Assessment methods for English language learner identification and placement
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Testing vs Alternative Forms of Assessment
Summary of "Testing vs. alternative forms of assessment"
Standardized tests, if used appropriately, can provide useful information about a non-native speaking student's skills and abilities. But such tests must not be used as the exclusive instrument to test a child's potential for success and need for academic remediation and support. Standardized tests provide incomplete and imperfect information because of ESL students' cultural as well as linguistic fluency (Law & Eckes 2007, p.23). Also, norming such tests is controversial, since by definition, half of the test takers 'have' to fall below the average (Law & Eckes 2007, p.23). Standardized tests also fail to give a complete portrait of the experiences of the test taker. Inadequate academic preparation, nervousness due to a lack of familiarity with the testing process, emotional distress in the new environment, as well as a smaller English vocabulary can all impact the child's score.
Testing vs. assessment is an important distinction to keep in mind. A test is simply a snapshot of a single point in time, and a one-dimensional portrait of a child's ability, often in a timed, formal, multiple-choice or fill-in-the-blank standardized format. Assessment is a much broader category of evaluation of a child's potential and abilities (Law & Eckes 2007, p.35). Alternative assessment is one solution to the problem of assessing ESL or special needs students.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.