Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,881 words

Gadamer's concept of faith and its epistemological illegitimacy

~10 min read
Abstract

This paper examines Hans-Georg Gadamer's conception of faith in order to determine the legitimacy of faith. Using David Hume's work on miracles as a guide, one can analyze Gadamer's claim in order to see if it holds up to scrutiny. Ultimately, it does not, because what Gadamer describes as faith, a "unique" phenomenon, is in reality merely a single flavor of the multifarious unfounded claims that can be found everywhere.

✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Essay 1,881 words

Faith

When Hans-Georg Gadamer argues that "the concept of faith, however, is uniquely suspended between a truth claim that lags behind knowing and a certainty that knowing lags behind," he is simultaneously making an ideological and epistemological claim, one that can, with a little effort, be refuted as illegitimate. This is because Gadamer proposes to regard faith a special category of human thought and proposition, when in reality it is merely belief in something without evidence to justify that belief. Through his particular formulation of faith, Gadamer attempts to imbue faith with a kind of epistemological legitimacy that disappears upon closer inspection. In particular, by considering Gadamer's claim alongside David Hume's consideration of miracles in his book an Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, it will become clear that Gadamer's claims about faith cannot hold up under scrutiny, and that faith is illegitimate as regards truth claims or a path to knowledge.

Before considering Gadamer's claims in regards to Hume, it will first be necessary to discuss precisely what Gadamer means when he argues that "the concept of faith, however, is uniquely suspended between a truth claim that lags behind knowing and a certainty that knowing lags behind." One may begin by taking note of the particular linear constructions he makes. He suggests that in this formulation, the progression is usually from truth claim, to knowing, to certainty, and immediately one may take exception with his formulation, because he is effectively mixing categories in such a way that his insertion of faith into this formula is in some ways meaningless. In effect, Gadamer has mixed two different modes of progression into a single unbroken line, and faith becomes the artificial conjunction unifying these two different modes.

On the one hand, Godamer is talking about the process of determining the validity of a truth claim. A truth claim progresses to knowing in the sense that one makes a truth claim, and then, having determined its veracity, "knows" whether or not its true, in the sense that all available evidence points one way or the other. On the other hand, Gadamer is talking about a different kind of progression between knowing and certainty, because in this regard certainty represents a kind of end-goal of knowing, in that the latter only ever asymptotically approaches the former due to the limits of human perception and cognition. Thus, the first pair represents a discrete process of activity with a beginning and an end, whereas the second pair represents an ongoing process of epistemological development. A truth claim lags behind knowing because a claim must be made prior to determining its veracity, such that one moves from truth claim to knowing, but knowing lags behind certainty in the sense that knowing is eternally pointing towards certainty without ever reaching it. Therefore, Godamer is essentially combining a diachronic process with a synchronic one while pretending that there are no differences between the two.

As one can see, Gadamer's construction is problematic even before he inserts faith into it, and when he does, he essentially inserts it into the place of knowing while nevertheless claiming that it is "uniquely suspended" in this space. This is a problem because as mentioned above, Gadamer's construction is nonsensical, in that his mixing of two different modes of progression renders the final formulation unintelligible. Nevertheless, one can at least attempt to describe what Godamer might have been intending with this construction, if only because it is clear that he has something to say about faith, even if he does so in a fundamentally flawed way.

1,212 Words Hidden
Godamer seems to suggest that faith is simultaneously a truth claim and a certainty, even though the former indicates an absence of evidence (as a…
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2012). Gadamer's concept of faith and its epistemological illegitimacy. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/faith-when-hans-georg-gadamer-argues-56937

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.