Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
¶ … Strict Scrutiny Equal Protection Test be Applied?
Hall (2004) states that "Certain classifications are intrinsically suspect. . . And are subject to the strict scrutiny test" (p. 69). However, not everyone agrees with this statement. In the article 'court challenge filed to new driver's license rules,' for example, Minnesota is trying to enact rules that require stronger documentation for those that want to get driver's licenses and visa expiration dates on driver's licenses for immigrants (deFiebre, 2002). The argument against this is that a driver's license is simply that -- a document allowing the bearer to operate a motor vehicle on the streets of this country -- and therefore has nothing to do with immigration, either legal or illegal, and/or any other issues that relate to where someone comes from. In other words, some people believe that asking for this other information is discrimination at it's highest level.
After reading the article and examining what Hall has to say, it becomes apparent that the strict scrutiny equal protection test should be applied to this issue, since the potential discrimination that could take place against completely legal immigrants that have done nothing wrong must be weighed against the possibility of this stronger documentation helping to catch illegal immigrants and helping to stop some of the inherent problems that are often seen when it comes to individuals that are after fake driver's licenses for various reasons. It used to be that only young people wanting to buy alcohol were interested in fake driver's licenses, but now with terrorism and other problems on the rise there are many other reasons that individuals can find to obtain a driver's license in a name other than their own. Because of this, some 'discrimination' can be expected but it must be utilized very carefully so as not to cause more harm to the individuals that it singles out than the good that it creates for the society as a whole that it is trying to protect.
Bibliography
deFiebre, C. (2002). Court challenge filed to new driver's license rules. Star Tribune. Retrieved January 16, 2007, from http://www.jewishcommunityaction.org:80/organize/media.htm.
Hall, D.E. (2004). Administrative law. Bureaucracy in a democracy. 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. Upper Saddle River, NJ.
The petit theft of the second degree charge will stand as well. Larceny in old common law was classified as compound or simple. Simple larceny was called grand larceny when the value of the stolen property was more than 12 pence, and petit (petty) larceny when the value was less. Compound larceny was the taking and carrying away of property from the person or house of the owner. In
A third approach in this area is the establishment of new co-pay programs which force patients to bear the costs of more procedures and treatments. This theory tends to shift part of the blame for over treatment back on the patient. Doctors claim that they order additional treatments because their patients insist on them. Forcing patients to share a greater portion of the costs of these additional treatments should arguably
My overall advice to Mr. Smith would be that he has a weak case, at best. Question Two: To evaluate whether Susie has a valid equal protection claim, one must start by determining whether the city ordinance is a state action. As a city is a branch of the state, the smoking ordinance would be considered a state action. The next step is to determine whether she belongs to a suspect
Any trade that crosses state lines or involves citizens from different state is considered interstate commerce. The Commerce Clause was considered an important power in the original drafting of the Constitution due to the controversies that were created in trading relationships between the states under the Articles of Confederation. As the nation has increased in size and economic activity, the application of the Commerce Clause has become increasingly more
The main advantage of the convention is that they provide an opportunity for candidates to define themselves in a positive way and for the party to heal itself after a decisive nomination battle. 2. The electoral college is the means by which presidents are actually elected. To win a state's electoral votes, a candidate must have a plurality of votes in that state. Except in two states, the winner takes all. 3.
features of a major area of law. The second part of the scholarly paper presents a thorough review of an organizational problem based on the rules and regulations presented in the first part of the research paper. The reference page appends twelve sources in APA format. Equal Employment Opportunity and Anti-discrimination Laws The academic world as well as the world of profession and occupation offers uncountable options in the form of innumerable