breast-cancer-screening-guidelines-1699

"New Breast Cancer Screening Guidelines" 13 April 2010. Web.3 July. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/new-breast-cancer-screening-guidelines-1699>

"New Breast Cancer Screening Guidelines", 13 April 2010, Accessed.3 July. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/new-breast-cancer-screening-guidelines-1699

Related Documents
Breast Cancer Is a Disease
Words: 4768 Length: 16 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 63242748

Partial Mastectomy- a procedure that remove part of the breast that contains the cancer and some tissue around the affected tissue. This type of surgery is also called a segmental mastectomy (Breast Cancer Treatment). In addition the National Cancer Institute reports that patients who undergo the aforementioned types of surgeries may also have some lymph nodes removed (Breast Cancer Treatment). Another type of surgery that does not conserve the breast is the

Breast Cancer Detection Rural Women
Words: 2201 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 10931212

In this particular instance the place to start would be to launch an education program aimed at both patients and providers as to the importance of early detection screening for breast cancer. The goal would be to implement outreach strategies to improve access to screening for women who have rarely or never been screened. A second thing that would need to be done would be that of developing a

Health Concerns Involving Breast Cancer
Words: 1100 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Health Paper #: 66435666

Breast cancer forms the second largest cause of deaths from cancer in American women. In the year 2015, roughly 232,000 women, mostly between 55 and 64 years of age, showed positive cancer diagnoses, with 40,000 succumbing to the disease. The median breast cancer-linked mortality age is 68 years. The US PSTF (Preventive Services Task Force) advises all females aged between 50 and 74 years to undergo screening mammography once every

Breast Cancer Pathophysiology
Words: 2914 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 95988583

Breast Cancer Pathophysiology Breast Cancer Advanced Pathophysiology Breast cancer is the most frequently diagnosed cancer in women worldwide. There are three general determinants associated with the cause of the disease: heredity factors, environmental factors, and hormonal factors. The risk of developing breast cancer increases with age, as 78% of cases are diagnosed in women ages 50 and older. Risk factors are distinguished by their respective etiological influences, such as family history, lifestyle, and

Pathophysiology of Breast Cancer Is
Words: 1143 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 52755323

However, in cancer these cells grow out of control and mutate, causing disease. Some of the issues with the development of breast cancer have been linked to exposure to estrogen, but that does not always appear to be the case (Sariego, 2010). Other factors can also be problematic. The main issue with breast cancer is not what caused it but how to treat it and whether it is diagnosed

USA and New Zealand Healthcare Compared
Words: 3464 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 53930810

countries of the West and other major developed countries throughout the world are notable in many ways. Comparing and contrasting the two is just one way that very interesting topics and debates can be triggered. While many Western and other developed nations share strong commonalities, there are also very stark differences. The United States in particular is an outlier in many ways given how it does not have a