In this paper, we are going to be comparing Wal Mart's business environment with Costco and Target. This will be accomplished by focusing on the company's financial information, what was learned, how this can be used by management, the firm's financial health, the effects of globalization, conducting a benchmark, best practices, operational and products analysis. Once this takes place, is when we will show the long term effects of Wal Mart's strategy on the company and its competitors.
Wal Mart's Business Environment
When most people think of Wal Mart, they will often associate it with the various stores around the globe. This has helped the company to establish a major presence inside the retail marketplace. However, the challenges with the economy and competitive pressures have been impacting the business environment of the firm. To fully understand what is taking place there will be a focus on: the company's financial information, what was learned, how this can be used by management, the firm's financial health, the effects of globalization, examining benchmarks, the best practices, operational and products analysis. Together, these different elements will highlight the strengths and weaknesses of the firm. ("2012 Annual Report," 2012)
Review Wal Mart's income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow to determine the financial health of the company.
Wal Mart is in a strong financial position in contrast with their top competitors. The company has more revenues, cash, debt and free cash flow. Evidence of this can be seen by looking at the below table which is highlighting their fiscal position in comparison with Costco and Target.
Wal Mart's Pecuniary Position vs. Costco and Target
Company
Revenues
Cash Position
Debt
Operating Cash Flow
Wal Mart
$464.41 billion
$8.64 billion
$57.46 billion
$27.25 billion
Costco
$99.14 billion
$4.58 billion
$1.56 billion
$3.06 billion
Target
$71.86 billion
$1.47 billion
$18.55 billion
$5.81 billion
("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
These figures are showing how Wal Mart is in a much stronger financial position in comparison with Costco and Target.
What have I learned about the Wal Mart by reviewing each statement?
After reviewing each financial statement, it is clear that Wal Mart is many times stronger than Costco and Target. This is because the company has more stores; they are focused on decreasing their operating costs and improving their revenues / cash position. The combination of these factors is helping Wal Mart to maintain and increase its dominance among the discount retailers. Over the course of time, this helps the firm to be able to adapt with changes in the economy and consumer demand. In many ways, one could argue that this allows them to remain competitive and address a host of challenges they are facing. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
Is there information in any of these documents that is of a concern? If so, describe what it is and what it concerns.
The biggest concern is that Costco and Target are continuing to open retail locations. This is troubling, as these kinds of challenges will have an adverse impact on the costs and bottom line results of these firms. The reason why is from the economy facing tremendous difficulties with stagnant consumer spending and increasing costs in energy prices. The combination of these factors is creating a situation where these two companies could disappoint investors by engaging in overly aggressive activities. Moreover, they are opening in areas where Wal Mart has at least one of their retail locations or Sam's Club wholesale stores. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
Evidence of this can be seen with Costco saying, "In the run-up to this year's holiday season, we also opened six new units in the following communities: Bucks County, Pennsylvania; Frisco, Texas; Pewaukee, Wisconsin; Augusta, Georgia; Yawata Kyoto and Zama, Japan. We have been actively reviewing potential sites and securing new properties during the economic downturn and have many promising locations to be developed over the next few years. And we are evaluating additional countries to help realize our goal of 1,000 warehouses in operation by the next 10 to 12 years." This is showing how Costco is trying to take market share from Wal Mart by going into locations where they are the most dominate. ("Annual Report," 2011)
These areas are problematic, as this could place pressure on Costco and Target to maintain a low price structure in contrast with Wal Mart. Yet, they are unable to follow the same kind of model and will feel squeezed from Wal Mart's aggressive marketing strategies. When this happens, there is the possibility of an increase in the underlying amounts of debt. While at the same time, their revenues from these locations will become stagnant. As a result, both firms should selectively focus on enhancing sales at existing retail locations and revamping their supply chain. If this were to occur, both companies can more effectively address challenges from Wal Mart and their lowest price guarantees. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
How can management use this information moving forward?
Management can use this information to help determine locations where Wal Mart may not be as dominate in specific areas. Furthermore, both firms could engage in activities that will reduce their costs for energy, logistics and operating margins. In the future, this will allow these firms to become more competitive moving forward. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
At the same time, Target and Costco can focus on those products that Wal Mart may not be carrying inside their stores. This is because the company has been adjusting with increasing amounts of competition by altering the product lines and reducing the number of items they are carrying. If Target and Costco can use a similar strategy, they will reduce their costs and increase their profits (by concentrating on those product / services that customers are demanding). ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
Summarize Wal Mart's financial health. How does it compare to other companies in the industry?
Wal Mart is a strong company from a financial standpoint. This is because the firm is actively involved in keeping their energy costs lows, competing against other organizations and continually expanding their total number of stores. This has allowed the company to quickly adapt with new changes and increase their bottom line results. ("2012 Annual Report," 2012)
Moreover, the company is focused on aggressively expanding their dominance in the area of e-commerce. These factors are helping the firm to increase its overall bottom line numbers while controlling costs. Evidence of this can be seen with Wal Mart saying, "We leveraged operating expenses in fiscal 2012 and 2011. In fiscal 2012, our operating expenses increased 4.8% compared to fiscal 2011, while net sales increased 5.9% in fiscal 2012 compared to fiscal 2011. Operating expenses grew at a slower rate than net sales due to our continued focus on expense management. Our Global ecommerce initiatives contributed to the majority of the increase in operating expenses, as we continue to invest in our e-commerce platforms." These factors are helping Wal Mart to have a competitive advantage over Costco and Target. ("2012 Annual Report," 2012)
As a result, this is allowing Wal Mart to dominate the marketplace. A good example of this can be seen by contrasting sales for the last three years at these firms.
Total Sales for Wal Mart, Costco and Target from 2009 to 2011
Company
2009
2010
2011
Wal Mart
$405.13 billion
$418.95 billion
$443.85 billion
Costco
$69.88 billion
$76.25 billion
$87.04 billion
Target
$63.35 billion
$65.78 billion
$68.46 billion
("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
These figures are showing how Wal Mart's strategy has allowed them to increase their total sales and dominance inside the sector.
Moreover, the firm has lower amounts of debt in comparison with the overall revenues that are being generated. The below table is illustrating how Wal Mart is in a stronger financial position in comparison with Costco and Target.
Wal Mart's Revenues / Debt in Contrast with Costco and Target
Company
Revenues
Debt
Wal Mart
$464.41 billion
$57.46 billion
Costco
$99.14 billion
$1.56 billion
Target
$71.86 billion
$18.55 billion
("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
These figures are showing how Wal Mart has more revenues and higher amounts of debt on a percentage basis. Yet, these numbers are so large that the company has been able to continue with its rapid expansion. This is giving executives the leverage to enhance existing stores, build new locations and to reach out to customers online.
Include a summary of Wal Mart's technologies advantages, or lack thereof, in comparison to at least two other companies in the same industry
Technology is one of the biggest advantages that Wal Mart has going for it. This is because the company will use these solutions to reach out to customers, improve inventory controls and to manage costs. What is happening is technology is an integral part of the firm's strategy. In many cases, this involves using e-commerce to reach out to cliental in addressing their needs. This is utilized in conjunction with helping to support the options they are providing to everyone. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
At the same time, technology is utilized to determine when a store is running out of particular items. This allows the company to send new products from the warehouse (which is located regionally). During this process, is when the firm will reduce their costs by having trucks supplied with merchandise that is going to various locations within the area. This helps Wal Mart to maintain price controls and limit the impact of commodities on their bottom line results. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
While Costco and Target, will use similar models to a certain extent. In the case of Costco, they are installing energy efficient meters that will control usage and have installed alternative power sources (such as solar cells). This helps the company to keep their costs low for operating each location. At the same time, they are utilizing supply chain management to quickly resupply various stores. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
Whereas Target, will use these tools to reach out to customers (through e-commerce solutions). They will also have these tools help to improve their ability to restock locations. The only difference between these firms and Wal Mart; is they are using these solutions on a limited basis and have taken a narrower focus. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
Describe how globalization has affected the company's business strategies.
Globalization has been affecting all of these firms. This is because they are rapidly expanding into higher growth markets overseas. These transformations are helping to diversity their earnings and increase their growth rates. This is allowing all of these companies to improve their revenues and dominance in particular segments of these markets. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
Conduct a benchmarking analysis.
To determine the underlying strengths and weaknesses of the various companies requires conducting a benchmark analysis. This will be accomplished by looking at: the best practices, operational procedures and products / services. These elements will highlight how the business model and strategies are helping Wal Mart's operating results.
The Best Practices
The best practices that are used by Wal Mart are helping the firm to control costs, adapt with changes in customer demand and to increase their bottom line results. This is taking place with the company implementing procedures that will enhance their ability to attract customers. For instance, the firm has been utilizing a model that is designed to reduce labor expenses and increase productivity. The way that this is achieved is to pay employees minimum wage and have their warehouses quickly responding to the needs of stores. This ensures that there are tremendous supplies located within close proximity to various outlets. At the same time, Wal Mart will adjust their marketing strategy and what products are carried in the store based upon customer demand. Recently, the firm announced that they are going to be open on Thanksgiving night. This is designed to reach out to customers who want to receive early deals prior to the official opening of Black Friday. These areas are showing how this flexibility helps the firm to offer more solutions. ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011) ("Wal Mart Black Friday," 2012)
When this is compared with Costco and Target, they are using certain elements to reduce their operating costs. Yet, in the case of marketing and promotions, these firms are often lagging behind Wal Mart. This is because they are more reactionary and want to see how customers behave based upon testing certain strategies. Over the course of time, this helps to keep them competitive. But, it does not allow them to be as dominate as Wal Mart (in contrast with meeting the needs of customers and offering innovative solutions). ("2011 Annual Report," 2011) ("2012 Annual Report," 2012) ("Annual Report," 2011)
You’re 83% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.