This paper examines Max Weber's foundational argument in The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, which links the economic rise of Western Europe and the United States to the spread of Protestantism beginning in the eighteenth century. The paper traces Weber's analysis of Luther's concept of the "calling" (Beruf), his use of Benjamin Franklin's writings as evidence of a religiously motivated work ethic, and his broader claim that Protestant reformism created the cultural conditions necessary for capitalist development. The paper also contrasts Weber's position with that of Karl Marx, who viewed religion as a product of human activity and an obstacle to material progress rather than its catalyst.
The German economist and sociologist Max Weber developed a series of theories based on the idea that religion — particularly Protestantism — is the source of economic growth beginning in the eighteenth century in many Western countries. The economies of Western Europe and the United States took an unprecedented leap, not only compared to economic growth before the eighteenth century, but also compared to the rest of the world. This era of rapid and positive economic development coincides with the rise of Protestantism in these countries.
His book, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, develops and explains his theory through a study of Protestantism versus other religions, especially in comparison with Catholicism. Weber's vision of how capitalism was influenced and sustained by the Reformation — as the generator of Protestantism — is grounded in its contradiction with Catholic dogma, which relies on the rejection of everything worldly.
In Chapter Three of his book, entitled "Luther's Conception of the Calling," Weber uses a key word in the Reformation that first appeared in Luther's Bible translation: "the calling," or Beruf in German. Weber writes in the opening of this chapter: "Now it is unmistakable that even in the German word Beruf, and perhaps still more clearly in the English calling, a religious conception, that of a task set by God, is at least suggested."
Further in his analysis of the concept of calling — first identified in the Bible by Luther — Weber continues that "the valuation of the fulfillment of duty in worldly affairs as the highest form which the moral activity of the individual could assume. This it was which inevitably gave every-day worldly activity a religious significance, and which first created the conception of a calling in this sense." Weber thus finds a logical explanation of "worldly activity," as he calls it, from the Protestant religious point of view. The concept of the religious calling becomes, in Weber's framework, the theological foundation upon which a disciplined, productive work ethic is built.
"Franklin's writings as evidence of Protestant work ethic"
"Contrasting Weber and Marx on religion's economic role"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.