Carrying on the Legacy of San Juan's Elders": intergenerational service learning project"

Elder Learning Service

By taking part in "Elder Learning Service," one can learn much from the experience. In fact, this is becoming a growing phenomenon both academically and within the community itself. All the research points to the positive impact of how much it empowers individuals into becoming better citizens by becoming self-aware of those that are in need. A service learning service was designed for high school students entitled, "Carrying on the Legacy of San Juan's Elders." Many conclusions arose as well as project outcomes for one to consider for any future project.

Service Learning: High School Students Engaged in their Community

The district in which I teach allowed me to do a service learning project with my high school students upon asking permission from the principal of the school. These were my goals when working with each of them. 1) Promote student and elderly intergenerational communication; 2) Improve student understanding of elderly and discourage ageism; 3) Enhance student learning of San Juan history; 4) Provide a student lesson that promotes communication and writing skills; and 5) Provide a finished product that can be given to the elderly person's family. Each participating elder either living in a personal residence, assisted living or home for the elderly will be paired with two Robinson High School students whose responsibility is to conduct one-on-one interviews to capture the elder's life history. The elder's story will get made into a printed, audio or video mini-biography that is provided to the person interviewed and family members.

Resources will include the Robinson mission statement, a Literature Review based on service learning references located at the end of this document, the PowerPoint software and the handout on results.

Prepare an information handout, checklist of visits, a report, PowerPoint presentation, and a professional development evaluation and feedback. Also, submit information handout, PowerPoint presentation, and professional development evaluation and feedback.

Theoretical Framework

Service learning is a practice that is highly acclaimed by researchers and educators as means to an ends to achieve school improvement (Seitsinger, 2005). The need for students to reach a high level of proficiency according to the established national benchmark that determines whether students are nationally capable. Even students doing well in according to these standards are not necessarily prepared to compete globally.

According to Seitsinger (2005), "Service-learning (SL) is among recommendations from educators for including real-world experiences in to students' education. The paucity of research and mixed findings on academic outcomes from K-12 SL led the author to examine opportunity-to-learn conditions and practices of 2,164 teachers in 271 middle schools involved in school improvement" (Seitsinger, 2005).

Seitsinger (2005) states, "Service-learning includes community service and goes further as an instructional strategy. The Alliance for Service-Learning in Education Reform (ASLER, 1993) definition of service-learning illustrates the complexity of this approach as a method of education, as well as the highly specific "operationalization" of the concept, at least as its proponents meant it to be applied" (Seitsinger, 2005).

Major league baseball via its Learn360 (Learn360, 2011) program enables K-12 students to view its service-learning content that covers core curriculum subjects necessary to develop the link between service activity subjects and core subjects. According to Learn360, "The partnership's goal is to create lifelong commitment to volunteerism through service-learning opportunities to high school students across North America" (Learn360, 2011).

Literature Review

Ren (2008) mentions, "A shared conceptualization of the term service-learning has helped with the issue of credibility. One significant difference between 1996 and today is the academic credibility associated with the practice of service-learning. This credibility has pushed the field to move beyond conceptual descriptions and anecdotal evidence to generate concrete outcomes through empirical studies" (Ren, 2008).

Additionally, according to Ren (2008), "Over the past decade, a large number of empirical articles have added to the literature on the measurable outcomes of service learning initiatives (Bringle et al., 2005). Engagement in service-learning projects has been shown to increase students' commitment to service (McCarthy and Tucker, 2002), preparedness for careers (Gray et al., 2000), personal growth, self-esteem, and personal efficacy (Primavera, 1999), communication skills, and social issue awareness (Leung et al., 2006), citizenship (Lester et al., 2005), and commitment to social justice and social change (Roschelle et al., 2000; Ren, 2008).

McLaughlin (2010) said, "Considerable growth in attention has been paid to community service and service-learning in the past 10 to 15 years (e.g. Lester, et al., 2005; Sullivan -- Catlin, 2002; Eyler & Giles, 1999; Hironimus-Wendt & Lovell-Troy, 1999; Rhoads, 1998; Jacoby, 1996; Kraft 1996). However, the bulk of this research is being done in grades K-12 and of general university populations. The perceived value of service-learning projects in schools of business remains largely undeveloped (Lester, Tomkovick, Wells, Flunker, and Kickul, 2005); hence, the need to focus on business schools in our service-learning research. The more we study service-learning, the more information we can pass along to achieve the greatest potential of positive outcomes from such projects" (McLaughlin, 2010).

According to Rose, Rose, & Norman (2005), "Research supports the benefits of incorporating community involvement projects in the curriculum at all levels, from K-12 to M.B.A. education. Advocates claim that service learning helps students develop skills in interpersonal relationships, teamwork, leadership, critical thinking, and communication, while acquiring better interpersonal relationships, teamwork, leadership, critical thinking, and communication, while acquiring better understandings of course content (Tucker and McCarthy 2001)" (Rose, Rose, Norman, 2005).

Govekar & Meenakshi (2007) mentioned, "Increasingly, experiential pedagogies have been hailing service learning as a means of linking formal classroom instruction with real-world learning that occurs beyond the classroom and involves the community (Godfrey, Illes, & Berry, 2005; Rama, Ravenscroft, Wolcott, & Zlotkowski, 2000; U.S. Department of Education, 1999). Although researchers have defined service learning variously in the literature, they have recognized service learning as an educational research approach that combines community service projects with credit bearing educational experience"(Govekar & Meenakshi, 2007).

According to Schmidt, Shumow, & Kackar, (2007), "This study investigates several questions about service activity among a nationally representative sample of U.S. high school students. First, what are the characteristics of adolescents who do service? Second, controlling or background factors related to service, does participation in service activities contribute to adolescents' academic adjustment, behavioral adjustment, and citizenship? Third, do the benefits of service differ depending on whether service was voluntary or required?" (Schmidt, Shumow, Kackar, 2007).

Schmidt, Shumov, Kackar, (2007) mentioned, "Several small studies and program evaluations on school-based service learning have highlighted the benefits of service activities for students' academic development. Such benefits include: improved grades and grade point averages (Follman 1998; O'Bannon 1999; Shumer 1994), higher test scores on state standardised tests (Akujobi and Simmons 1997; Morgan 2000), increased attendance (Follman 1998; O'Bannon 1999; Shumer 1994), academic interest (Stephens, 1995), school engagement (Melchior 1999), decreased dropout rates (Duckenfield and Swanson 1992), and stronger classroom task-engagement and skills (Stephens 1995). (Schmidt, Shumow, & Kackar, (2007).

One has to note that Schmidt, Shumow, & Kackar, (2007), "Most studies showing benefits of service have examined voluntary rather than required service. Evidence from some small local studies shows that many high school students engage in voluntary service (Hansen et al. 2003; McLellan and Youniss 2003), but few researchers have looked explicitly at required service. In a review article of school-based required service, Billig (2000) reported positive effects on personal/social development, civic responsibility, academic learning, career explorations and aspirations, atmosphere of the school and the community's perception of youth." (Schmidt, Shumow, & Kackar, 2007).

Implementation of the Project

Best practice activities in this impact project include the implementation of the service learning impact project,"Carrying On the Legacy of San Juan's Elders," student research and group application to the real-world issue of aging, history/social studies lesson plans, interpersonal communication and interviewing lesson plans, presentations, pre- and post-assessments regarding students' beliefs about the elderly, and reflections.

Differentiation is implemented into the lesson plans for students that will give them the opportunity to develop their own questions, and determine how they will record the interviews for presentations to the class and final products for the interviewee and family members.

Resources include the pre- and post-student evaluation measurements, community agencies and organizations, administration and staff members, families, and assisted living residents and homes for the elderly. The student pairs will visit the residences of the man or woman to be interviewed. They will prepare their written, audio or video materials/presentations in the classroom and at home. They will make final presentations in front of the classroom. A party will be held at the end of the service learning that will be attended by the students, people interviewed and family members.

Analysis

the student pre and post-evaluation measurements will reveal student beliefs and knowledge about the elderly. Post-presentation surveys of the agencies and residences involved, interviewees and family members will be conducted to determine the benefits derived from the intergenerational communication and interviews.

An analysis of the qualitative data will attempt to show catalytic authenticity, a stimulated change for the better (Lodico et al., 2006, p. 275), and transferability, whether the community assembly can be effective in other similar communities (Lodico et al., 2006, p. 275). The data will be coded into categories and organized into a thematic report.

The results will determine if the students have a better understanding of the elderly and a reduction in ageism false beliefs and stereotypes. The assessments will find if there has been personal growth, emotional understanding and cognitive growth as a result of the students' encounters with the elderly. It is hoped that the students will have a new level of awareness of what can be learned from the elderly based on their involvement with historical events and the challenges these individuals face as they become older members of society. One hopes that this will encourage the students to recognize the rewards of participating with and serving the elderly and decrease their hesitancies and fears of interacting with older individuals. This will empower them through the entire process. In fact, some may choose to work with them for the long-term by going into the medical field in the future.

Resources will include professional development feedback, student pre- and post- evaluation measures and feedback from elderly interviewees, family members, and elderly residences, The PowerPoint software and the school library will be utilized.

Findings

What one found is quite significant to this service learning experience. As the facilitator, this is what I discovered. My students greatly appreciated this experience because a select few are interested in going back as a volunteer to work with the elderly in the community. From the evaluation provided, many discussed their experience, and ironically, a lot of what was presented is positive. In fact, many want to do service projects at least once a year at Robinson High School. This demonstrates how much one did learn when taking part in this life-changing venture to become a better person for society.

When presenting the information found to the student body and staff. A PowerPoint presentation and accompanying handout will present results and recommendations to the stakeholders in the high school library. A final "closing" will get held with the final products, written materials, and audio and video presentations available for viewing. In the end, everyone will have a practical perspective on what was found and ways to apply it to their lives because of it.

Reflection and Conclusion

This document will detail the entire experience. I will provide my personal feelings and insights about the lesson plans, the professional development opportunity, the goals and objectives, the community need, student learning objectives, assessment data and challenges. I will detail what was learned, what was advantageous and what areas should be altered if this service learning project is recreated. I will make suggestions for similar impact activities as well. Future Discussions and Considerations

I hope to gain more people to attend these events in the future, and to strive to come up with creative ways in which to teach future students for "Elder Service Learning." One will discuss what to do in the future as well as future considerations for this particular project based off the feedback presented from the students, faculty and staff. Ultimately, people will learn from each other from the experience and become better people as a result which is worthwhile. Evaluation From the evaluation set forth by the students, faculty and staff of Robinson High School, this is what I learned from it. I will use more than one Nursing Home facility in the future in order to make sure that more than one staff is utilized and to prevent students from getting picked on from their peers. As a part of faculty, I will make sure that each student gets more of an opportunity to assist with the care of the elderly by reading them stories or talking to them when family is unable to visit. The students also suggested that they have an opportunity to sing to the elderly, so that they can make sure that they get the most out of the experience. I will strive harder to implement these things for my students in the years ahead.