Verified Document

New York City's Beverage Ban Essay

Related Topics:

NEW YORK CITY'S BEVERAGE BAN (300 words requested)

Last year, the New York City Board of Health followed the lead of Mayor Michael Bloomberg and banned the sale of sodas and other sugary beverages in serving sizes over 16 fluid ounces. The purpose of the ban was to reduce the societal harm caused by the consumption of high-calorie, high-sugar-content drinks because they contribute to the problem of obesity. Since then, a New York trial court rejected the ban as "arbitrary and capricious," largely because it was established by the Board of Health instead of the New York City Council. The Mayor responded publicly that his administration intends to appeal the decision and that the soda ban is no different, in principle, from similar measures already in place, such as against smoking in restaurants and trans-fats in commercially-prepared foods. The justification is simply that obesity burdens public health care resources and therefore, some of its known causes should be subject to regulation. Meanwhile, opponents of the beverage ban argue that it violates the personal autonomy and freedom of personal choice. They are concerned that regulating soda cup size is a slippery slope leading to laws prohibiting eating too many calories or banning sunbathing, because they also cause health problems.

The legal basis of the State Supreme Court decision was that the ban is "arbitrary" because it would only have applied to some types of businesses and only to those regulated by the city. For example, supermarkets and chain stores were exempted, even though they might be located on the same block as businesses affected by the ban. Ultimately, whether or not future versions of the same law survive legal challenges will probably depend more on how they are framed and whether they resolve some of the issues that the court characterized as "arbitrary" rather than on whether or not the city authorities have the legal right to regulate the sale of large servings of some kinds of beverages.

Source Consulted

Saul, M.H. (2013). "Judge Cans Soda Ban: Ruling on Sugary Drinks Marks Rare Defeat

on Health Policy for Bloomberg." The Wall Street Journal (March 11, 2013).

Retrieved online: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323826704578354543929974394.html

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

New York City's Beverage Ban
Words: 592 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Argument Opposing the Ban The primary argument against the beverage ban is that it violates the fundamental autonomy and freedom of personal choice. Critics argue that in that respect, it is no different from prohibiting the consumption of a maximum amount of calories or banning sunbathing, because the former also contributes to obesity and because the latter is known to cause sin cancers that are sometimes deadly and that are also

Smoking Ban Tobacco Smoke Should Certainly Be
Words: 1586 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Smoking Ban Tobacco smoke should certainly be considered a toxic chemical, and its risks to human health have been well-known for decades. Any reasonable person -- or indeed anyone who is even slightly familiar with the medical and scientific evidence -- would certainly know this today. Forty years ago, the federal government banned tobacco advertising from radio and television and put warning labels on tobacco products, while class action lawsuits have

Social Media - A New Kind of
Words: 2405 Length: 6 Document Type: Dissertation

Social Media - a New Kind of Security Problem in Business The Newest Threat to any Business: Social Media Social media is one of the most significant changes that has come about in communication today. However, it can also have serious implications for business and for the privacy and protection of businesses and employees. Overall, social media is not something that can be ignored by businesses today, because it can offer worries

Block for Instructions Issue Facing a Local
Words: 1051 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Block for Instructions Issue facing a local community: Limitations on soda consumption in New York City One of the most divisive local issues in America does not pertain to gun control or education but revolves around that quintessentially all-American beverage -- the soft drink. New York City Mayor Bloomberg recently proposed limiting the sizes of "large sodas and other sugary drinks at restaurants, movie theaters and street carts, in the most ambitious

Bottled Water Be Banned Why
Words: 3428 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

Is Bottled Water Truly as Pure as the Industry Would Like Us to Believe? The NRDC hired three independent laboratories to conduct the testing of more than 1,000 plastic bottles -- 103 different brands -- and found that "about one third" the 103 brands contained "significant contamination," that is, levels of chemical or bacterial contaminants that exceed federal and state standards. After the independent labs completed their research and testing, NRDC

Soda Tax in California the Issue of
Words: 1528 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Soda Tax in California The issue of soda tax, or the implementation of rules that guide the soft drinks industry in terms of guiding the consumer on the content of the soda which often is at the expense of the manufacturer, is not new to California. New York City had a similar bill that was passed but later on shelved due to a court ruling that favored the soft drinks manufacturers

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now