RE: Topic 6: The American War for Independence – Treason or Justified Rebellion?
Treason or justified rebellion? Well, both! Ultimately we need to decide what kind of world we want to live in and what kind of country we want to give to our children. Dear citizen, Jenny is right: “We free citizens of these thirteen colonies must no longer stand idly by and endure such offensives, but instead come together!” Yes, we may be committing treason against the Crown, but is treason really the highest crime? We think not. Tis a much higher crime indeed to infringe on the rights of others, deprive others of freedom and liberty, and prevent the progress of humanity. We stand at the cusp of a tremendous revolution, one that cannot be stopped. If there is a way to settle these matters peaceably, then certainly we are all for it. But given the reactions of the Crown to our latest, reasonable, and fair demands, it would seem that the King is no longer interested in catering to the best interests of the citizens. The Townshend Revenue, Tea & the Coercive Acts benefit the Crown but not the people it serves (Jenny). That being the case, it is high time we launch a conscientious, organized rebellion. I also wish that we could resolve our differences in a less disruptive manner, but it does not seem likely. We have to act on principle, thinking of the next seven generations and not just of ourselves. Otherwise, why would we have bothered at all leaving behind all that we knew in order to start a new world?
References
Jenny. “RE: Topic 6: The American War for Independence – Treason or Justified Rebellion?”
RE: Topic 1: The Trial of Anne Hutchinson
A devout Christian and mother, esteemed midwife and valuable member of the community, Anne Hutchinson does not deserve to be persecuted in this manner. Although her views might be contradictory to the norm, some might even say outlandish, she has every right to express her opinions on Christian doctrine and theology. I do not even believe the real issue her is Hutchinson’s gender. If a man were to usurp the authority of the clergy, then he would also be brought to trial under this puritanical system.
We claim fathers and mothers came to these colonies to flee from tyranny and religious persecution. Yet here we are, persecuting others for having different beliefs from our own. Let there be some pluralism within our ranks. So what if some of our kind believe in Grace over Good Works, Faith over Deeds? As long as these are good, hard working, god-fearing people, let us leave them alone one and all. Let us use the courts to evaluate the justice of deeds, not of ideology.
I personally disagree with the content of Hutchinson’s claims, for I also uphold the spiritual value of good works. Doing good for others is the cornerstone of Christian life. Based on her having done many good deeds as a midwife and leader of women in the community, Ms. Hutchinson may be more worthy of entering the kingdom of heaven than those who wish to banish her from our stead.
References
“Trial and Interrogation of Anne Hutchinson,” (1637). http://www.swarthmore.edu/SocSci/bdorsey1/41docs/30-hut.html
You’re 100% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.