Pedophilia Term Paper

Length: 30 pages Sources: 20 Subject: Psychology Type: Term Paper Paper: #90713233 Related Topics: Multivariate Analysis, Lolita, Dependent Personality Disorder, Recidivism
Excerpt from Term Paper :

It will focus discovering the treatment option, or combination of options that results in the lowest incidence of recidivism for the longest period following the treatment. It is difficult to predict future events, therefore the research will take a historical perspective on the problem.

This study will compare recidivism rates for the four most common treatments used for pedophile offenders. It will only consider treatment for those that were convicted of their crimes. It will compare those that received group therapy only, cognitive behavioral therapy only, treatment with SSRIs only, and chemical castration only. Many treatment plans include a combination of treatments. Therefore, a comparison of the most common treatment combinations found during the course of the research will be compared as well. The most common treatment combinations include Group therapy and cognitive therapy, SSRIs and cognitive therapy, chemical castration and cognitive therapy. The most common combination treatment involves use of cognitive behavior therapy with SSRIs (Barbaree & Seto, 1997).

It will explore these combinations in terms of reduction in recidivism rates over time. It will compare recidivism rates for the seven treatment categories at 1 year after discontinuation of treatment and every year after that up to 10 years following treatment. If recidivism occurs in a sample subject, then time will only be counted from the end of the first treatment session. Repeat recidivism will only be considered as an occurrence recidivism, regardless of the number of reoccurrences. The objective of this study is to isolate the single best treatment option for affecting a long-term change in behavior.

It will address the following research questions in relation to the objectives of the research study.

1. Which types of pedophiles can be successfully treated using cognitive therapies alone?

2. Is pedophilia too resistant to psychological interventions such that it can only be treated with medical therapies?

3. Which medical strategies are most effective in treating pedophilia?

4. Which treatment strategies produce the most reliable long-term results?

Rationale of the Study

The research objectives of the study address the most prevalent concern of those involved in both the law enforcement and mental health professions concerning the prevention of unlawful acts against children. Regardless of one's feelings on the rights on an adult to determine their own feelings regarding the topic, when urges and feelings become behaviors, the rights of children are at stake. Society places a high priority on the safety of children. Therefore, reducing behaviors related to pedophilia are an important issue for society and those that are responsible for upholding societal ideals. Pedophilia is considered to be a heinous crime by a majority of society, therefore academic attention to reducing the future occurrence of such acts is held in high regard by many.

Definition of Terms

Several terms regarding pedophilia have become obscured through colloquial or non-academic usage. Therefore, it is necessary to explain the definitions of these terms as they will apply to the current research study. The following definition will be used throughout the research study.

Adult. An adult will mean a person over the age of 18, either male or female.

Age of consent. The age of consent varies in different countries around the world. For the purposes of this study, the age of consent will refer to that of the United States, 18.

Castration. A procedure the reduces sexual urges in the individual by external means. For the purposes of this study, it refers to the administration of certain pharmaceutical compounds, prescribed by medical personnel that are known to reduce or eliminate sexual urges. It does not refer to the physical removal of genitalia in this study.

Child. Any person below the age of 18 is considered to be a child for the purposes of this study.

Co morbidity. This term...

...

Law enforcement refers to any member or branch of the law enforcement branch of the government. It is used in general terms throughout the research study and does not delineate rank or position in the law enforcement hierarchy.

Mental health professional. This means any member of the medical or mental health community that is involved in the diagnosis or treatment of pedophilia.

Offender. This term refers to a person that has been criminally convicted of a sexual offense related to a child, regardless of the severity or circumstances of the activity.

Pedophile. For the purposes of this study, a pedophile will mean a person that has been convicted of an unlawful sexual act involving a child. In some circumstances, it will refer to a person with sexual urges and fantasies, but that have not acted upon them.

Pedophilic behavior. This term refers to acting on pedophilic feelings and urges by engaging in any sexually related act with a child. The act does not have to involve sexual intercourse, but means any activity prohibited by law such as touching or suggestive verbal or visual behavior.

Pedophilic fantasies. This term refers to dreams or thoughts that involve the adult interacting in a sexual manner with a child. They may or may not be expressed outwardly.

Pedophilic urges. This term refers to physical and mental arousal in response to a child stimulus.

Recidivism. This is a legal term referring to repeat offenses of the same crime. In the case of pedophilia, it does not have to be the exact same crime. For instance, if an offender is convicted of sexual intercourse with a minor, but is later convicted of possession of sexually explicit material involving a child, it will still be considered recidivism for the purposes of these research.

Therapy. Any treatment designed to reduce the occurrence of pedophilic behaviors is considered to be therapy for the purposes of this study. This includes non-medical, medical and combination therapies.

Limitations of the Study

There are several limitations that will impact the interpretation and context of the research study. Some of these limitations stem from the social definitions and current controversies over pedophilia. Others are the result of limitations inherent in the research methodology. The definition of these limitations and their impact on the conclusions of the study will be addressed. Some of these limitation will be addressed more thoroughly in the appropriate chapters of the text.

This study will be limited to those pedophiles that have been convicted of criminal offenses involving children under the age of 18. There are several reasons for this. The first reason is that those that have been convicted of child related sexual offenses are easily quantified through a law enforcement records search. Quantification of those that have not committed crimes must be measured using mental health records or self-reporting measures. These methods are considered to be unreliable for several reasons.

One of the key difficulties in interpreting statistics related to pedophilia is that they reflect "averages" within groups. However, it tells us nothing about the likelihood that any certain individual will be likely to become a repeat offender. Within these statistics, are individuals that committed repeat offenses and those that did not. The key to lowering these figures relies on the ability to provide the most effective treatment for each and every individual involved. This is one of the most important reasons for the conduct of this research project. This project will focus on discovering which treatment methods offer the best answer to the problem of repeat offenses among pedophiles. The ultimate goal is to provide a means to determine which treatment methods will be the most likely to prevent recidivism in the individual. Finding the best treatment method for each individual means

Scales and other assessment instruments are used to measure the "progress" of the pedophile in returning to correct patterns of thinking. However, pedophiles are aware of the ramifications of expressing these feelings outwardly. They know which answers are "politically correct." Therefore, the validity of self-reporting measures for pedophiles must be questioned. For this reason, scales that measure the "thoughts and feelings" of the pedophile will not be considered a reliable means to assess the success or failure of a treatment method.

In addition to a compulsion to appear to be "politically correct" in the eyes of society. The pedophile might also falsify answers in order to avoid potential legal ramifications of their answers. It is not likely that they would be willing to provide answers that will incriminate themselves. These same limitations affect studies found in the literature review that use self-reporting questionnaires as a means to measure the effectiveness of treatment methods. Self-reporting methods are more reliable for conditions that do not carry the legal and social ramifications that pedophilia does.

There are simply too many confounding variables and limitations to conducting a study that measures the feelings of the pedophile. This study will focus on the social goal of reducing outward expression of pedophilia. This study will rely on recidivism as the measurement tool. Recidivism is easily…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

American Psychiatric Association (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (fourth edition), 302.2.

Barbaree, H.E., & Seto, M.C. (1997). Pedophilia: Assessment and Treatment. Sexual Deviance: Theory, Assessment, and Treatment. 175-193.

Berlin, F. (2000). Treatments to Change Sexual Orientation. Am J. Psychiatry 157: 838.

Bradford, J.M.W. (2000). The Treatment of Sexual Deviation Using a Pharmacological Approach.


Cite this Document:

"Pedophilia" (2007, April 14) Retrieved April 11, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/pedophilia-38585

"Pedophilia" 14 April 2007. Web.11 April. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/pedophilia-38585>

"Pedophilia", 14 April 2007, Accessed.11 April. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/pedophilia-38585

Related Documents
Pedophilia
Words: 3095 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 20222853

Introduction Few psychological disorders are as stigmatized as pedophilia. From the Greek meaning “love of children,” pedophilia is defined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual as “recurrent, intense, sexually arousing fantasies, sexual urges, or behaviors involving sexual activity with a prepubescent child or children,” (Muller, 2016, p. 1). The media perpetuates stigma by semantically linking pedophilia with child sexual abuse or child molestation. In fact, pedophilia refers only to the desire

Brain Function Between Pedophiles and Non-pedophiles. Summarize
Words: 1260 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 27126358

brain function between pedophiles and non-pedophiles. Summarize the evidence in support of this assertion. Propose a study that would advance our knowledge of the topic. Pedophilia is such a horrific crime; it is difficult to rationally evaluate the objective medical evidence that can give clues as to why it occurs. However, recent scientific evidence indicates that there are specific biological components of the brain that can cause a predisposition to

Paraphila the Ancient Philosopher Plato Claimed That
Words: 1412 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 16482628

Paraphila The ancient philosopher Plato claimed that all immoral behavior was the result of some disorder in the soul (Gert and Culver, 2009, p. 489). Although very few people now hold this view, deviant sexual behavior is often considered symptomatic of a mental disorder. However, not all deviant behaviors fit the clinical definition. For example, if a heterosexual man becomes aroused by dressing in women's clothing, it is considered by most

Premature Sexualisation Public Hysteria or "Sex Panic"
Words: 2335 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 43919700

Premature Sexualisation Public hysteria or "sex panic" involving the "sexualisation" of children may be getting a decent outing in Australia at the present moment, but it is certainly nothing new: fifty years ago it was Elvis Presley's hips that portended imminent moral collapse, two hundred and fifty and a dance craze called the "waltz" was considered immodest and the "emo kids" of the late eighteenth century were committing suicide after

Human Sexuality Manifests Itself in
Words: 8600 Length: 31 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Sexuality Paper #: 19843016

He was unworthy, because he had in effect become both a woman and a prostitute. If as an adult he nevertheless went ahead and exercised his citizenship by casting his vote or speaking in the assembly, he could be put on trial and lose not only his citizenship but also his life. Such charges may not have been brought very often, but it did sometimes happen,(18) and the very

Sex Crimes
Words: 2364 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Sexuality Paper #: 36021050

Sex Crimes Sexual crimes have certainly among those that cause the strongest reaction in the population. The feeling of revolt is also generally more intense when discussing issues related to sexual crimes against children. (Pithers and Gray 1998) Society is demanding and harsher penalties for those responsible for these crimes and their crimes are seen as particularly repulsive, even to other criminals. The severity assigned to these crimes can be illustrated