Verified Document

U.S. And European Jury Systems Term Paper

Reform from within the EU does not seem possible, either. It is so structured as to prevent changes in member states' minority status and other modifications from becoming attainable. Attempts by any government to amend the Community laws are considered doomed to failure, because Parliament has almost no part in European law-making (Andrews).

Conclusion

Common and civil law systems are inherently opposed, although their shared goal is to conduct a just, speedy and most inexpensive settling of conflicts (Messitte 1999). American courts have increasingly acknowledged the need to continuously evaluate and modify their processes and altogether improve the quality of justice. Efforts cover many other aspects of court activity, ranging from dispute resolution mechanisms, such as arbitration and mediation, to procedures, such as default and summary judgment used I the early stage of a trial without needing to proceed to a formal trial (Messitte).

Jury trial has disappeared in the English civil law since the Common Law Procedure Act of 1854 when communications improved with railroads and the telegraph. Now, the right to a jury trial is reserved for serious offenses, such as rape, assault and murder, and which explains why people in California pay $53 a year to support their court system as compared to only $23 paid by the British. This is only in addition to extended litigation costs (Adams).

Blue Ribbon Commission investigation conducted in 1996 reported on improvements on the jury system of California (Adams 2003), which...

One would reduce the number of jurors in civil trials, which would likewise reduce peremptory challenges and raise the pay to more than the current $5 a day.
It can make more sense to give the judge the lead role in examining witnesses and greater power in the evidentiary process so as to considerably decrease lawyers' effort and cost in exchange for increasing the judge's participation (Kotz 2003). This is one advantage European courts or civil law has over the American common law system. The latter can help the average individual by reforming current civil procedures by modifying the traditional system or by introducing and adopting alternative methods of resolving disputes as major steps to take (Kotz).

Bibliography

Adams, James, ed. The Jury Enigma. Court Management Observer, 2003. http://www.cmobs.com/editorial403.htm

Andrews, D. Freedom in Jeopardy. Freedom Central, 2004. http://www.freedom.central.net/euandbritain.html

Kotz, Hein. Civil Justice Systems in Europe and the United States. Duke Journal of Comparative and International Law, Special Issue, 2003. http://www.law.duke.edu/shell/cite.pl?13+Duke+j.+Comp+8+Int'l+L.061

Massitte, Peter J. Common Law vs. Civil Law Systems. United States Information Systems, 1999. http://usinfo.state.gov/journals/itdhr/0999/ijdc/messitte.htm

Nelson, Thomson. Introduction to Judicial Systems. Thomson Nelson Political Science Resource Center, 2004. http://polisci.nelson.com/introcourts.html

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Adams, James, ed. The Jury Enigma. Court Management Observer, 2003. http://www.cmobs.com/editorial403.htm

Andrews, D. Freedom in Jeopardy. Freedom Central, 2004. http://www.freedom.central.net/euandbritain.html

Kotz, Hein. Civil Justice Systems in Europe and the United States. Duke Journal of Comparative and International Law, Special Issue, 2003. http://www.law.duke.edu/shell/cite.pl?13+Duke+j.+Comp+8+Int'l+L.061

Massitte, Peter J. Common Law vs. Civil Law Systems. United States Information Systems, 1999. http://usinfo.state.gov/journals/itdhr/0999/ijdc/messitte.htm
Nelson, Thomson. Introduction to Judicial Systems. Thomson Nelson Political Science Resource Center, 2004. http://polisci.nelson.com/introcourts.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Privatization of America's Highway Infrastructure
Words: 3937 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

The highway system is an important part of the infrastructure that gives America a competitive advantage. Anything that threatens the highway system in the United States is a threat to the competitive advantage of America. These threats include a lack of funding. When one considers the current situation from this perspective, the importance of finding a solution to the problem of how to fund the highway system becomes one

Surgical Options for Post-Larengectomy Patients
Words: 2338 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

In situations where outcome or decision control is ceded to a legitimate decision-maker, the available legal procedure may be judged according to whether it provides adequate 'voice' for the aggrieved, adequate process control, and/or the satisfaction of being respected and afforded an appropriate level of procedural justice as a litigant, defendant or citizen. In any event, continued dialogue between lawyers and psychologists from both types of system is encouraging. To

Social Impact of Cold War & Terrorism
Words: 1772 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Social Impact of Cold War & Terrorism The Cold War is often associated with the idea of making great and physical divides between the good and the bad of the world. It was a symbolic representation that extended for about 30 years on the expectation that the greatest powers of the world could, under the right circumstances, impose a sort of benign order on the planet by isolating the evil empires

British Electoral System Reform Over
Words: 7210 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

The Constitution is based on several key principals the most notable would include: separation of powers as well as checks and balances. Separation of powers is when there are clearly defined powers that are given to the various branches of: the government, the federal government and the states. Checks and balances is when one branch of the government will have the power to the check the authority of another

Nursing Malpractice Introduction- Modern Nursing
Words: 4389 Length: 13 Document Type: Literature Review

The plaintiff, however, has a burden of proof prior to any other technical issues. In addition, because of the nature of the allegation, and the fact that normal members of a jury or judge cannot be expected to understand complext medical terms and procedures, expert witnesses are typically called -- usually for both sides (Uribe, 1999). In the United States, there have been several cases that have set international precedence

Equality of Arms in International
Words: 3446 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Historically, since the end of the Vietnam War in 1975, Cambodia has suffered under the oppression of dictators such as Pol Pot, who instituted Communism and its related rights violations of law. As a result, the question of the future of Cambodia has become vitally important and likewise, international law has had to step in to remedy the situation. Statutes and Charters from the United Nations Tribunals The evolution of international

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now