Verified Document

Fundamentalism And Evolution At The Scopes Trial Essay

Related Topics:

Trial?

The Scopes "Monkey Trial" was less about a teacher's violation of an arcane Southern law regarding the teaching of evolution in the classroom and more about the place of Christian culture, doctrine and ethics in the modern world. The trial came down to William Jennings Bryan (who had run for president a quarter century earlier) on the side of Christian culture and the atheist Clarence Darrow as Bryan's political, social and cultural antagonist. While ostensibly there to prosecute and defend John Scopes respectively, the spectacle that the trial quickly became revealed the underlying purpose of the courtroom scene: like the trials at Nuremberg that would come a quarter century later, Scopes was a "show trial," the real meaning of which was a "showdown" between the Old World ideology and the New -- or, in other words, the extent to which the Christian religion had a place in modern America.

As Thomas Dixon points out, "Bryan was a defender of the newly formed movement for Christian 'fundamentalism'" (86). Bryan set himself up as the spokesman for the Old World ideology -- the fundamental tenets of Christian culture and beliefs, based on the teachings of the Bible. The Scopes Trial was of interest to Bryan because, being a famous public speaker (mostly remembered today for his "Cross of Gold" speech in the 1896 presidential race), he saw the opportunity to pit Fundamentalism against Atheism -- which in his view (and the view of his followers) was the most pressing threat to American health, wealth and well-being. Bryan decried anything that attempted to reduce humanity to the level of the ape and cited the textbook used by Scopes at the school where taught evolution, describing it as a tool to "shut up" mankind "in the little circle entitled 'Mammals', with thirty-four hundred and ninety-nine other species" (Dixon 86). Bryan's rhetoric was inflammatory and provocative...
For Bryan, life without Faith was untenable -- and teaching such a life to school children was an act of corruption that should never be allowed. The question of the origin of the human existence was a stage -- a platform -- from which Bryan could pronounce the merits of Fundamentalist Christianity: it was his pulpit, and like any good preacher he seized the opportunity to preach to the masses, in the spotlight, debating the eternal opponents of God (represented in the Trial by Darrow). It was a stage that transcended the mere local matter of Scopes teaching evolution (against the law in Tennessee): the debate between evolution and Creationism was symbolic of the larger struggle between the forces of Good (Christian Fundamentalism) and the forces of evil (atheism).
This is not to say that proponents of Creationism or of evolution are good or evil in and of themselves -- and that was not really the question at the Trial. It was, in effect, a trial of ideas -- not of people. Certainly, John Scopes was on trial and was found guilty of teaching evolution -- but he himself was ultimately incidental to the much grander vision unfolding in the courtroom. It was a contest between two visions of the world, of life, of the meaning and purpose of life. And while Bryan could characterize atheism as an evil in and of itself because it lacked awareness of God, or could characterize evolution as anti-Christian and therefore evil in and of itself, the men who supported these positions were not ones who could, according to the very same Christian ethic espoused by Bryan, be judged. After all, according to the tenets of Christianity, men are not meant to judge others, for judgment is reserved for God alone: He is the only one with the capacity to see into the minds and hearts of men and judge them accordingly. It is Augustine…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Trial One of the Most
Words: 2171 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

In 2005, a Federal Judge in Georgia ruled that any sticker or notice violated the separation of Church and state, "Due to the manner in which the sticker refers to evolution as a theory, the sticker also has the effect of undermining evolution eduction. . . The distinction of evolution as a theory rather than a fact is the distinction that religiously motivated individuals have specifically asked school boards

American Religious History Defining Fundamentalism and Liberalism
Words: 2705 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

American Religious History Defining fundamentalism and liberalism in Christianity is hardly an exact science, especially because prior to about 1920 there was not even a term for fundamentalism as it exists today. While present-day fundamentalists often claim descent from the Puritans and Calvinists of the 17th and 18th Centuries, Puritans were not really fundamentalists in the modern sense. They were not in conflict with 20th Century-style liberals and supporters of evolution

Schulman & Dumenil Comparison/Contrast of
Words: 2015 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Schulman illustrates this by reference to Bob Dylan's lyrics, whose images (such as Isis) evoke the spiritual quests of the New Age mysticism and whose outlaw heroes voice an angry suspicion again established institutional authority (Schulman, 147). The same hostility to mainstream values was repeated in iconoclastic directors such as Cassavetes and Scorsese. One sees as well that the 1970s critiques of religion were not based on evolutionary science

Sociology: Changing Societies in a Diverse World
Words: 9606 Length: 30 Document Type: Book Report

Sociology: Changing Societies in a Diverse World (Fourth Edition) George J. Bryjak & Michael P. Soroka Chapter One Summary of Key Concepts Sociology is the field of study which seeks to "describe, explain, and predict human social patterns" from a scientific perspective. And though Sociology is part of the social sciences (such as psychology and anthropology), it is quite set apart from the other disciplines in social science; that is because it emphasizes

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now