Argument Against Portuguese New World Involvement Essay

PAGES
3
WORDS
1065
Cite

Men Folly

The work of Restall covers a lot of ground when it comes to classic literature. One of the approaches and treatments that is common in such literature is the concept of "great men." Of course, the topic is a bit silly and under-informed nowadays. This brief essay will cover why precisely this is the case and it will use Restall's work in Seven Myths as the main sources of analysis to make that case. While the use of "great men" in classic literature is to be expected and customary, an obvious modern case can and should be made against the general concept and how what supposedly made men like Cortes and Columbus "great" was actually regular and normal behavior for the time and the positions of power that those "great men" held.

Analysis



Restall makes prescient and honest points about men like Columbus and Cortes. Beyond the fact that many people of that time are still treated as heroes and worthy of the holidays that are assigned in their honor (e.g. Columbus), what they actually did was not all that abnormal and what they did was not all that different than what others in similar positions made. Indeed, Columbus is hailed as being the one that "discovered" the Americas even though there is clear evidence that there were aborigine peoples in the Caribbean and Americas upon his arrival and what he did in response to this discovery was commissioned and requested by the crown that sent him. Also mentioned by Restall is the...
...

Two other names that come up when speaking of the great men myth are Cortes and Pizarro. Of course, Cortes was a conquistador from Spain that was leading the expedition that eventually led to the fall of the Aztec empire. Francisco Pizarro, on the other hand, was similar in that he led the similar effort that led to the fall of the Incas. In the case of all three men, they were indeed among the first to do what they did at the level of what was completed. However, to suggest that their behavior was unexpected or undesirable would be incorrect. At the same time, to suggest that what they did was anything "exceptional" for that day and time is also not the case. As history has proven, at that time and since, it was a common practice of the Spanish and the Portuguese (not to mention the British and the French) to conquer all of the people and lands of the Earth so as to bring them under control of their commissioning country and/or crown (Restall, 2003).
As for specific words and phrases that Restall uses, there are many. Indeed, the mission and commission of the men above was to conquer and control. Restall quotes Francisco Lopez de Gomara as saying "the Conquest of Mexico and the conversion of the peoples of New Spain can and should be included with the histories of the world, not only because it was well done but because it was very great" (Restall, 2003, p. 1). The "great" quip notwithstanding, this is an accurate and blunt…

Cite this Document:

"Argument Against Portuguese New World Involvement" (2016, September 06) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/argument-against-portuguese-new-world-involvement-essay-2167459

"Argument Against Portuguese New World Involvement" 06 September 2016. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/argument-against-portuguese-new-world-involvement-essay-2167459>

"Argument Against Portuguese New World Involvement", 06 September 2016, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/argument-against-portuguese-new-world-involvement-essay-2167459

Related Documents

Balance of Power Help Us to Understand the Origins of World War I? The origins of the first world war of the 20th century are now a matter of historical record, but even prior to the outbreak of hostilities in 1918, most observers in a position of authority readily recognized that it was not a question of whether there would be a war, but rather of when and where it

Slave Trade in and Between
PAGES 7 WORDS 2106

Discussion The focus of this work has been to answer the questions of: (1) How was the slave trade practiced in Europe and Africa before 1550, in comparison to the slave trade in and between the two regions after 1550?' And (2) 'What were the main differences between the two periods in terms of their origins, motivations and effects on African society?' These two time periods, before 1550 and after 1550 have

Slave trade of Indians and blacks began with Columbus but the overall slave trade was much worse and lasted later in history in Brazil Summary of slave trade in Brazil Quick Facts about Slave Trade in Brazil Firm connections with slavery in highlands People involved included Portugese, Luso Brazilians and the slaves themselves Like Columbus, killing and enslavement of indigenous peoples was common Some slaves escaped and hid in mocambos and quilombos Renegade Indians and escaped slaves

To critically investigate the current state of international business relationship development literature. 2. To explore the characteristics that determines sustainable international business relationships within the Libyan business context-from the Libyan point-of-view. 3. To present a model based on the findings from the two objectives above. This model will serve two main functions: (I). It will help fill in gaps in the current literature relating to the development and maintenance of business

The milestone that the Civil Rights Movement made as concerns the property ownership is encapsulated in the Civil Rights Act of 1968 which is also more commonly referred to as the Fair Housing Act, or as CRA '68. This was as a follow-up or reaffirmation of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, discussed above. It is apparent that the Civil Rights Act of 1866 outlawed discrimination in property and housing there

Reconstruction of Iraq
PAGES 3 WORDS 972

Iraq Reconstruction Reconstruction of Iraq: UN or U.S. Responsibility? Three years ago, the world had witnessed two significant events that determined the fate of two of the most powerful nations in the world: the World Trade Center bombing in United States, and, consequently, the U.S. offensive against Iraq in March 2002 (Gulf War II). These events have eventually led to the oust of Saddam Hussein, incumbent dictator/leader of Iraq and the temporary