Legalizing Sale Organs. Include a Works Cited

¶ … Legalizing Sale Organs. Include a Works Cited page. Writing Tips Academic Essay a. Use present tense MacKay's essay "essay "conclusions .

There is presently much controversy regarding the sale or organs, as while society has traditionally adopted unsupportive attitudes regarding this enterprise, many people lobby in favor of legalizing it. Joanna McKay's essay "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" explains why it is wrong to consider that organ sale is an immoral act and why the general public needs to understand that it can actually play an essential role in helping humanity experience great progress. There are a series of individuals who share McKay's convictions and who believe that people should not think of this matter as presenting them with an ethical dilemma. On the other hand, there are many people who consider that the issue of organ shortage should be dealt with differently and that organs cannot simply be sold as if they were a product.

The masses have to comprehend that "the considerable disparity between the number of patients who could significantly benefit from organ transplantation and the number of human organs available for transplant" is a serious issue and needs to be addressed through considering all solutions available. It is certainly difficult to determine whether individuals are provided with organs by gift or if they are simply presented with things that they can use however they want to. The fact that commercial transactions are an important part of our society influences individuals in believing that the medium of exchange in general made it possible for people to experience progress and that a person should be allowed to do anything that he or she wants with his or her body as long as his or her actions do not violate the rights of others. Society promotes the concept that it is wrong for human beings to be sold but it is difficult to understand whether organs should be considered equivalent to humans as a whole. People who are interested in selling their organs have come to adopt such a position because they need money and because they are desperate in most cases. Through buying organs from them, other individuals can be considered to take advantage of this situation. It is certainly absurd to consider that a person could be interested in selling his or her organs and that he or she is not distressed or unacquainted with the consequences of his or her actions.

Roland Chia believes that the human body has "to be regarded as 'sacred space' and axis mundi, the center of our world and the 'space' around which it rotates" (Chia, 30). Living bodies make it possible for individuals to be considered unique beings and for them to be differentiated from others. Chia explains that people apparently fail in their attempt to understand their role in the world through considering that they can be considered to be distanced from their bodies when they should actually understand that they are their bodies. In contrast to Chia, McKay seems to believe that things need to be viewed from a material point-of-view instead of being seen from a traditional perspective. The writer basically thinks that the modern world has no place for opinions that cannot be supported through using solid arguments that are considered to be in accordance with the modern social order.

S.M. Rothman and D.J. Rothman advise that people need to take action before it is too late. From their perspective, organ sale has presently drawn a lot of supporters and people are slowly but surely reaching a stage where they are considered to be no different from products or animals. The writers claim that people are influenced by the fact that they receive money in exchange for their organs and that they are unable to comprehend the complexity of this act. Individuals who previously wanted to donate their organs might actually be inclined to sell them by thinking that they are helping someone and getting paid at the same time, thus meaning that they reach their goal.

McKay describes present day conditions in the medical world and emphasizes the fact that many people are currently about to die because they are unable to find a donor that can help them. This happens in spite of the fact that there probably a lot of individuals willing to sell their organs but being unable to do so. Some of these potential donors turn to the black market and end up being operated by inexperienced surgeons who are mainly interested in the financial aspect of the matter and who are not necessarily interested in having patients alive consequent to the moment when they extracted organs. Also, such enterprises encourage criminals in kidnapping individuals and stealing their organs.