Achilles' choice between love and eternal glory in the Iliad
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Greek and Roman Mythology
Achilles rejects the embassy when they offer him a truce together with treasures. For him the love of Briseis as well as personal honor are more important than the rewards offered by a man he despises. The options that are left for Achilles is either fighting and dying, which will result in lasting honor or leaving for Greece and making a life with Briseis. This is a difficult choice, because lasting glory would mean lasting life, even after physical death. Achilles appears to attach great importance to this when he enters the battlefield, but when he meets Briseis, it appears that his love is gaining the upper hand.
Personally, I believe that living a long and full life on earth would have been the better choice. It is difficult enough as it is to find a lasting and fulfilling love as he has with Briseis. Obviously Achilles' heart lies in this direction, and I think he would have been ultimately happier and more fulfilled with this option.
Choosing battle, death and everlasting glory as he did can perhaps be understood from the viewpoint of the time.
I do not however believe that this was a wise choice, because being physically dead would preclude Achilles from experiencing any of the glory he so highly prized. In other words, he would not at all even be aware of the glory that subsequent generations would ascribe to him for his conquests.
With Briseis on the other hand he would have had a family to love him until his dying day. As it was, Achilles died soon and violently, knowing the love of his girl for only a limited time. In my view this is somewhat self-defeating. It is better to live long and be loved while alive than to be remembered for thousands of years after death. This is so because the former includes awareness. Achilles would have been happy and aware of the love within which he was living.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.