This paper analyzes the 2006 film A Scanner Darkly through the lens of sociological deviance theory. Drawing on cultural-transmission theory, Robert Merton's strain theory, social control theory, and concepts of elite deviance, the paper examines how key characters — including the undercover Officer Fred/Bob Arctor and his associate — embody different levels and types of deviant behavior. Additional topics include the role of anonymity in facilitating deviance, the real-world parallels of the fictional New Path corporation, and the moral implications of individual self-control in resisting deviant norms. The paper concludes that personal standards and community investment, as illustrated by the contrasting outcomes of the two protagonists, are central to understanding conformity and deviance.
In accordance with cultural-transmission theory, deviance is a behavior that is learned through interaction with others. Individuals learn from those who participate in deviant norms and who display deviant values. The female protagonist largely represents entry-level deviance in the sense that she associates with cocaine and Substance D addicts without altering her own behavior. Moreover, she acts as a supplier of Substance D, yet at the conclusion of the film she becomes a police officer intent on dismantling the operations of New Path. The manner in which law enforcement follows a chain of evidence from low-level deviants — such as this character — is through direct daily supervision, since numerous opportunities for deviance can present themselves to such individuals. This approach ensures that the evidence gathered remains valid and admissible.
Away from his undercover work, Bob Arctor's real identity in the film is revealed as Special Agent Fred. Officer Fred plays an everyman role in A Scanner Darkly (2006). According to Calhoun and Coyers (2013), this dynamic relates directly to the concept of deviance — specifically what they term elite deviance. Calhoun and Coyers (2013: 174) note that an individual may perceive his or her own offending behavior as either criminal or non-criminal. Officer Fred perceived his offending behavior as non-criminal on the grounds that he had not physically harmed anyone through his activities. Furthermore, he considered his offences distinct from ordinary crimes because working as an undercover officer was legal and he was simply fulfilling his professional duties. This rationalization is evident in his deviant acts of becoming addicted to Substance D and pursuing a romantic relationship with the woman he was assigned to surveil — both of which directly conflicted with his professional obligations.
In the film, Substance D produces dementia or a split-brain disconnection that causes a progressively fragmented, disjointed, and illogical self-consciousness. It effectively causes a separation between cognition and perception, with the two faculties battling for control of the individual. This reflects the reality that some awareness has cognitive elements, and some cognition has perceptual elements. The resulting instability of individual identity, and the increasingly desperate struggle to maintain coherence, mirrors the dysfunction of society itself. This dynamic relates to one element of Robert Merton's strain theory. According to this theory, strain can be individual in nature, referring to the resistances and difficulties a person encounters when attempting to satisfy personal needs (Boundless, 2015).
Bob Arctor embodies the duality between good and evil in several ways throughout the film. First, his undercover work has led him to become addicted to Substance D, and he spends his days intoxicated alongside his roommates. Second, Arctor has befriended the very woman he is tasked with surveilling — a woman who is not only a cocaine addict but also a supplier of Substance D. Third, Arctor's objective is to purchase a large quantity of Substance D from her so that she will introduce him to her drug supplier. The complicating twist is that Arctor has simultaneously developed genuine, outwardly unrequited romantic feelings toward her, creating a profound tension between his professional mission and his personal attachments.
"Arctor's conflicting roles and moral tensions"
"How anonymity and the internet enable deviance"
"New Path as symbol of exploitative institutions"
"Self-control and community investment prevent deviance"
You’re 47% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 4 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.